Resp. Experts,
Filed Divorce Petition under section 13(1)(ia)on the ground of cruelty and sought lumpsum alimony from Respondent. Court has not framed separate issue for lumpsum alimony. Is separate issue for lumpsum alimony required to be framed by the Court? If cruelty is established, then in the absence of separate issue for lumpsum permanent alimony, is Court bound to consider the case for lumpsum permanent alimony when it is prayed for?
Are there any supporting judgements?
Kindly extend your valuable guidance.
shweta yashwant kunte
08 August 2013 at 11:58
my husband has filed a divorce case against me on the basis of cruelty, which ofcourse i deny.he has falsely created such a situation and documents that i take tutions at home which i dont.and showing himself to b jobless whr as he owns a salon which is bought by him after our marriage.he owns a flat which he has sold off widout telling me and much before he sent me notice.am i liable to ask for a share on his property.i am not earning anything.am completely a home maker.can u guide me???? can i ask for a permanant allimony?
Sir I got married in 2009 my wife left me to her parents for delivery after delivery she did not join me so I filed rcr in family Court and divorce after 2 years under same case during councelling my wife got ready to join on condition of seperate house so we live together with my3 3 year daughter for one week in seperate rented house again she left me as her grandmother dies. Now she is not ready to come back and warned me not to contact her mean while I contacted Court councillor he told me that Case is already disposed and order is passed he can't do any thing my lawyer told me to wait for 1 year to apply for divorce my question is 1)what are
Chances of divorce after one year on the basis of decree passed by Court 2) is it necessary to execute the order though it is compromise decree 3)what action I can take against councillor as I came to know that he is good friend of my father in law
I married 5 years back. First one year, I lived with my wife in a rented house. The same city, wife house located. We are both employed. First one year was happy. When she leave to her home for delivery, she and her parents invited me to live in their home. Two years, I lived in her house with her parents and her brother.
Problems started soon, when we started living in her home. I could observed that my wife behaviour to me was so rude with the presence of her parents. She started to scolding without specific major causes. She started to sleep with her mother in night. After midnight (1pm) she arrive to bedroom and sleep again. Her parents encouraged her. She was reluctant to visit my home in my native place and bring kid to my home. My wifes mother started to put her nose in our personal matters too. I felt so irritated. I warned her against it, but no use.
My wife got mothers share of property and We build a home there. The property is near to wifes home. We both shared money and build home.
In that moment, I got another job and shifted to my native place. Wife stayed at her home. At that time they rented the home without informing me. They didnt informed me anything about advance amount and rent etc. All things controlled by her parents. I visited two or three times in a week to wife and kid. She started quarrel these days.
After one year her job shifted near to my native place. We started living in my home with my mother and father. Our kid started to go to a school near my home. After one month, she started quarrel by complaining about travelling problems to her office. Her office is 25 km from home and lot of buses to that place. She complained to her parents and they come bring back kid and my wife. She started to stay in a hostel near her office. And stopped all communications. After 3 months, we compromised through a friend. She demanded that, rent a house near her office and stay together. I rented a home near her office and started living. That time she got pregnant and her parents started to visit home to take care her matter. At that time, she again started to hate me in the presence of her parents. I found that, her mother give her lot of mental pressure. As the result, she behaves cruel to me. She aborted 4th month and went to her home by taking medical leave. I visited her home and meet her frequently when she is taking rest. Few months before the end of medical leave, she telephoned me and told that, she will not return to the rented house and asked me to vacate the house. She also asked me to dont try to contact me her again. If anything to talk, contact with her parents. She started to commute from her home to her office (150 km one side by train). She terminated all communications with me last 3 months. Kid (4yrs) also reluctant to call me.
My father tried to talk with her parents when she left my home first time. Then, they used bad words to my father. So he is reluctant to talk with her parents again. I am in a dilemma. I strongly think that, her mother give pressure on my wife so she act according their decision. Her father has no voice in the home. He is a silent man.
I am in a dilemma, what I do?
Kumarsirik
07 August 2013 at 23:06
If a woman wants avoid humiliation to her in-laws through cases under sections 498a, 406 etc that require arrest or detention or involvement of police, yet, she wants to get divorce, justice and compensation due to her husbands acts that are not very criminal in nature what can she do?
Such as husband mistrusted her, is irregular in performing intercourse, concealed facts from his past that have deep impact on the health of the relationship. Unlike acts of husbands who endanger spouse physically, who should be dealt with harshly and immediately, these issues in marriage do not require extreme measures like police arriving at door steps of the matrimonial house causing humiliation and loss of pride in the soceity in addition to the verbal harassment the bridegroom family shall face in the hands of the police in addition to the remand for few days.
