V R SHROFF
09 February 2012 at 09:30
ALL LEADING EXPERTS PLEASE:
Kindly suggest/ give your clear Opinion about the following:
1] SHOULD WE REPLY SMS LANGUAGE QUERY
2] PL SUGGEST ISSUES THAT CAN BE TAKEN UP WITH LCI
3] ANY OTHER RELEVANT PROBLEM
4] ANY OTHER GRIEVANCE
snchandrasekarabharathi
09 February 2012 at 00:49
i want to file an application under sec. 50 of the mental health act, 1987. though there is a specific provision regarding jurisdiction under sec. 50, still the court requires a direct judgment on the jurisdiction point. Can you please help me immediately.
surajp21
08 February 2012 at 21:42
Dear Sir / Madam,
My query is as follows:
The owner of Chawls, who used to ran stock broking business also, was booked under fraud and his properties were deposited with the Maharashtra Govt under MPID Act.
Now, tenants of one of these chawls wants to form a Tenants Association to protet their interest. Due to the acts of the owner,regitration of chawl as a co-operative society got delayed and now its under court.
I wish to know:
1) what is the remedy for tenants of such chawl to get it registered as Co-operative Society? is it possible?
2) If (1) is not possible, then whether such Tenant's Association can be registered? If yes, under what ACT?
Seek your opinion.
Regards,
Suraj
jatin sharma
08 February 2012 at 20:36
hi,if any person drinking a liquor in our car on road side and police catch him with red handed then what will be the procedure follow by the police and what kind of offence was mention in fir?
thanking you.
CA VISHNU GAVKARE
08 February 2012 at 19:16
Dear sir,
which act governs the rent agreement i.e. tenent for the place situated in Maharashtra(Mumbai).
CA VISHNU GAVKARE
08 February 2012 at 19:14
Dear Sir,
I have taken a place (gala) on rent basis for 33 months for business (Commercial) Purpose.
is it beneficial to get Leave & License agreement registered in Bandra. Further if i want to register it how much it will cost including all charges i.e. preparation of agreement, franking, stamp duty(rent 12,000 pm for 33 Months & deposit 60,000/-), registration & any other charges.
what is the loss if i prepare agreement on 100 Rs. stamp paper n make notary only due to financial crunch.
CA VISHNU GAVKARE
08 February 2012 at 19:06
dear sir,
I have started with business & prepared logo for the same. please advice me how & where to register the LOGO.
R.Ramachandran
08 February 2012 at 13:51
I am opening this thread for discussion by experts with a view to arrive at a consensus on the question:
1. What is a commercial query.
2. Whether a query from an Advocate bro\theren, which obviously is to render professional service to his clients will fall under 'commercial query'.
BACKGROUND FOR THE ABOVE QUERY:
To day, there was a query from an Advocate seeking advice/experts views, in regard to a case being handled by him for his client.
Mr. V.R.Shroff (after quoting the profile of the Advocate querist) wanted to know from other experts "whether the querist Advocate deserve Answer from LCI Experts?
The points that has to be considered is:
1. What is a commercial query?
2. Whether the query raised by an Advocate bretheren to render professional service his client would fall under the category of Commercial query?
And what is/or should be our Policy in attending to such types of queries?
Mr. Arunagiri opinied that:-
We can help the aggrieved person. If any advocate wants a help from us, let him contact through email. Get the services, by paying the fees, fees may be paid by online.
Mr. Barman, was having the following view:
I slightly disagree with Mr ARUNAGIRI as being a ready reckoner for professional advocates is not what for we actually spend our time. If any advocate asks for help then he should also contribute his bit by resolving queries of others. He simply can not surface and ask queries to solve cases of their own. I support what Mr Shroff has tried to say and request my other friends to make their opinion clear and loud in this topic. I am in against of helping professional advocates though exception could be made for freshers.
Mr. Khaleel Ahmed expressed that Any body can seek legal advise through this forum. Query may be commercial or non commercial.
Mr. Sudhir Kumar said:
If a client has come and paid fee his commercial interests are served. But some advocates are really dedicated and want to help their client the best. I believe this queriest has understood limitation of his intellect and does intend to use others brain. All of us have the limitation of their intellect and greater successful men are those who can understand it and are able to identify the field where others may be knowing better than him. When god has taken incarnation still he needed help of mortals. So the god has not allowed perfect knowledge even to himself.
It is not he but all other members who get benefitted be the varied views of intellectuals. When one has decided to share knowledge on charity then it should be beyond our thought as how best the queriest uses them.
Some litigants themselves make query and get benefitted and some of them may be befitting in the trade or service. On the same time there are non-serious queriests who come to ask how best to hide their crime and are undeterred by the advise. Some of them do not like advise of not going to court and seek extra-judicial remedy. That is not the problems of those replying.
So I may be permitted to agree with Mr Arnunagiri and to say that we should allow this query.
Mr. Ramachandran said: By taking one issue of "Anonymous query", we reached some consensus and resolved that issue.
Similarly, the point which Mr. Shroff has raised here is quite interesting and the views of Mr. Barman and Arunagiri are worth considering. But this requires a separate discussion by the experts to arrive at a consensus.
I feel that we should follow the dictum of solving one issue after another. Thus as a second issue (after 'Anonymous') let us deal with this issue.
Till such time we arrive at a consensus amongst ourselves, I feel that we should answer the query so long as it is not an "Anonymous" query - unless the query is out and out from a Corporate or a Commercial query.
Deepak Nair said: I endorse the views of Mr.Sudhir and Mr.Ramachandran.
Mr.Sajid himself has stated that he is an advocate and he needs advise to sole a case handled by him. What I feel that this is the site were not only the litigants, but also a number of advocates get benifited, mainly because of this EXPERTS section. As stated by Mr.Sudhir, the querist has expressed his limitation and he is in need of help/guidance and, in my view, it is not at all wrong if the experts help a lawyer who is in need of advise to handle his case. I sincerely say that I too have availed some guidance from the learned experts for such matters which were not faced by me personally. That is the reason why i decided to contribute to the experts section. Therefore in my view, there is no wrong in answering this issue.
Mr. Ajay sethi is of the view that we should resolve the legal queries raised by other lawyers on this site. if any advocate needs a second opinion and wants help from us no harm in advising him .
Keeping the above background, other experts may contribute their views so that a consensus can be arrived on the above two issues.
I request Mr. SHROFF to take on from here to collate the views of other experts, and then to communicate the 'consensus'.
Harish Wani
08 February 2012 at 10:16
i want to start online legal consultancy. for that what permission i want to take and from where this permission take please tell me in detail....
© 2026 LAWyersclubindia.com. Let us grow stronger by mutual exchange of knowledge.
Shift duties for gazetted officers
Sir
pl guide whether Gazetted Officers (Class "A" & "B") can be detailed on Shift duties viz
0800 hrs to 1600 hrs
1600 hrs to 0000 hrs
0000 hrs to 0800 hrs
thanking you
yours faithfully
nks prasad