Dear sir,
Our opponent filed a declaration suit for land against our mother in 1989 and it was decreed in his favor and aggrieved by the said decree and judgment my mother preferred an appeal in the Sub Court and the same was also dismissed by the Sub Court.
Against the said dismissal of first appeal, my mother had preferred Second appeal before the High Court of Madras in 1995. In 2009, I got power from my mother to proceed the case on behalf of her and filed in the second appeal to implead me as the son and the power of attorney holder and the same was accepted and impleaded me as the power of Attorney of my mother in cause title by the high court of Madras. Further I filed an application to appear and argue as party in person in the said second appeal and the same also was allowed by the high court.
Then I appeared and argued as part in person in second appeal. Though I am not being an advocate, the High court of madras considered all the facts and allowed our appeal by dismissing the judgments of lower courts on june-2014.
Now our opponents have preferred SLP in Supreme court and notice (Show Cause) also was served to me to file counter on Nov - 2014. And the enquiry of the said SLP arrived at registrar court of supreme court on Jan-2015. On that day I filed application to pray to allow me to appear and argue as party in person in the said SLP also. The enquiry on the said application arrived on March-2015 in supreme court. Since the facts of present stage of the SLP, the supreme court declined my prayer and advised me " The petitioner can engage any counsel and may present in the court and may assist to the advocate. And also ordered that " Post the matter, after engaged the counsel"
Till this day I did not engaged any counsel and SLP is also not listed till now.
In this situation My 3 doubts are,
1. Again can I request the supreme court to allow me to appear and argue as party in person?
2. What is the procedure to pray again to allow me to appear and argue as party in person?
3. What is time limit to file counter in SLP and now can I file my counter in this stage?
Kindly Please let me know about the above information.
Mortgagee want his money which he has given to owner of propertyX from me and i am the auction purchaser of property X
i have no role in that mortgage i am just a bonafide purchaser and i got confirmation of sale also he has not come to recover his money before confirmation of sale
After 11 and half years of confirmation of sale he files a suit for recovery against me his case against auction already dismissed
What should i do? to defend myself in court
Riya
09 January 2016 at 23:01
Respected Sir,
Please look into the question and put your views :
My father was an Employee of Eastern Coalfields limited and he expired on September 2012 during his service period after that my elder brother (Age 30) gave the employments of my father to me (younger brother age 27) on a condition that I have to pay Rs.25 Lakh.
And I joined service on April 2013, during the time of employment the EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED have undertaken a INDEMNITY BOND and AFFIDAVIT that I have to look after the dependent of my father i.e. my elder brother and his family, and then on May 2014 an agreement of Rs. 25 Lakh made between me and my elder brother with two witnesses. that in lieu of employment of my father I will pay me a sum of Rs. 25 Lakh within 6 months. But I failed to comply the agreement. Now I want to know that the agreement made in a Rs. 10 Stamp paper before the public notary.
Can he file a case against me on the basis of the mere Agreement of Public Notary and what are the chances of this case and what are the consequences as well as how vital is the INDEMNITY BOND and AFFIDAVIT which I have gave to EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED that if I fails to maintain they EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED is free to deduct my salary. if I don’t pay me the amount.
Please advice me I dont have so much amount to give him, what are the legal chances of my safeguard. Please advice.
kannan
09 January 2016 at 22:43
I bought a land from its legal owner. I calculated the area of the land based on the patta and the measurments given the land suvey map of revenue department. Now the neighbor does not agree with the boundry. What is the legal position/soltion.
rahul
09 January 2016 at 21:35
Sir,
This is a fresh suit filed after withdrawing earlier suit with liberty to file fresh suit.
In earlier suit there were three defendant A, B, C.
D & E are the legal heirs of A.
After serving writ of summons in earlier suit, Plaintiff came to know that Defendant A has died & hence while filling affidavit of service, Plaintiff advocate informed to the court that Defendant A has died & Plaintiff advocate asked for time from court to file Chamber summon to bring legal representative of A on record & court gave the time for the same. This is a point 1
Thereafter Plaintiff could appoint lawyer due to financial problem & hence court appointed lawyer from legal aid.