Rakesh Malik
07 August 2013 at 22:32
My wife is mba. I have filed divorce case after one month of marriage. We never consummate the marriage. So I have filed for null and void marriage case.
She was working before marriage and was earning more then me. After marriage she is not working.
In mediation the mediator told me that as I have filed the case, court can ask me to pay 50% of my salary as maintenance to my wife. My father is retired govt. employee. My mother is a government employee. We have our own home. We are two brother sister and my sister is married. Sir I have no liability.
My wife also want divorce but she is asking for 15 lakh as compensation.
How much maintenance she is entited for?
Member (Account Deleted)
07 August 2013 at 20:21
ME AND MY FRIEND WANTS TO GET MARRIED BUT GIRL FATHER IS NOT READY FOR IT AS I AM A BRAHMAN AND GIRL IS SRIVASTAVA.NOW SITUTATION IS THAT GIRLS FATHER HAS TAKEN THE GIRL BACK TO LUCKNOW FROM NOIDA AND HE IS NOT ALLOWING THE GIRL TO MOVE OUT OF THE HOUSE.GIRL FATHER HAS ALSO TAKEN HER MOBILE LAPTOP AND EVERY MEANS OF COMMUNICATION FROM WHICH SHE CAN CONTACT ME.I GOT A CALL FROM HER LAST MONDAY FROM A LOCAL PCO OF LUCKNOW SHE WAS CRYING AND UPDATED ME THE SCENE WHICH I HAVE DISCLOSED IN THE BEGINNING OF THIS QUERY.SHE ALSO SAID THAT SHE IS BEEN BEATEN EVERY DAY BY HER DADA AND BROTHER.WE LUV EACH OTHER WANT TO GET MARRIED PLEASE UPDATE WHAT TO DO .MY FAMILY MEMBERS APPROACHED GIRL FATHER BUT HE REFUSED TO TALK ON THIS MATTER.......PLEASE UPDATE WAT TO DO
Dear Sir/Madam
Mr. Ram was the owner of the property and after his death the property devolved among his four sons Ajay, Vijay, Ravi, Rajesh.
All four sons sold the (ancestral property) property through Development Agreement. According D.A. each son posses 2 Flats on the land in the constructed building, and Rs.16 lacs each.
Mr. Ajay distributed his share (ancestral property) means 2 flats and Rs.16 lacs between him and his two sons and Mr. Ajay is alive.
When Mr. Ajay's daughters came to know about the said distribution, the daughters are demanding their rights in their fathers share (ancestral property) .
My question is when Mr.Ajay is alive can the daughters of Mr.Ajay ask for their share in the Ancestral Property.
Pooja Chopra
07 August 2013 at 12:12
I have found multiple evidences that my husband has been seeking sex with other men from the time that we got engaged till April- May. I do not have any recent evidences of the same. However all this evidence is in form of Chats and pages that he has visited. He is also registered on a gay site. I know of a couple of instances when he has lied to me.
If I want to file for divorce basis this then is this evidence enough? How do you go about doing this? What is the fees that I will need to pay to the counsel?
Maintenance for wife and 498a
Sir I am very much tensed as my wife is pressurizing me and my family for money. Believe me my case is real. Let me tell you truth. My wife has affair with the devar of her elder sister. That person is already married for six years and he too has filed divorce case. I have call recording of my wife with his boyfriend in which they are talking romantically. Sir actually the true story is this, my wife run away with his boyfriend who is devar of her elder sister. That boy is also not at his home for last 7 months. My wife is also not at her father home. Now she is saying that she lives with her bua (father's sister).I don't know her address. The day on which my wife left my home my father in law made the missing complaint of her in local police station. In his complaint my father in law mentioned that in laws of my daughter never demand dowry, never physically or mentally harassed her daughter.
After 7 days the day from which my wife left my home, she made a complaint in local police station accusing me and my parents for dowry and harassment. When police came to my home we showed the copy of complaint made by my father in law. The investigating officer filed the complaint made by my wife and no action taken by police against us.
It is the incident of january 2013. In march 2013 my wife lodged a complaint in crime against women cell. When we get the summon we went to caw cell office. My wife asked for return of dowry and divorce in front of investigating officer. She submitted a false dowry list. But we had actual list signed by her father and her elder brother. When we showed our list that list was accepted by caw cell and we were given a date to return the dowry goods in CAW cell.
When we went to return the dowry goods my wife refused to take the dowry goods and asked for 15 lakhs as compensation. The CAW cell investigating officer told my wife that as we returning the stree dhan, 406 can not be imposed on us. But 498 A can be imposed. CAW cell give us new date to come with the statment of her father in which he has mentioned that in laws of my daughter never demand dowry, never physically or mentally harassed her daughter. Sir please help me. I just want to know:
1) Can 498 A be imposed on us?
2) How much maintenance my wife is entitled for?