Anonymous
14 February 2011 at 07:45
Ashwin (name changed for confidentiality), a relative of mine, got married in the year 2001. At the time of his marriage Ashwin was working in a private company at Mumbai. He and his wife Rajni (name changed) led a happy life for about four years. Every thing was going well between them during this period. Ashwin’s actions amply prove that. For instance, Ashwin took out a few insurance policies on his life and nominated his wife as the beneficiary. Similarly, in all his other investments, Rajni was the only beneficiary.
While aspiring for advancement in his career Ashwin switched a few jobs and was generally doing well. For about a year and a half he was based in his wife’s home city Allahabad where he was working for a contracting firm. Unfortunately, things didn’t work out very well and he couldn’t successfully continue to work for this firm. Ashwin then tried his luck in business and started his own small shop in his home city Kanpur. The business was small and the income was low. Though Ashwin’s parents adequately supported the couple, Rajni started feeling financial constraints. In order to provide Ashwin with more flexibility and time Rajni decided to leave him alone for a couple of months and went back to her parents’ home in March 2004. She kept in touch with Ashwin via telephones from there and continued to motivate him for trying harder.
Not satisfied with the income he was able to generate from his small business at Kanpur, Ashwin took a new job in Mumbai in August 2004 and shifted base. He did very well in this job. His career has progressed exceedingly well since and he is now working for Reliance at a reasonably good salary in Delhi. Despite his excellent career growth and significantly better financial position, his wife wasn’t impressed and decided not to return to him at all. For last about seven years, Ashwin and his family have made numerous efforts to bring her back but have not been successful. The only reason she gives is that Ashwin’s family did not adequately apprise her and her father of Ashwin’s salary and his financial status before arranging this marriage. Had they known that, this marriage would not been possible. More than six years have now passed and the couple haven’t cohabited even for a day.
Though Rajni is not willing to return to her husband at all, she is averse to the idea of legal separation too. It is understood that she is practising law in Allahabad High Courts. Ashwin is terribly shaken. He is unable to understand his wife’s motives behind all this.
How to break this impasse? Ashwin has almost reconciled to the fact that he may have to lead a lonely life. In regards to filing a case for divorce, some lawyers have advised him that if he goes ahead with this he may lead himself to a worse situation. This mainly assumes that if a divorce case is filed, there may be a retaliatory case from Rajni in which there may be an attempt to implicate him and his family in some forged dowry or harassment charges.
What will be the best course of action for Ashwin to pursue further? Is it mandatory to file an RCR suit before filing a divorce appeal? Whilst the chances of rapprochement appear to be very bleak now, it will not be very difficult to prove their physical separation for more than six years.
Anonymous
13 February 2011 at 13:40
B married in the guardianship of his elder brother, B is mentally ill but that too recognized after 3yrs of marriage, now B has got 2 child, 1 is male(2 yrs) and the other one is female(4 yrs),B has same ancestral land and he is uselessly selling his land without giving a thought to his future and also he is not doing anything to earn his beard and butter, so in such case wife of B i.e A wants to occupy the ownership of the land so as to keep her and her children future secure.I want your suggestion on this case so that the purpose of A gets fulfilled.
Anonymous
13 February 2011 at 12:06
I am a 35 year old guy been married for 11 years and have a son who is 4 years old. i am my wife had issues right from the start which led to lot of fights and i was also subjected to physical and verbal abuse by her. When the same was not getting resolved, i moved out of the house in april 2010 and have been staying out since. i have been paying my sons school fees and also saving money for him in a bank account. I need to know how can i go ahead with the divorce and whether staying seperated for 1 year without any contact is a ground for divorce and will be same be easy or will have to be contested.
This query was asked under queries and the answer of expert was No, which was wrong. I could not answer because I am not an accredited expert. But the answer "No" is wrong. The "No" answer is valid only according to Hindu scriptures and the khap panchayats of Punjab and Haryana. The Hindu Marriage Act prohibits marriage between first cousins only whether maternal or paternal or cross. Marrige between individuals beyond first cousin, whether maternal or paternal is permitted under all marriage Acts of Parliament. It is very unfortunate that so called experts only reply. Experts also can give wrong replies.
A forward caste male married a S.T. Women they gave birth to a male child and obtained divorce after 5 years. The child is living with his mother. Does the child is entitled to claim S.T. status. Plz suggest some case laws connected to this case.
Anonymous
12 February 2011 at 17:18
i was married in 2008 as per indian christian marriage laws. My marriage lasted for about 3 months. My husband was in the US. After three months of marriage, he happened to run away with all my money and thereafter i didnt hear from him for a very long time until lately.
As we werent in touch, i filed for divorce and got an exparte decree in 2010. Now my husband has approached me for a divorce. My lawyer suggests that its better to file for divorce on mutual consent. I am wondering why my ex parte decree wont help! Do i have to file for divorce again?
What are the proceedings for mutual consent? How long will it take for that to come into effect?
Anonymous
12 February 2011 at 16:58
My wife filed case under scetion 9 of H.M.A Act. in session court & COURT PASS specific performance DECREE in her favour. even i have given the statement that i want to live with my wife & i have not decerted her .
Query: CAN COURT ATTACH MY PROPERTY. pl tell me how should i defend the case.
Anonymous
12 February 2011 at 16:03
Dear Experts,
Our Marriage was solmenised on 08-Feb-2011 in an Arya Samaj Mandir in Delhi.
But both of us are residents of Faridabad(Haryana). Now can i register my marriage in Delhi itself.
All my documents (Age & Residence proof etc.)are of faridabad.
I will be really thankful for your precious advice.
Anonymous
12 February 2011 at 14:32
Petitioner wife had filed application under section 24 mentioning that she has no source of income. But actually she is a government employee. At the DATE the respondent husband shown her service crtificate with salary. But just before producing certificate the wife said she dont need maintenence and give her litigation expenses only. Order was passed to give her rs 2000/- as litigation expense. There was no action against her after production of her service certificate.
1. 7 months have been passed. The divorce petiotion is also there by her. Is there any law/ruling against her wrong flow of information in section 24 application about her job.
2. She has levelled many allegation in the same application for which she didnt gave any proof. There was lot of harassment of respondent. Is there any rule / section that she can be prosecuted ???
Regards
compulsory stay of daughter in law(widow) and sons
My muslim widowed mother(76 years) is staying with house maid alone in fathers house.The eldest daughter in law and sons has tortured my mother mentally and she has been taken for psychiatric treatment before 3 years and kicked her out of the house. Then my mother gave 19 cent plot in her name to the grand son and made them leave the house and was staying with the maid since then. Now they have compulsorily come to the house and started staying there and telling its their property so will not leave. My mother has 7( 2 died) sons and 3 daughters.What is the law helpful?