experience related matter.
Querist :
Anonymous
(Querist) 01 April 2011
This query is : Resolved
I applied for a RO dealership in AMM office, BPCL Co. Panipat. For dealership selection there were allotted total 4 marks for Experience in various fields. The brochure has mentioned that
For Business Experience there are maximum 4 marks and will be awarded as follows-
1.Retail trade of Petroleum products=4marks
2.Related petroleum trade / transport / automobiles =3
3.Hospitality / Service industry / FMCG=2
4.Others=1
Based on furnishing of documentary evidence to establish the relevant service. Managerial/ supervisory experience of one year will qualify for full marks and proportionate for lesser experience.(This note was for individual applicants.)
I submitted my experience of Life Advisor / Agent of Insurance Agency which is for 2009-10 and I cover more than one year of experience in this field. Insurance Industry is a service providing industry and thus I qualify for 2 marks as per the brochure guidelines. But during the selection process the selection committee awarded one mark instead of two, to me for my experience. For this I made a representation before the authority to give me full 2 marks for my experience. But the authority denied saying that –
Since the role of Life Insurance Advisor (agent) is not a full time Managerial / supervisory Role, thus only one mark was given.
In the same brochure, the terms and condition regarding experience are mentioned as follows –
Based on furnishing of documentary evidence to establish the relevant service in the sector.
Note: At least 1 year of experience of providing service in a particular sector will entitle for full marks & proportionately for experience of less than 1 year.
(However this is written in the case of non individual applicants i.e. for a firm etc. But it defines that proportionate lesser marks are for experience of less than one year instead of full time or part time. The selection committee is not the authority to decide my job as part time or full time.)
In the brochure of other oil company HPCL the terms and conditions are cleared and are as follows for individuals –
Based on furnishing of documentary evidence, along with the application, to establish the relevant service. Managerial/ supervisory experience of one year, as on date of application will qualify for full marks. No marks for experience of less than 1 year.
My queries are as follows –
1. If the decision of the committee to award one mark is as per law.
2. On the basis of above facts am I not eligible/ entitled for full two marks for this category.
3. What course of action I should take against the authority which is bent upon not to consider my representation to favor the other applicant.
