LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Siddique   20 March 2015 at 12:33

Investments deal between x and y

Dear Respected Sirs,

Would like to know your expert legal opinion on the below matter of finances/investments between 2 parties viz. X and Y as outlined below :

X has been running a small-scale shop dealing in boutique & tailoring niche since the past few years. Y invests in X's business a certain amount for monthly returns. During the period when Y invested with X, the business was booming. Getting carried-away by this, X inadvertently & under ignorance committed to pay Y, an exorbitantly high, very unrealistic monthly returns to Y without enlightening Y (unintentionally) about the inherent underlying risks of the business (downfall). This deal was based on 100% verbal communications only & no writing work/legal agreement of any sort was executed between X & Y.

The exorbitantly high payments by X to Y over the months hardened the perception & mindset of Y that regardless of the recession in X's business, Y should always continue to receive the so-called "Profits" from X regularly every month. Y was always under the false impression that she would endlessly continue & entitled to receive the so-called "Profits" from X.

So far, the total installments of money returned by X to Y over the months, far exceeds the capital invested by more than 200%.

X was so over-optimistic & blind with her booming business that she could not realise that she would most certainly face an inevitable downfall period in her business at some stage which would play havoc with her finances. She failed to anticipate that how she would pay Y under these circumstances. And the inevitable happened; the business went into recession. X started defaulting on payments to Y & no longer in a position to further pay Y any more money.

Just to reiterate, X has already returned to Y more than 200% of money invested by Y (which X has regularly maintained a record of; no such record maintained by Y)

X is taking the stand & stressing on the fact that since she has already paid Y more than 200%, X is no longer obliged to pay any more. Also since the X's business has crashed & near shut-down, she (X) is not in any position whatsoever to pay Y any further. Despite recovering 200% more than her actual capital, Y still continues to pressurise X to keep on paying her (Y) knowing well that X has incurred big losses in the business.

Now relations has gone sour between the two & Y threatens to file a civil suit against X for recovery of Y's capital.

Kindly advise how much weightage is there in this threat by Y & how would the law view this deal ? Is this case admissible in the court-of-law as there are no written / legal agreements of this deal between the two ?

Between X & Y, who has the right stand ?

sunit kumar   20 March 2015 at 12:19

Cheated by person in government job activity

dear sir,
i wanted to conform ,
is there will be any problem need to face if i will lodge FIR against my case ?
bcoz i am little worry if POLICE will ask to me why i given money for government jobs to my friend? bcoz this is also against law to give money to any one for this kind of activity ???
that time what should we need to do.??

Note - i did all payment through Deposit in Bank and Cheque

sunit
sunitrock@yahoo.com

Hemant khandelwal   20 March 2015 at 11:15

Suits of civil nature

Please read and answer.need help badly. Explanation 1 to section 9 of cpc defines the suit of civil nature as a suit in which the right to property or to an office is contested.it means that a suit can be a civil suit only if either right to property or right to office is involved in it.suit must fit in these two criterias to be called a civil suit.all others are excluded from it.
I am writing some illustration which are called suits of civil nature-
1>suits relating to right of worship.
2>suits for damages for civil wrong.
3>suits for specific performance of contracts and for damages for breach of contract.
4>suits for specific reliefs.
5>suits for restitution of conjugal rights.
6>suits for dissolution of marriage.
7>suits for rents.
Above mentioned suits neither fit in criteria of property suits or office suits then why and how there are suits of civil nature?how these suits fit in those criterias? Explain in detail.

Ramesh   19 March 2015 at 18:34

In a lease deed boundaries are not mentioned.

Dear Experts of the forum,
In a lease deed (Inam Land) my Grand Father did not mentioned boundaries and the extent of the land; which was leased (for aa chandrarkam, permanent lease) to a person Mr.'X' in the year 1935, but only some land marks are mentioned. But,after the death of Mr.'X' his wife leased the same land in the year 1948,to a person Mr.'Y', clearly stating that this land was obtained from my Grand Father on lease. And this lease deed contains the extent of the land and its boundaries clearly.
My grand Father gave only Ac 7 07 gts, out of Ac 49 38 gts. The case is going on for last 45 years. some times we won ,some times they manged in the different forums.
The problem we are facing is our grand Fathers lease deed; where extent and boundaries are not mentioned only land marks are given.

Please ,Please suggest me a way out for this problem, for which act i will be ever thankful to YOU and the FORUM.

M.M.SURANA   19 March 2015 at 17:31

Rent

Dear Friends, I m tenant in house. I sent the rent to my land lord for the month of Feb 15 by MO but they refused. I came to understand through people my building has been sold to someone else, hence they refused . by so fat they have not informe about this matter that it has been sold. they knowingly doi8ng this act to get it vacate. pl advise me.

Rajeswariii   19 March 2015 at 15:12

Illegal land sale

Sir, my Grand father (Mother's father) owns an agricultural land of around 7 acres. He has 5 sons,3 daughters. I am the daughter of youngest daughter of my grand father. all the sons and 1 daughter stay in Malaysia. My mother used to look after the land for the past 10 yrs on behalf of my grand father. He passed away some 9 yrs back. 1 year back, my uncle's wife (Uncle passed away) collided with one of the daughter's son, who is a lawyer and both of them sold the land to a politician. Even though we have filed a case against the buyers, the case is not doing well. My uncle's wife's address is not available. She escaped after selling. This Lawyer cleverly managed not to have his name in any document sold.I want justice for us and the culprits My uncle's wife, lawyer,revenue officials have to be punished. How to proceed?? Please guide

sunit kumar   19 March 2015 at 10:57

Cheated by person in government job activity

dear ,
kindly suggest me what to do, if one of my friends cheated me on helping In Government job , he told me he have some source and circle who conducting govern job activity in different sectors if you need this then you have to pay some amount against this .
so for this i given 30 thousand rupees , but after that nothing was happen and now they deny to refund my money and not picking my call as well .
i know the person detail and where he is living with family and where he working.
i also have proof of audio recording and cheque detail , cash deposit slip and more.


kindly suggest me should i log FIR to my nearest police station or what to do????

Sunit
sunitrock@yahoo.com

praveen   19 March 2015 at 10:53

Reg power of attorney

sir we have given power to a finance guy for our house document worth 80 lakhs, to get 3 lakhs from him . we have registered the power, after an year we found that he is tryin to cheat , when we put EC and saw he has put an sale deed using the power.after that we have cancelled the power of attorney.
now he has filed a case in the court, how to protect our property.The finance guy has put an sale agreement for 25 Lacs and has stated that he has received Rs 50,000 as advance and the sale has to be done within a year.what are the chances for us to defend and win the case? For 3 Lacs we cant afford to lose our hard earned savings ! is there way to secure it? The finance guy has our original document.Please help

Skeptical optimist   18 March 2015 at 21:30

Quantum of compensation claim in consumer court.

Is it necessary that monetary compensation claimed for a given complaint filed in Consumer Court has to be less than or equal to what was asked for in the legal notice served prior to approaching Consumer Court? OR claim can be higher based on reasoning that filing the case involved additional effort, which could have been avoided, had legal notice been addressed satisfactorily before-hand.

Skeptical optimist   18 March 2015 at 21:21

Quoting landmark judgements in consumer court.

I have query related to Consumer Courts.

While filing case, if a few landmark judgements are quoted therein, in support of the complaint; is it necessary to attach complete judgements or summary of judgements along with said complaint OR judge(s) and opposite parties are supposed to unearth them from net or AIR kind of volumes, for their own reference?