gururaja
19 November 2013 at 17:51
My sister got married 6 years back and have one child. They have so many familiy issues. Every time my sister is blaming her husband and he is blaming my sister. He is blaming that my sister threatening him to commit suicide. She is very afraid that he will leave her. Every time we console them and for sometime there will not be issues. Then again it comes. My sister is saying that her husband dislike us coming to their home and interfering in their life. But he is saying that my sister is abusing him , his parents and sisters. Some time back, our father expired and we partition the property. That time also, we got issues. One big wrong my sister did is she came to our house without informing him. So he filed conjugal right case. After that, sister attended the case and she went with her husband. Our father's death effected her a lot and she is not able to tolerate the separation. Also, we are not talking with her. In this depression, she tried to commit suicide also. Then we showed her to doctor and they told that she have Paranoid schizophrenia. She was under treatment for last 10 months. What happened, we dont know, she stopped medicine and he is complaining that she is acting very violent. He admitted her in hospital. They told that she is suffereing from Borderline Behaviour disorder. Now she is with us. We are afraid that her husband will file any case on medical basis. Pl do advise us what to do. But she wants to leave with him. If he does, can we file any dowry case against him or his family?In this, my sister's son is effected most.
Rakesh Malik
19 November 2013 at 13:01
If someone make a compliant in which he provides address where he/she do not resides. I mean a person is staying at address x and in complaint mentioned address is y. Is that complaint legal. Is it offence providing wrong address to police. If yes, under which act of IPC.
Rakesh Malik
19 November 2013 at 12:59
If someone make a compliant in which he provides address where he/she do not resides. I mean a person is staying at address x and resides at address y. Is that complaint legal. Is it offence providing wrong address to police. If yes, under which act of IPC.
Sanjiv Malhotra
19 November 2013 at 12:06
My father in law has been living with us ( i.e his daughter and me (son-in-law))since the last 2 1/2 years as his son and daughter in law have shown utter disregard to his well being. my mother in law expired intestate in 2009. the son holds 16 % undivided share in my father in laws flat and my wife holds 16 % and my father in law 66 %. the flat was bought by self aquired funds by my father in law and his son has 0 Rs contribution to it. That being the matter i want to know the process of disinheritance as my father in law is very disturbed that his son and D in law havnt bothered to even call him ONCE or even meet him ONCe in the last 2 1/2 years. they are absolutely not bothered whether he lives or dies. Just the other day my father in law rang up his son and said he would like to meet him, and his son flatly refused to meet him or acknowledge him !! i would like to bring to the fact that we are in the process of filing suit of maintenance U/s 125 of the IPC against him ( the son ).Does this not amount the cruelty and indifference by the son towards his 82 year old father ? are they not laws that protect the rights of senior citizens against this absolute uncareing and indifferent attitude. I mean not even one phone call or visitinquiring about his health etc... not even one!! kindly advise. Thank you
Geeta
19 November 2013 at 11:36
I have filed dv asking for shared household /matrimonial home had submitted the sale deed of the house which even today belongs to my husband .however he has stated that he had sold the house and is residing in a rented house .i have never resided in the rented house and doubt that even he is staying there.i had submitted the sale deed in my petition updated till sep and he says he sold it in aug.does court consider he sole statement only which is completely false ?what should I be doing now?
maitri
19 November 2013 at 02:29
Hi,
My brother had an old lady as a cook from beginning of his career. After his marriage same cook continued to come to cook for him and his family( Wife , Son ). This cook gave her daughter-N-Law as her substitute for this job as a cook when it was difficult for this old lady to cook anymore. After few months, this old lady passed away. This new cook remained as my brother's family cook for last 9 years. When my sister-N-law filed a 498 case against all of us( my brother, mother and 4 sisters), she made the cook as one of her witnesses. My sister-n-law is a big liar and blaming us for all such criminal acts about which we can't even think of. I am ready to go for lie-detecting test if it is required to prove our innocence. After getting bail, as per Lawyer's advice my brother started staying with his wife. But it was impossible for my brother to agree to his wife's demand to sign an agreement to close the case. So after 2 months he decided to leave his bungalow and stay outside wherever he can arrange his accommodation. He also went to his cook's home to tell her that he no more need her service as a cook. When he went to her home, he was shocked to know that cook has not told anyone in her family ( including her husband) about her involvement in this 498 case as a witnesses. Now my brother's wife is making big issue out of this and she is demanding my brother to request the same cook to go to his bungalow for cooking where only his wife and 2 kids live. My brother is going to stay elsewhere and have his meal in restaurants or mess.
My questions are - Did my brother commit a mistake by asking cook not to come for cooking anymore? Should he fall for his wife's demand and request that cook to go for cooking for his wife and kids? His wife is a well settled doctor. Can't my brother ask his wife to take care of the cooking/meal problem by herself? Either she can cook or hire a new cook! Can my liar sister-N-law put my brother in trouble again for visiting cook's home and firing that cook from job?
