LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

rohan sharma   10 March 2013 at 16:49

Maintenance revision by my wife

Sir,
I am not living with my wife since 2010. In the year 2011 i filed sec 9, which was transferred by my wife, which is still in court, as due to transfer it was delayed.In 2012 she joined my due to mediation in section 125 which she filed in 2011 and later on it was withdrawn as she started living with me from Jan 2012. But once again she returned to her father home in Aug 2012, she filed section 125 once again. IN SHORT, COURT HAS GIVEN FOLLOWING JUDGEMENT " ........IN THE INSTANT CASE THE P-1 HAS NOT PLACED ON RECORD EVEN A SINGLE COMPLAINT MADE BY HER AGAINST THE MISBEHAVIOR OF RESPONDENT(MY. RATHER SHE HAS PLACE ON RECORD A LEGAL NOTICE ISSUED TO HER BY THE RESPONDENT FOR REJOINING HIS COMPANY. IT IS ALSO AN ADMITTED FACT THE THE RESPONDENT HAS FILED A PETITION U/S 9 HMA FOR RESTITUTION OF CONJUGAL RITES. THE RESPONDENT HAS ALSO PLACE ON RECORD THE COMPLAINT MADE BY HIM BEFORE THE CONCERNED POLICE AUTHORITIES ON 2012, WHEN THE P-1 HAS LEFT HER MATRIMONIAL HOME FOR THE SECOND TIME. THERE IS A STATEMENT OF P-1 RECORDED ON THE SAID COMPLAINT WHEREIN SHE HAS ADMITTED LEAVING HER MATRIMONIAL HOME WITH HER CLOTHES, AND OTHER STUFF......................................CONSIDERING THE REASONS GIVEN ABOVE AND THE CONCEALMENT MADE BY THE P-1 IN HER PETITION AND ALSO CONSIDERING THE FACT THAT HER ALLEGATION ARE NOT SUPPORTED BY ANY COMPLAINT WHEREAS THE CASE OF THE RESPONDENT IS DULY SUPPORTED BY HIS COMPLAINTS AND PETITIONS FILED, PETITIONER NO 1 PRIMA FACIE DOES NOT APPEAR TO HAVE A SUFFICIENT CAUSE TO RESIDE SEPARATELY FROM THE RESPONDENT. ACCORDINGLY NO MAINTENANCE IS GRANTED TO HER AT THIS STAGE AND THE INTERIM APPLICATION QUA P-1 STAND DISMISSED. ....................................THE RESPONDENT IS EARING RS 35000. ...........CONSIDERING THE INCOME OF THE RESPONDENT AND HIS RESPONSIBILITY I HEREBY AWARD MAINTENANCE AT THE RATE 6000/- IN FAVOUR OF P-2

P1 is my wife and P2 my daughter of 2 year.
Sir,Above stated judgement is of the court they rejected maintenance at the first stage but instructed me to give maintenance of Rs 6000 for 2 year baby.

As per your earlier suggestion i take important decision and did't filed for revision as i was thinking Rs 6000/-, because expert suggest me not to file for revision.

But Sir, my wife file again a case for revision of maintenance, this time, her advocate has given a lot of examples of judgement when court also allowed maintenance in the favour of wife.

I wants to ask what will happen now , what decision court may give now.
Please reply sir, as i am very afraid , as already i have burden of Rs 6000/-. I have private job not govt. job.

Next time i will attach my case file so that you can understand it better and reply me in better way but right now please tell me what could happen at this stage.

Regards.

abhimanyu   10 March 2013 at 13:42

Marriage

A boy and a girl are children of two real sisters,who are Hindu by religion. Both children have never met each other as Boy is a USA citizen and girl is an Indian citizen. Please advise:

a) Can Boy marry that Girl?

b)If so, where this marriage should take place in USA or India?

c) What legal formalities should be completed
for this marriage?

LK   10 March 2013 at 09:59

need suggestions

Dear Experts,

Need your suggestions on the below mentioned queries:-

1) my wife file a divorce,maintenance, dv and caw case after 5 months of leaving matrimonial home.

2) she has filed cruelty,harassment, dowry in all the cases same complaints with no evidence.

3) she has taken all her and my belongings and jewelery fron her parents and given by my parents at the time of leaving home.

4) we have filed our reply of divorce,maintenance,dv with proofs.

5) i have attended almost 10 caw cell dates and IO is favoring her a lot besides a reply given by me with complaints and proofs.. What action can i take against IO?

6) IO is very adamant to register a case. What should i do?

7) there is a lot of mismatch between the stridhan list and the bills provided by my wife at caw cell.

8) we have given so many complaints But no action has been taken by io and at police station.

