KETAN MANDANI
09 May 2015 at 16:51
Dear Sir,
I have just signed up for lawyer's club India, website..
I have a particular issue regarding Parking in co-operative housing society.
I live in a rented flat in a 13 storied building in Kandivali (west) in Mumbai. I own a four wheeler Car. The landlord stays in Europe, and have given power of Attorney to his father in law staying in Ghatkopar, Mumbai, who signs rent agreement with me every year.
My society (Building A) is in a larger premises having four other buildings (building C, D and E).
There are 51 flats in my building, out of which only one flat (i.e. mine) is on rental basis and all the others are on ownership basis.
Each building has its own internal parking area where they have demarcated parking space. plus there is an access road connecting all the buildings, on both sides of which, parking spaces is there. The four buildings viz. A, C, D & E have formed an Apex Body which has taken up the ownership of access road and have distributed parking space within four buildings recently. Accordingly, my building (A) has been allocated four car parking to be given to its members.
Now the issue is as follows :
the society of my building (A) every year conducts a draw / lottery for allocation of parking space in its 'own' internal parking space (where approx. 27 parking space is available compared to more no. of cars). However, the society did not include my car in the lottery citing that I am staying on rental basis and all the other people on ownership basis have objected to inclusion of my name. I did not object at that time; and placed my car on Access Road where parking so far was on 'First Come First Serve' basis. If I didn't get parking, I had to park the car on main road. Similarly, for all those who didn't get parking in lottery system, parked their cars on access road if available; or else outside. but most of the flat owners had two cars; one allotted in society parking area and other placed on access road.
Recently, the four buildings made an apex body (of A, C, D & E). and took up the road and distributed parking amongst themselves as mentioned above. My society has been allocated four Car Parking Spaces. In my society (building A), there are five excess cars including mine (Excess cars are those cars which didn't get parking space in lottery system in society's internal parking area).
Ideally, the society was expected to further conduct a draw / lottery of these four car parking space, to accommodate four out of five cars including mine. But once again they did the same thing, i.e. excluded me because of my 'rental' status and distributed four car parking spaces amongst themselves because of which I had to keep my car outside the premises ie.. on road on first come first serve basis. All these four cars are second cars of their owners. whereas I have only one car. I had requested the society to consider my car in the lottery of atleast access road if not in the society's parking space; but they did not consider the same.
My question is :
1) First of all, can society allocate its own parking space (internal parking) through lottery system or it has to be on first come first serve basis? Even if society has allocated internal car parking through lottery, can they exclude tenants (ie. families staying on rent)? Don't rental members have equal rights on society's resources? Can society discriminate against families staying on rental basis while conducting lottery system? shouldn't the car be considered as the car of Flat no. xxx from which the society has been getting regular maintenance?
2) Regarding Access Road : Can Apex body of four societies distribute parking space on Access Road amongst four buildings against collection of deposit? or the parking on access has to be on first come first serve basis? Also, even if it has allocated parking space amongst four buildings, can my society allocate parking through lottery system or the parking on these four spaces have to be based on availability?
Next Most important question is : Can my society exclude me from lottery / draw of four car parking space allocated to it on the access road, & thus distribute amongst four members? Can they discriminate against tenant?
I would request you to kindly guide me so that I can protect my rights as a tenant having equal rights to 'use' the common resources of the society. I am ready to pay the parking deposit and monthly charges.
I would be greatful to receive Experts' opinion (with relevant section of any act, if possible). and what further actions can I (& should I) take?
Thanks and Regards
Ketan Mandani
Mumbai
ketanmandani@rediffmail.com
nagaraja
09 May 2015 at 14:10
What is the meaning of DTCP Approval
1. While providing Approval , whether DTCP will insist for Good Roads , Drinking Water facilities - for any ventures
2. What are the mandatory points required for DTCP Layout approval ??
3. Covered Car Parking in the ground floor is permitted by Chennai Tamilnadu government ?
Naga Raja
Respected experts,
please help me out with three queries with regard to division of property among Muslims under personal law-
1.if a Muslim women has certain property in her name say 100 rupees earned by the women, and if such women dies intestate leaving behind only daughter and a husband, what would be the share of each them.will the daughter would be entitled to the whole property or husband is also entitled to some share, if yes what would be his share.