AROKIASWAMY
18 November 2013 at 22:49
DEAR SIR
this case from Tamilnadu .one christian father having property by self acquired one . he died intestate leaving his wife and 3 sons and 3 daughters. how their father property will divide among them ?Give legal advice
Vijay
18 November 2013 at 18:56
we got married 5 months back, as my wife is always blaming lie on myself(we dont get even single paise of dowry) and during marriage she lived me with only for 15 days happily after that she went for higher studies and not showing interest to pick a house in the place to leave a life even in the weekend where she is staying(am working in another city) and not showing interest to come to my home even in her vacation, when enquired in their home also their parents not showing interest to send her with me, so when filing RCR, can i ask police or court to ask their herself and her mother to undergo psychatric test(like lie detector test???) so that we can come to know the truth from their mouth itself(what and all they have thinked criminally) is it possible in indian laws?
Mrunmai Deshpande
17 November 2013 at 19:42
I am a woman of 65 years of age staying with my son and daughter in law. My daughter in law deserted my son 3 years ago, staying with her parents, working there and earning a salary of Rs12000/- pm. My bahu, when staying with us always carried a campaign against me, making false allegations, maligning me in the eyes of my son, threatening me of committing suicide. Even she wrote note making false allegation against me and threatening of suicide and then deserted my son 3 years ago. I immediately wrote a detailed letter to her parents refuting all allegations and informing them about the suicide threat. I had sent the letter by Registered A/D and preserved the acknowledgement. This was 3 years ago. Had it been true, she would have definitely lodged a police complaint then as she had full protection of her parents. She did not do so. Now when my son informed her that he wants divorce under desertion and cruelty she said she would contest it and lodge a police complaint against me for domestic violence. Is the DV act not for the protection of senior woman like me? Can I lodge a police complaint against her under DV act for mental torture as aggression is best defense. If she can lodge a complaint after 3 year, can I also not lodge a complaint. Please advise how do I go about?.
'surprise exhibit/doc' during cross-exam!! please advise!!
My question is
What is correct/settled position of law as to ‘introducing documents/exhibits while cross examining the opposite side’s witness (either the opposite party to suit or other witnesses of opposite side) ?
My belief is that ONLY the Respondent/Defendent (against whom the liability is alleged) in any original trial are protected from unfair 'surprises' (new documents/exhibits during cross) ................ BUT plaintiffs are NOT protected against any surprises, as plaintiffs are supposed to be aware of "facts of case and subject matter" and are expected "not to be surprised about their own grievances/contentions (alleged rights accrued).
The situation is as follows:
Plaintiff's evidence stage is going on …
Plaintiff has given Exam in chief.
Now, the current status is as follows:
§ Respondent is taking plaintiff's cross exam/confronting the Plaintiff in cross (i.e. plaintiff is being subjected to cross exam)
§ Respondent has a surprise document to expose 'vexacity of plaintiff'!!
§ I got only one case law so far of BOM HC (2011) which suggests 'plaintiff's mischief can be exposed' and there is NO need to publish ‘surprise’ document before hand else the plaintiff gets a clue as to what is comming!!!!
1. So Order 7 R 14, Order 8 R 1-A and Order 13 R 1, read together an exception is carved like Respondent is NOT using the abovesaid ‘surprise’ doc to support/prove Respondent’s plea but to demolish/disprove plaintiff's plea!!! and thus/hence there is no need to give notice /list of docs while filing WS vide Order 8 Rule 1-A, else the surprise element in cross examination would vanish. And it is as good as giving a list of 'likely questions in cross' in advance!!!!)
But in support of above I request some more legal expert opinion, and some more guidance from experts, and also SC/ BOM HC cases laws.
I have a few genuine doubts as well!!! as follows. Please comment on those. thanks in advance.
In regards to production of documents/list etc CPC provisions as ….
In Order 7 Rule 14, wording is as ‘…… plaintiff’s witnesses …….’
In Order 8 Rule 1-A, wording ALSO is ‘…… plaintiff’s witnesses …….’
(Both are referring to plaintiff’s witnesses)
In Order 13 Rule 1, wording is as ‘……witnesses of the other party ....’
(my question here is … what about ‘defendant’s witnesses’??? I thought initially there is a printing mistake in CPC bare act that I have, but it is not!!!!)
Thus, the Respondent wants to 'disprove' the plaintiff's version of facts and expose vexacity/mischief!
There is no such burden upon respondent, but respondent taking onus to do so. if plaintiff's version of 'facts' remain 'unproved' still it is sufficient.
Vide WS, the Respondent has not only explicitly denied "plaintiff's version of facts/incident" but also alleged a new "respondent's version of same facts/incidents" etc Whether Respondent's version of facts get proved or not is not a matter of concern (as there is no counter claim by respondent), if plaintiff's version of alleged facts get demolished, then there remains nothing in the case!
Please clarify my doubts as follows (I am confused after reading those case laws):
There is another BOM HC case law which says (as to O7 R14, O8 R 1-A & O13 R1):
“ …. there is distinction in the term witness and a party to the suit …”
“The party to the suit cannot be equated with the witness and cannot be confronted with a document by casting surprise upon him, particularly when the documents were not filed by the plaintiff along with the list of documents on which he is going to rely upon.”
Thanks