Is the supreme court judgement applies to city municipal corp too

rp shahi (Querist) 01 June 2017 This query is : Resolved
In a Civil appeal NO: 1132/2011 @SPL(C) No:3109/2011 arising out of special leave petition ( Civil) CC no. 19869 of 2010 : Jagpal Singh & Ors v/s state of Punjab , Justice Markande Katju has clearly mentioned that in no circumstances village Punchayat land, ponds, open areas can be vested to state for any other use.

Can this directive of judgement be used for Citi council or municipal corporations/ urban development dept , too which is my place Ranchi is capturing and destroying all ponds, parks or any open space.

Follow Query

Report Abuse

Guest (Expert) 01 June 2017
Any Judgement Of courts could be treated as Citation.

Guest (Expert) 01 June 2017
It is up to the concerned Authorities to decide

Guest (Expert) 01 June 2017
Other wise you have to file A suit in Concerned Court

Guest (Expert) 01 June 2017
The Supreme Court Judgement referred by you could be filed as Citation in your Case

Guest (Expert) 01 June 2017
The Concerned Court would certainly consider your Citation filed

Guest (Expert) 01 June 2017
Discuss with A Local Good Senior Advocate

rp shahi (Querist) 01 June 2017
The question is whether order in reference to village land would hold good for city land and council too?

Guest (Expert) 01 June 2017
when the Subject and Related Issues are same certainly it would be applicable as Citation of Similar Issue

Rajendra K Goyal (Expert) 01 June 2017
No material facts given.

Please discuss with local lawyer.

Decision can be followed if the material facts are similar or similar law point is involved.