LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Basant Aggrawal   09 July 2025 at 08:19

I need some guidance.

Hello respected members,

I need legal guidance regarding the ownership of a HUDA plot in a partnership firm case. Here are the details:

In 1990, a partnership firm named M/s Radheshyam Aggrawal Chemicals was formed with four partners:
Deenchand Aggrawal, Basant Aggrawal, Rajesh Gupta, and Manish Jain.

In 1992, a HUDA industrial plot was purchased in the name of the partnership firm.

In 1997, three partners—Deenchand, Rajesh, and Manish—retired from the firm by signing a dissolution deed, leaving only Basant Aggrawal as the continuing partner.

One important clause in the dissolution deed said:
"Sh. Basant Aggrawal shall have the right to carry on the business of the firm under the same name M/s Radheshyam Aggrawal Chemicals singly or with new partners. The retiring partners shall have no right or claim in the assets, goodwill, or property of the firm and shall not use the firm’s name."

After this, for 3 months, Sh. Basant Aggrawal continued the business alone under the same firm name.

Then, in mid-1997, he brought in two new partners, Sh. Jille Singh and Sh. Ajay Singh, through a new partnership deed. The firm continued in the same name and address, but there was no mention of the HUDA plot being transferred or pooled into this new partnership.

Later the same year, Basant Aggrawal retired from the firm by signing a retirement deed, and the business continued in the same name with Jille Singh and Ajay Singh as partners. In this manner, the constitution of the partnership firm was changed. Again, the retirement deed did not mention the HUDA plot or any asset transfer.

No NOC or transfer permission was ever obtained from HUDA during this entire transition.
Also, the plot is still registered in the name of the original firm as per HUDA records.

My Question:
Given these facts, who is the rightful owner of the HUDA plot?

Is it Basant Aggrawal, who was the sole surviving partner after the dissolution, and never officially transferred the property?

Or is it the reconstituted partnership firm with Jille Singh and Ajay Singh?

What legal view would HUDA or a civil court take in such a situation?

Anonymous   08 July 2025 at 21:26

Misconduct of advocate

Sir, one lawyer has taken my civil (against my uncle reg. Inheritence property) case and that case has been compromised. Now my daughters filed case against me for partition. In that case My previous lawyer has represents my daughters. Its not ethical. How to remove opp. Lawyer from case? Because Im his old client and he knows all my weakness and strength.

Tejas Shetty   08 July 2025 at 13:45

Suing bmc: demolished our property, no fair compensation.

We had a road side shop, that we had been running for almost 35 -40 years, late 2019 this shop was demolished by BMC against courts order, then they were showing alternate properties, that were absolutely terrible, the property we had was giving us a rental of around 35k in 2019, and was valued at around 80 lakhs during that time.

Since we rejected the alternative properties, they offered a compensation of around 22lakhs, which we also rejected and took them to court, then the court again orderrd them to show us good properties within 8 weeks, then covid struck, BMC didn't follow through with the order, things got perpetually delayed. Now again they're asking us to take a residential property in mahul gaon, which is actually a place where BMC is not supposed to give as per the court because it is a terrible place.

I'm looking for a civil lawyer who can help me with this, this is a straight forward case, please can someone help me, guide me to take things forward.

Anonymous   08 July 2025 at 12:09

Ipc 302 case mai father ko life sentence mila hai

My father got life sentence from lower court due to false murder case alligation on false testimony by someone from lower court we had given petition of bail in allahabad highcourt. It almost 3 years but still we are not getting date on nearby no it listed 190 or 360 case no inside the court what should I do I got fed up with this need to suicide please can someone advise how to get the file no on top 20. And my father case is 24 years back

Anonymous   08 July 2025 at 11:17

Loss of govt job due to administrative error?

Situation:
Two Players named A and B earns national sports certificates for playing Wushu and become eligible for a govt job in Himachal Pradesh under 3% sports quota reservation scheme.

Department of Youths Service and Sports which acts as a bridge between various Government Departments and Players, send Communication to Player A saying that there is a JBT teacher job available with Department of Primary Education and it matches with your qualification (JBT Diploma from govt college and TET pass certificate). Do you want to take this job?. Player A gave the consent and same was sent to department of Primary Education. Department of Primary Education send the joining letter and after verification of all the documents, player A is allocated the school to join as Primary Teacher. He is doing job as Primary Teacher for last 7 months.

Now Player B seeks job in Electricity Department based on his Qualification (JE Diploma in electricity). But Department of Electricity deny the job, saying that this sport/game which you play is not in the list of jobs recommended by department of Personnel and Training so we cant offer you job.

Player B file a case against department of Youth Service & Sports and ask if this job is not recognized by department of personnel and training, then on what grounds you are recommending the names of players to various government departments for jobs under sports quota. To which Department of Youth Service replied that this game was delisted in year 2018 but due to carelessness of the department (administrative error ) the list was never updated and we were recommending the name of the sportsperson of this game also. Now we have updated the list so we will not recommend the players of this game.

Now my Question is - what will happen to those players who got the jobs under sports quota this game after 2018. Will they loose their jobs?

Anonymous   07 July 2025 at 21:30

Release or gift or will or anything else

Dear sir

My dad was single owner of flat. He did nomination in my mom name when he was alive.

Then society transferred flat in my mother's name after my dad expired.

Me and my sister is there.

Now what are the options available with my mom If she wants to pass on that flat to me and my sister. Also advise any other option.

Regards

Anonymous   07 July 2025 at 10:48

Declaration based on registered mortgage deed

We don't have any title deed other than Revenue records and registered mortgage deed. Can we claim declaration based on registered mortgage deed alone? Considering it is settled position Revenue records are not document of title. It is a Ancestral property

Any citation, please share.

Anonymous   06 July 2025 at 20:20

Money fraud

My mother was a member in a kameti (not authorized), around 50k was due when the lady ran away with the money leaving her husband and daughter. Her husband claims that he is not aware of the location but she still owns 2 house in our locality where her husband is residing currently. Her truecaller shows that she and her son constantly talk to people over call despite that her husband claims that he has filed a police report and they are unable to track her. what should we do to get our money back. The lady still resides in delhi and the whole cause of action took place in Delhi itself. Also, her husband claims that she took away the kameti diary along with her.

Anonymous   06 July 2025 at 12:16

Leasing out soceity crech

Dear exports ,
Builder has given creche to soceity but we wanted to know Can we lease out the soceity creche on rent to generate some income for betterment of soceity as per maharashtra Co-operative soceity act 1960.

Anonymous   05 July 2025 at 18:12

Regarding trial procedure in matrimonial case

Dear Experts,
Written statement is filed with allegations from Respondent. No documents has been attached substantiating the allegations.
Similarly income affidavit is filed without any documents (salary, bank statements, ITR etc) and us also incomplete.
Even after posting the same during enquiry, there is no response.
To extent possible I have submitted documents from my side.
I am not sure on why is this negligence from opposite side.

She has claimed maintenance and trial (by way of evidence is to commence).

By question is can the documents be submitted now (written statement related at this point by opponent) just like that. Do they need not get permission first? I wanted to know the procedure in family court.

Similarly in this stage also if documents on income affidavit is not submitted, then what should be my next step. Can experts guide me?