KASI VISWANATHAN
02 March 2015 at 22:20
1. Investment Advisors India Ltd ("IAIL"), an Indian Company, is a growing private equity firm based in Mumbai. It had an annual turnover of Rs. 200 crore for the financial year 2005-2006.
2. Supreme Constructions Consortium ("SCC") is also an Indian Company. It is a real estate contractor, which has executed several prestigious building contracts for top corporate houses over the years and has become a reputed name in the real estate industry.
3. In June, 2005 it was decided in the Board Meeting of IAIL to setup their own corporate house in Mumbai, at a unique address in keeping with their growing market repute etc. In July, 2005 for the aforementioned purposes, IAIL procured a piece of land from MMRDA in the prestigious locale of Bandra - Kurla Complex ("BKC"). In August, 2005 IAIL invited Request for Proposal ("RFP") (including Building designs, quotation etc) for constructing their corporate house. In September, 2005 after reviewing several proposals, IAIL selected the proposal submitted by SCC for its unique design, costs and other factors. On 15 September 2005, IAIL and SCC signed the contract that provided: -
a. SCC shall complete the construction of the project by December, 2006;
b. The total cost of the project was Rs. 60 crore;
c. IAIL will make payment in four equal tranches of Rs. 15 crore each, in October- 2005, February-2006, June-2006. The final settlement was to be made in December-2006 when the project was completed and was handed over to IAIL.
d. SCC was required to furnish a bank guarantee in favour of IAIL to cover breach on their part; which was 50% of the value of the contract or Rs. 30cr.
4. The construction began in October, 2005 and continued as per plan without any delay till June, 2006. On 10 June, 2006 a fire broke out on the top two floors of building causing severe damage to the project under construction. It was found that a certain machinery kept by SCC caught fire; thus substantially delaying the construction work. SCC and IAIL set up a committee of their officers to investigate the fire. The Committee recorded minutes that the fire arose from the position of machinery kept by SCC, and that the committee was unable to conclude whether SCC was at fault, and that this question of deciding fault will be referred to experts by IAIL immediately. IAIL never made this reference. The committee also noted that the fire had caused loss to the incomplete structure, and that the cost for completion would increase by at least 20%. After heated discussions at the meeting about extra costs, and about who shall bear these, IAIL and SCC decided to discuss these in a later meeting. This meeting also never happened.
5. The construction was finally completed in March, 2007, three months behind schedule. The final tranche of payment (Rs. 15 crore) was withheld by IAIL till the construction was complete on 1 March, 2007. SCC sent a letter on 15 March 2007 to IAIL claiming the last tranche of payment that was due and additional charges of Rs. 5 crore for the delay in construction citing clause 11 & 12 of the contract. The clauses read as under:
"11.0 SCC will not be liable for any loss or damage arising out of the work
carried out under this contract;
12.0 Furthermore, SCC is entitled to levy additional charges where (i) extra work is required to prepare the project before handing over of the finished project, and (ii) increase in costs arising from delay in completion of project, where delay occurs from causes outside the control of SCC."
6. IAIL refuted the contentions made by SCC vide a reply letter dated 20 March, 2007, stating that construction had not been completed as per schedule agreed under the contract, furthermore, it pointed out that due to delay in completion of the building, IAIL had incurred a loss of Rs. 50 lakhs as rental charges towards its leased office premises for the period of January-March, 2007. It also emphasized that it had the right to invoke the bank guarantee that was furnished as part of the contract. Further, IAIL stated that it was withholding the payments due to SCC for these reasons.
7. Meanwhile, an article containing an interview with the CEO of IAIL published in a
popular business magazine mentioned how the contracts entered with SCC were performed in bad faith.
8. On 30 March 2007, IAIL invoked the bank guarantee and collected 50 lakhs under the guarantee from the bank.
9. On 20 May, 2007, SCC filed a Civil Suit (C.S. No 1000/2007) against IAIL in the City
Civil Court Mumbai claiming the amount of Rs 15 crores of the final tranche of pay
ment,
Rs 5 crores for extra cost caused by the delay in construction, 50 lakhs being the amount
collected by IAIL under the bank guarantee, interest on these amounts, and also for Rs. 5
crore as compensation for loss arising from libellous statements made
against its
reputation. In the reply to the plaint, IAIL has refuted the contentions stating inter alia
that they were entitled to withhold payments for non
-
adherence to time schedule by SCC
and loss
es that arose as a consequence.
10.
