LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Self service   26 December 2010 at 18:57

Wife claim on money spend from joint account

Dear experts, Wife and husband both maintained joined account. Wife's some salary deposited in account. It was used by husband for household expenses and investements on wifes name or miscelleous expenditure. After 3 years wifes started demanding money back with allegations husband has taken money. She has no fixed amount claim and asking for much more then she earned. Is this demand is correct? IF husband is in need of money he cant use wifes money? And wife can ask money that was with spend with her consent?

Mohammed Khaleelullah   25 December 2010 at 23:09

Position of a Muslim wife reverting back to her original religion of Christanity

Dear experts,
A Christian woman marries a Muslim man by converting herself to Islam at the time of marriage.She begets two children.After some time she reverts back to her original religion i.e. Christianity.Her husband continues to be a Muslim. She names her children with Christian names.My query is:-
(1) What is the legal status of the woman?
(2) Under what Law i.e.Muslim Law or Christian Law she will get her share in the property of her husband?
(3)What is the legal status of her children?
(4)After re-conversion whether she continues to be his wife?
Kindly legally answer the above queries in detail item wise for a clear standing of the law.Thanks in advance for taking pains for answering the same.

Anonymous   25 December 2010 at 21:52

remarriage

R/experts,
Can Hindu widow claim any right in the immovable or other pecuniary property of her first husband's family after remarriage? If yes,by which section and which act.

Anonymous   25 December 2010 at 21:25

property dispute

My father-in-law has two sons and two daughters. he has a house and site but it belongs to my mother-in-law. my father-in-law built upstairs only. They registered a will distributing the property equally by 4 parts. but while the old couple were ill, the sons frightened them and registered another will saying the property belongs to only sons. my father-in-law died on 22nd dec, 2010 and my mother-in-law was telling what happend to them. In this connection do the daughters have any right over the property? Is the second will is legally powerful? As the original site belongs to my mother-in-law, can her daughters claim their share in the property? pl answer.....

Anonymous   25 December 2010 at 20:57

huf latest law for involve daughter for right

sir i want the detail of huf latest ammendment law that specify that there will be a right in huf property of daughter after marriage.

Anonymous   25 December 2010 at 18:36

remarriage

R/experts,
Can widow claim any right in the immovable or other pecuniary property of her first husband's family after remarriage? If yes,by which section and which act.

Anonymous   25 December 2010 at 16:01

want conciliation in divorce after one year of rcr.is it possible?

husband filed for divorce after one year of rcr.recently 125 going on.even i BEGGED for reconciliation many times.she sees me cheap.now in divorce proceedings she is asking for reconciliation.i dont want her to come back because i tortured since three years alot.my rejection can made any impact on divorce proceedings ?PLEASE suggest me?

RAM GOPAL SHARMA   25 December 2010 at 12:46

RIGHT OF DAUGHTER IN PROPERTY

My father has created a gift of agricultral land which was self acquired by him at the time of abolition of tenancy act in Rajasthan in samvat 2015, in favour of me along with two brothers on 03.09.2005. Now my sister has challenged the gift and filed civil as well as revenue suit in the appropriate courts in Rajasthan. Pl let me advise whether legally they can claim the share in self acquired property of my father.
Pl advise.
Regards
Hemant Kumar

Jamai Of Law   25 December 2010 at 11:27

Any 'Pro-Review' citations? to oppose Apeal-in-disguise plea

I am in urgent need of supporting citations (Bom HC, SCC) which are pro towards 'application for Review of Ad-Interim Maint Order' at Family COurt.



Kindly offer suggestions.



The Scenario as follows:





Petitioner-wife although awarded int. maint vide interim Order for the 'sake of kid' and not for her vide sec 24 of HMA, had concealed material facts (which are avaiable as new disclosure which is glaring and can't be ignored. Wife is found to be saving double the money in FDs, than what is asked in maint., and came to court with unclean hands that she hasn't got enough money to support her as well as kid) This disclosure was unknown to husband





In the Order passed, there are self-evident 'errors which are apparent on the face of records, such as'

Court concluded that no evidence is adduced by Respondent-husband about a fact, but evidence was very much there on record and it was submitted at the time of WS filing.
Wife herself conceded about the 'existance' of the facts for which court was asking proofs to respondent, which respondent he couldn't gather (but didn't ask for more time).
'Sudden U-turns, travelling beyond the pleading, amendment to pleading' by Petitioner-wife 'on-the-fly' during argument , although dis-agreed by respondent. Court presumed and allowed the amendment to pleading, whithout assigning and ascertaining the burden-of-proofs to petitioner (which is a glaring 'procedural error' in FC, on the face of records). also This is not inference but it is self evident by reading the text of the order.
This caused 'erroneous' inferences subsequently by the court....but 'erroneous judgement is the outcome of the 'errors on the face of recorsd'
and counter plea 'appeal in disguise' can not leave the respondent remedyless
as respondent is 'NOT allowed for appeal' as this is interim order,
as respondent is allowed NOT allowed for Civil Revision at HC (videCPC 115, in the present context, only wife may go for Civ. Rev. Pet. at HC if the interim order results in finality of suit, but that is also not the case here.)
and Respondent is left with only remedy of EITHER Review at FC
OR Writ under 226 and 227 at HC




'errors on the face of records' has caused to occurance of judgement which the respondent finds it 'erroneous'.





And hence Respondent prefers to apply for review, not purely from the view that 'judgement is erroneours' but mainly from the perspectives of 'error on the face of record' as a primary reason, but feels entitled to get the 'judgement corrected' in the due process.





'Court of equity' prevails all the time along with 'court of law'. Respondent (at FC people not expected to be proficient in law) can't be made to run pillars to post, for conflicts of 'province of appelate court and original jurisdiction'.





If anyways if the review is to be ordered, then he be allowed to adduce the evidence which wasn't produced earlier, that doesn't mean amendment to pleading but supplication of incomplete evidence.





Error are liable to made by everyone, error and offence are different.

If judiciary has provisions to correct its own mistakes in records, then litigants in FC who are illiterate of law, are shown the rulebook about timely submission fo record?





litigants in FC, who are illiterate of law, also be benevolently condoned about their 'failure to adduce evidence in timely manner'





Respondent was expected the wife to come clean before court in financial matters which are trasparent due computerisation of banks etc, and on top of it she was expected not to take U-turns and sudden outbursts which in fact resulted in conceding to



Actually 'the correction of erroneous judgements occured due error on the face of records' is within the review jurisdiction .







How to counter/demolish a very likely and very anticipatory counterplea of 'appeal in disguise' from the opposite party?



Please advise and please refes of useful citations if any




If the FC rejects the 'Application for review'...does the respondent still have remedy available under Writ under 226 and 227 at HC afterwards?





If the FC allows the 'Application for review', ...........

but in review and rehearing of the same if the court retains or comes to the same conclusion as previous one (which is unlikey....raher it shud reject app for review........... process of allowing the review underlines summarily.............about the possibility of settig-aside the previous order, ..............unless opposite party also comes with statling new evidence to defend the order)...

does the respondent still have remedy available under Writ under 226 and 227 at HC afterwards?









Thanks for your expert suggestion, in advance

Anonymous   25 December 2010 at 11:20

brought the child without knoledge of wife

i brought my son from his mother on his first birthday with intention that to see my child for some days because she dont allow me to see my child.now they are threatening me to put cases on me.please could you explain what type of cases will be possible on me?still now not divorced?