2.if a Muslim husband and a wife is living separately for more than 20 yrs, would there marriage be subsist and is annulled? note- they are living seperately without judicial separation or under any provision, they have not seen each other for 20 yrs.
chandrasekhar
08 May 2015 at 17:48
Sir/Madam,
I have been notified that, DKT land is for sale in Andhrapradesh.
Need your help to have clarifications for the below points.
1) DKT Land and DKT Patta are one and the same ? If not , what's the difference.
2) Is Granted/Assigned Land and DKT land are one and the same ? If not , what's the difference.
3) Are we allowed to purchase DKT land ? Considering that current owner of DKT land does not belong to SC/ST.
4) What are the mandatory documents that has to be verified before buying DKT land?
5) Are the registrations allowed for the DKT land especially in AP? and will there be any passbooks issued for DKT land ?
6) Are the bank loans possible on DKT land(as security) ?
7) Are those DKT land's eligible for government subsidies ? such Irrigation drip etc.., ?
Please help to have clarificaitons for above points.
Also please provide if there is any weblink to the AndhraPradesh goverment law act document.
Anonymous
08 May 2015 at 16:53
Respected legal experts,
An immovable property was purchased by a mother in name of her three minor sons via agreement to sell in 1973.The three minor sons executed a registered gpa in favour of their mother in 1973.The sale deed couldn't be obtained because the colony was unauthorised.Later on,all the three sons gave up their all and absolute rights by giving statements before s.d.m and the statements are registered with the s.d.m in 1984 when they attained majority.
The mother then transferred the property to her husband on notarised gpa in 1985 as gpas were also banned by then.She died in 2003.
The husband then gifted the property to his grandson through a registered gift deed in 2015.The sub registrar checked all the papers and the deed is duly stamped and registered.
The said documents have also been accepted for mutation.
Can any of the sons still claim title to the property?
srinivas
08 May 2015 at 12:45
my mother is aged 80 years and want to give a plot in karnataka which is in her name(bought by my father) to three of her daughters equally .is making will is beetr or doping a gift deed is better
2) which will be easy and economical
3) if taking mutation at a a laterstage by my sisters will be costly and lenghthy process
4) i am the only son and my mother does not want to give any share in that .is that fine and legal.
pl reply pointwise
thanks in advance
rohansingh
08 May 2015 at 08:17
Hello Sir, my father Mr.A and Mr.B were 2 brothers. Due to some dispute my grandfather had to leave his native place without taking concern in his father's property part. According to Will of my grandfather, I am the owner of a shop property, my mother is the owner of a house property. The will had been submitted into the court and we are not available with the hardcopy of that Will. So how can I sell that property in my name.
Also my mother wants to tranfer her property in my name. What is the procedure to do that?
Please suggest the way out as I am badly in need.
Thanks in advance
hunny singh
07 May 2015 at 19:44
my father gifted me part of his property to me as gift deed,which is registered in court of law, dis property is sole owner of my grandfather and free hold property, this property was owned by him during partion of india pakistan, by his hard earning, this gift deed is made without knowlegde of his other sons and daughter, and rest of the property . he had made registered will, he is mentally fit and active at the age of 95, as all his expensive are incured by me .can anyone can challenge this deed or can u suggest anyother documents required to make my hands safe,
thanking you
Abhishek
07 May 2015 at 19:27
Hi,
Is it possible to convert Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC) industrial land,which is on lease, to freehold land/ commercial land. If yes, What are the relevant clauses/references in MIDC Act. Apart from this, If this land is being subleased, is it possible for sub-lessee to use the industrial land for some other purpose for which such land was originally allotted.
Nri power of attorney registration
Sir,
I would like to purchase the site in bangalore but owner in usa his father wants sell the property through notary gpa from usa
He says register in this gpa, when the owner comes do the register certification from registered office, i would like to know is it valid and what is the process.