Lawyer from legal aid file chamber summon for deleting the name of Defendant A. (but not for bringing D & E legal representative of A on record). Court allowed the chamber summons but legal aid lawyer did not make changes in the plaint by remaining absent. There is no careless on the part of plaintiff as plaintiff on time to time present before the court.
Finally court kept the matter for evidence as plaintiff failed to carry out amendment even after allowing chamber summons.
Thereafter new lawyer was appointed from legal aid & new lawyer informed to the court that earlier lawyer failed to take proper steps & applied for withdrawal of suit with liberty to file fresh suit. This is a point 2.
There is a gap of 3 years in point 1 & 2. During this 3 years chamber summons was pending.
Court allowed to withdraw suit with liberty to file fresh suit & observed that ''perusal of record would reveal that the advocate for the plaintiff had not taken proper steps and in such circumstances, it will not be justiciable to throttle the grievance of the petitioner without adjudicating it in accordance with law & as such I allowing the application’’.
Thereafter plaintiff filed fresh suit making D & E (legal heirs of A) as defendant.
But advocates for D & E claiming that fresh suit is not maintainable against D & E because earlier suit is abated against A as Plaintiff failed to bring D & E on record in earlier suit & hence plaintiff can not make D & E defendant in fresh suit in place of A.
Is it right that Suit is abated against A ?
Pleas Guide.
Sorry for long query
rajesh karnik
09 January 2016 at 21:32
Respected Sir/ Madam,
In our suit defendants have filed motion for deciding preliminary issue under 9a of cpc on the point of limitation on the two point.
1. It is barred by law of limitation. (can be decided on Question of law)
2. It is not maintainable as statutory notice under special act not given to statutory organization (It is a question of law & fact).
3. No cause of action
4. Court fees
As far as first objection is concerned , it is mandatory for the court to frame preliminary issue & we also have no problem as we are confident that suit is in limitation. (foreshore CHS - supreme court April 2015 9a is mandatory)
As far as second objection is concerned, we are of the view that concerned statutory notice is not applicable in this suit because of fact & whether notice applicable or not can be decided after going into merits & hence we are opposing on this.
As far as third & fourth also we do not have any problem as there is a cause of action & court can itself decide about from reading of plaint & even if court fees found to be deficit, we are ready to pay.
Therefore we are thinking of opposing only on second point in order to allow court to decide as early as possible.
1. Is it right or we should oppose on all the point because they are defendant.
2. Is it possible that court will not frame preliminary issue on notice even if it goes in the root of jurisdiction because of mix question of law & fact ?
Thank you.
Plaintiff in person
pvra
09 January 2016 at 16:55
Respected Sir,
I live in Tamil nadu.
I wish to apply for succession certificate to claim my share of my late father's bank deposits.
Court fees comes to around Rs 10000/- (rupees twenty thousand only).
Can I file my case now, and pay the Court fees at the time when Court orders the issue of succession certificate?
Look forward to your valuable replies.
Eshwari
Whether execution and registration of joint Will in a single document is prohibited?
Anthony
09 January 2016 at 10:29
I have a case against the BMC H/W ward for demolition of enclousers of Gr.foor otlas in Dindoshi Court pending---further the same Complainant has now made a complaint to demolish the 2 Doors leading/opening unto the Otla--is this possible when the same matter/case is Active--is it not Sub Judicial matter??
During the pendency of o.a.
Sir,I am a central govt. class-I officer and was arbitrarily transferred in march,2015 and aggrieved I filed an O.A. in CAT.I was granted stay in April,2015 but my deptt. did not allow me to resume my duty.CCP was filed.In Sep.2015 after going through their counter reply Court passed further directions for necessarily allowing me to resume my duties.My Deptt. allowed me to resume duty but by sending another officer on leave(who had joined in my place without relieving me).Surprisingly just after one month they called that officer back on duty and again relieved me in October by issuing fresh order in effect to implement the same impugned transfer order which was kept in abeyance in April,2015!the subsequent orders have been challenged through an M.A. in the O.A. A fresh CCP has been filed in the previous O.A.and notices have been issued.My query is that (1)whether the respondents can do that during the pendency of the O.A. and the CCP in O.A. in spite of the stay still continuing? (2)Do i need to file fresh O.A. challenging the subsequent orders?
(3)It has become a vicious cycle of harassment for me and aren't they taking the CAT for a ride too?
.....regards