disputed ownership

rajesh makol (Querist) 22 March 2013 This query is : Resolved
mr A sold a dda flat to B via registered GPA in noida. on same date A executed Will And payment receipt in favour of C in delhi. Before A died B sold flat to D. Is D entitled to ownership or C can claim. The receipt in favor of C does not mention the object of consideration. it merele says received ... in advance.

Follow Query

Report Abuse

ajay sethi (Expert) 22 March 2013
it is necessary to go through the papers to advise .
as mentioned earlier you give only half baked facts .
you have not mentioned dates of transaction also not given replies to queries rasied earlier.
consult a local lawyer .

Adv k . mahesh (Expert) 22 March 2013
without the transaction papers cannot say correctly

prabhakar singh (Expert) 23 March 2013
Title of property can not be deemed to have passed on to B from A just on the basis of a
registered GPA (even if it conferred a right
to sale by B on behalf of A).

Title was not passed from A to even C just on the basis that on same date A executed Will And payment receipt in favor of C in Delhi.But since consideration was received
it would amount to an act of fraud committed by A on C as on the same date A registered a GPA in favor of B in Noida

If right to sale was conferred by by GPA of A to B and before A died B sold flat to D,then it is here that LEGALLY TITLE WOULD BE DEEMED TO HAVE PASSED ON FROM A TO D EVEN IF SALE DEED WAS SIGNED BY B ON BEHALF OF A ON THE BASIS OF GPA.

THE WILL FROM A TO C CAN TAKE EFFECT ONLY AFTER THE DEATH OF A.

THEN D HAS CONCLUSIVE TITLE OVER WHAT WAS SOLD TO HIM BY B ON BEHALF OF A AGAINST C WHO IS BENEFICIARY OF WILL BY A TO HIM