9) to secure myself and my family we all have got notice bail.

Waiting for your revert....

sugureddy manikya reddy   10 March 2013 at 09:51

Can a person can claim maintenance petition?

Dear Experts,

whether a person unable to maintain himself can file a maintenance petition against wife if she is working?


one of my client have undergone for (illarikam),he stays with his wife and her parents,now he is unable to maintain himself and where as the wife is doing job, can he go for a maintenance petition?


but he is not willing to take the divorce.

Kalyan Ghosh   10 March 2013 at 09:02

Validity of address

I am from the boy's side.In a mutually consented divorce case the girl's party wants to give the Voter ID Card Address in the Application for Joint Petition.Problem is this the girl does not live at this address and present address is different from the Voter Card Address(CURRENT COMMUNICABLE ADDRESS IS DIFFERENT FROM THE VOTER CARD ADDRESS)MOREOVER ALL CORRESPONDENCE BETWEEN THE BOY'S FAMILY AND THE GIRL'S FAMILY ARE BEING MADE AT THE GIRL'S PRESENT ADDRESS.ALSO MARRIAGE REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE AND SOCIAL MARRIAGE INVITATION CARD ADDRESS ALSO SHOWS THE CURRENT ADDRESS OF THE GIRL(NOT THE VOTER CARD ADDRESS).
We cannot see the motive behind this move.ALSO THERE IS DOUBT IF THE VOTER CARD ADDRESS IS A COMMUNICABLE ONE.TO THE BEST OF OUR KNOWLEDGE THE CURRENT ADDRESS IS MORE IMPORTANT.Please advise

pritpal rajput   10 March 2013 at 08:47

About u/s 13 - b

kya u/s 13- B case file karne ke baad 6 month ka samay lagna jaruri hai , before 6 month order nahi ho sakta agar dono parties razi ho.

Maria Priya   09 March 2013 at 23:59

Spouse seeking separation

Hi,

My friend is gng thru a separation. His wife has asked him to leave the house, The house in which they are living currently is owned and fully furnished by the MIL. Currently the MIL is also staying with them. My friend works for a software company.
The reason why the wife asked him to leave the house is that they are not compatible & not on talking terms for the last 4 years( have been married for the past 8 years and have a son aged 5).

Pls advise what steps need to be taken by him to protect himself against any domestic violence or a dowry harassment case she might file in the future.

R.Ramesh   09 March 2013 at 16:40

Fakse witness in charge sheet

Good Evening Sir,
I/O came to my house and conducted enquiry with our neighbors and that time I/O said the result of enquiry shows that my sisters names can be removed from Charge Sheet but when I collected Charge Sheet in that I/O did not removed my sisters names and now I came to know that what ever the witness given by my neighbors I/O did not considered and instead of this I/O had kept only my wife sides’s people’s witness but my wife side witness people they are not aware about issue and moreover they are from different place and even they did not watched and they does not belongs to the place of offence.So, with false witness I/O had submitted the false charge sheet and made involved all our family members in Charge Sheet. So, sir on this for whom I should to complaint about false filling of charge sheet or in what way I should proceed legally.
Thanking you.

SHRIKANT   09 March 2013 at 12:13

Can i file rcr after 2 years of wife leaving matrimonial home

Hello Sir

Myself from Mumbai married in June 2006 . Wife has left matrimonial home in Gujarat since Nov 2010 alognwith 5 year old son. Even after trying several ways by family friends she is not ready to come back . I sent a legal notice in Aug 2011 asking her to come back .But she file CRPC 125 of interim and final maintenance in sessions court of Gujarat. She has been asked to come before court for putting her say but shes not appearing in Court since last 6 hearings and my lawyer is not helping me much . Now after 2 and half years of separation all relations are dead and i want to start new life. However i know if i file divorce i will not get it since it would be contested by wife. So , should i file RCR at this stage since i know she is not going to come back again. Will i get RCR since i have tried many ways to call her back even i tried through Social community way. Putting this case from Mumbai or Gujarat would be helpful ??

Ankarsh Rattan   08 March 2013 at 20:07

Declaration of religion (caste)

I am Scheduled Caste Hindu Balmiki by birth but I like Christianity by faith. My marriage is solemnized in Church because my wife is Christian by birth. Now, we both are in matrimonial dispute. She leave my home from last 1.5 years. I put conjugal rights u/s 32 of Divorce Act 1869 on her. We have a girl child aged 2 years who is presently with her. I withdraw My conjugal rights case. Now, every time my inlaws complaint to my department that i am christian and takes Privilege of SC reservation, but this is my right, I am by birth belongs to SC Category.

Please tell me how can i declare my religion and caste that I m by birth Hindu