Pending this suit, in Jul
y 2009, and at the instance of the Court, IAIL deposited 15 Crores
in the Court and SCC handed over the
constructed corporate house
to IAIL. Parties did
this without prejudice to their rights.
11.
The facts stated in paras 1 to 8 are either admitted or suffici
ently proved. The matter is
fixed for final hearing. Argue for (i) Supreme Construction Consortium, or (ii) Investment
Advisors India Ltd in the said civil suit.
This imaginary problem is formulated
for the purpose of moot court only.
i am born to a hindu schedule caste father but my uncle when my parents expired has given as christian in all my school records & govt. office too since he is a converted christian. I have filed a suit in the civil court for caste declaration. what will be the consequence of the suit. will it stand by me as per recent supreme court judgment. Thanks in advance. Vennila.J.
shaikh
02 March 2015 at 15:53
Hi Experts,
I have given my flat on 11 months leave. After the expiry of the agreement the person does not want to vacate or sign the new agreement or register the new agreement.
Can we consider him as a trespasser and initiate and ex-party order or criminal case.
Also is it safe to make an agreement in the name of persons wife, or it becomes difficult later to vacate since she is a woman.
thank you.
Dear Experts,
Can you please guide me to how to file complaint under whistle blowers act?
can you please explain in simple language How this act functioned.
Thanks in Advance
manojkumar
02 March 2015 at 05:10
Respect lawyers
My grandfather have several properties which is inherited by his father.
1. One acre two cents agricultural Land given by some kind of society
2. 77 cents agriculture land his self acquired properties
3. Four cents land
4. Eight cents land
5. Etc...
My grandfather died at 1990.
Before that my grandfather partitioned
Properties by notary, but there aren't registered.
In that properties my father signed without intimating my mother, I was 3 year boy (minor).
When I asked to relatives there are saying that ur mother signature won't necessary for that properties
Is it correct?
My grandfather have five Children
Four son's and one daughter
Last son is my father.
All of my grandfather properties or sold out without intimating my mother
My father died at 2002.
What should I do?
sivaraj
01 March 2015 at 21:59
one trust have three trustee one trustee died other trustee was resigned one trustee alone that trustee can enter an agreement of sale the trust property
Kishore Padav
01 March 2015 at 21:47
One of the flat owners in the society has one
2 BHK flat in our society. He has rented out his flat in our society and stays in a flat in another building.
These person still is the secretary of our society even without staying in the society. This person is politically connected and had done many illegal things in the society like converting his stlit parking into offices. He
is on a buying spree of purchasing stilts in the office for converting them into offices.
I wanted to know what the Housing Society rules says about purchase of multiple stilts by a single falt owner in a society.
What is the correct forum to complain about this illegal activity by remaining anonymous without getting into confrontation with this person who is a goon and has political connection.
kishore
01 March 2015 at 12:51
sir one of my friend "X" and his girl friend"Y".my friend "X" was helped by his girlfriend "Y" for his business by transferring amount from "Y" to "X".both X and Y are loving eachother REVERSE FACING LOT OF PROBLEMS FROM HIS GF FATHER.BUT HE HAS LOT OF EMAILS SENDED BY HIS GF FOR HELPING HIS BUSINESS.IS IT CRIMINAL OFFENCE BUT MY FRIEND BUSINESS IS IN LOSS HE CANNOT RETURN BACK MONEY..MY FRIEND RECEIVING MAIL FROM HIS GIRLFRIEND FATHER TAT HE SHOULD NOT CONTACT HER BY PHONE/MESSAGES/MAILS JUST TO FORGET HER...
Yeshwant
01 March 2015 at 11:55
Hi,
An civil suit was filed on a land against Party X. Case is going on.
Even though we filed Sale Deed objection, property was registered under Party X.
Now Party X wants to sell or transfer the property to Party Y.
Can you please let us know, how can we stop the sell or transfer of property as the case is still pending in the court.
Thanks and Regards,
Yeshwant Gupta.
Issue with notarised gpa with less stamp value sold property with sale deed.
Hi All,
1.Non blood relative A with notarised GPA in 2006 attested by wife with 100 Rs stamp value sold the property with sale deed to X when the GPA grantor was alive along with all the property documents.
2. And X has sold to Y.
3. we z have purchased from Y but recently we came to know that a first owner wife has filed OS in 2008 on A and X challenging the GPA and decree has given in favour of first owner wife since A and X were never bothered to look into the case and now the case is in EX.
4. So please advice how to deal with this, we are in possession from 5 years.
5. can we pay the stamp value for the GPA now and clear the issue.
can we go for out of court settlement or can we fight the case.
Thanks