LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Dilip   26 August 2014 at 22:53

Legal analysis of high court judgement

Dear Experts,
A judgement of Hon'ble Guwahati High Court has come in my favour. I was appointed as a Teacher in AR and since the very first date I am teaching in Children School. And after more than 60 years an attempt is initiated to deploy me in Non-teaching activities and instructional duty to Troops for which I was not appointed. I challenged the order of the same and the order of the CAT in Hon'ble High Court and thus the Order. Now I want an expert analysis on this and valuable suggestion on this. The judgement is as under :-
Heard Sri R Mazumdar, learned counsel for the petitioner and Smt. B Das, learned Central govt. counsel.

Petitioners were appointed as Hindi teacher to teach Hindi to the jawans. On occasion they were drafted to schools run by Assam Rifles to teach Hindi to the students. Petitioners were repatriated from the schools and they are now directed to attend to civil works and also to assist jawans in combat operation. Petitioners challenged the said order before CAT. The CAT found nothing offensive in the order that directs petitioners to discharge duties of civil nature and as well duties relating to combatant operation. Petitioners aggrieved by the said order filed this petition.

The counsel for the petitioner submits that duties relating to combatant operation are onerous and not part of their job chart, and there is a risk element too. Petitioners being civil teachers appointed to teach Hindi to the jawans they should be confined to the said duty only, the other duty should not be added to their job chart.

The counsel for the respondent strenuously submits that the charter of duties prescribed by circular dated 15th July, 2013, now in challenge, cannot be assailed and petitioners are bound to comply with the posting orders and to discharge their duties.

The counsel for the petitioner per contra submits that option was given to the Hindi teachers to choose between combatant duty and duty of a civil teacher. All of them opted to remain as civil teacher. Therefore they cannot be enjoined to do the duties of combatant nature.

Upon consideration of the facts and material it is to be seen that petitioners have not opted for combatant duty; they opted to remain as civil teacher. Therefore they have to be treated as civil teacher and they are bound to discharge duties of civil nature. If there are any vacant civil posts in that event petitioners who are civil teachers can be posted to such vacant posts(of any nature) as a temporary measure until the said posts are filled and till then petitioners should not refuse to discharge such functions. In that view of the matter the writ petition is disposed of.

Pradyot   26 August 2014 at 21:41

Complaint to supreme court

I want to complaint to supreme court against corruption in consumer court in Mumbai with documentary proofs. I send a registered letter to Registrar Sc Delhi but it was refusd 7returned back.
let me know how to send complaint to supreme court

radha@77   26 August 2014 at 20:46

Pil

Sir, I want to File a PIL in Supreme Court of India . But i don,t Know the Procedure and don't Have enough money to Hire a Lawyer. So Please help me .

Suraj L Vaswani   26 August 2014 at 20:11

Marriage registration

Hello Experts:

One of my muslim friend recently got married and it was an arranged marriage. Grateful, if anyone could help me understanding how does he get his marriage registered? What documents are required for the registration? What are the fees, etc.

Cheers!
Suraj

sigatapu naga seshu kiran kuma   26 August 2014 at 16:45

Icici lombard property linked insurance policy --- not covered disease--reg

Dear Sir,


Very respectfully bring the following facts of the case for your valuable and breathing suggestion for over coming the hurdle.


Sir,

My uncle purchased the Residential flat at Visakhapatnam on 30.10.2007 from Dharani Constructions by way of home loan from ICICI Bank, visahpatnam for an amount of Rs.6.00Lakhs and same was registered in mu uncles name.

I further humbly bring to you that, at the time of sanction of house loan by the ICICI banker insisted us for taking property linked term insurance policy ( in case of death of insured the debt amount of Rs.6.00Lakhs waived) from ICICI Lombard for an amount of Rs.30,000/- for a period of 5 years, at the instructions of the bank we bought the policy which was ended on 31.10.2012.

unfortunately on 02.12.2012 my uncle demised with leaver disease leaving behind my aunty and four daughters. later we filed claim form which was sent by ICICI bank and same was submitted along medical bills.

after prolonged time the Insurer returned the our claim with a letter that your disease not covered under policy, whereas the claim for consists of liver disease.

immediately we sent a letter to insurer about his indiscriminate action, but no replay and no action, finally we lodged a complaint before district consumer redressal forum same was numbered and sent notices to insurer.

NOW THEY RAISED THAT YOUR POLICY EXPIRED and we are not responsible.

so kindly help us for how to over com this.


your most respectfully

sasikiran


SACHIN KUMAR SHARMA   26 August 2014 at 14:56

Expert for credit co-operative society

I want to register a Credit Co-Opeartive Society in Meerut so please suggest me Expert in Meerut for registration of Credit Co-Operative Society.

Please suggest me any local Lawyer with Name and Contact Details for the above.

Baidhya Nath Nayak   26 August 2014 at 11:24

Need/want to get acquiant with laws

Hi
I am not a law person(that is related to law directly)I need/want to know all the laws existing in our country .
May be this is not the correct forum for this kind of query but I believe a law expert can only tell how to get acquintaed with law,instead of doing a google search .

apology If this is a wrong forum ,but intention is not to misuse this forum .
Thanks experts..

Sultan   26 August 2014 at 00:00

Taking photo illegal


Being an noise pollution & RTI activist, whenever there is violation of rules, I usually click pictures as evidence for future, is it unlawfull.


further is taking pictures in public hospital is unlawfull.


( no woman pictures are taken, care is taken to avoid confrontation)


Raushan   25 August 2014 at 21:14

Janhit yachika

If there is any possibility to submit a Janhit yachika for public interest against school vans which are running on roads with private permits,without follow any traffic rules ?
They must not carrying valid docs and any first aid boxes in the Van. They are carrying students above their seating capacity. They are breaking rules and playing with life of children. This is dangerous for future of our country. Thease are happening all over India.(Specially in major cities). Please suggest.

Please reply.

arunkumark   25 August 2014 at 19:38

Audit of cooperative housing society

The 16 members society does not want the managing committee to follow all the bye laws strictly. like change of user/not paying the maintenence/storage of material in the passages/drainage system rule etc because of that they refuse to accept/approve the audit report in the Agm. they just dont sign for approval of audit report but also not mentioning any reason for not approving the audit report. Is it necesary to approve the audit report by all the members including defaulter members ( 101 mcs act proceeding pending).only managing committee approves the audit report which is sufficient or not.please advise whether we should approach dy registrar to appoint their representative at the time of agm