LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

B S Kainth   27 November 2012 at 19:34

Sa dispense

Respected Members ,
I would like to put-up my query which is as follows "In Complaint case ,If complainant fail to establish his allegation on accuse which are written in the complaint ,can the statement of accuse be dispensed" If yes U/s ? any judgment for reference ?

With Regards
B Kainth

Sorry, I was unable to explain the circumstances .I am elaborating my query

. Complainant was filed u/s156/3(200) CRPC
2. Pree Charge summoning was made in the absence in accuse
3. Later accuse came to know that Lawyer of complainant got typed the statement on its own.
4. At the stage of chief and cross examination all the witnesses of complainant and complainant himself failed to prove what they had said in pre charge statement.
5. Now it’s time for the statement of accuse
Can the statement of accuse be dispensed" If yes U/s ? any judgment for reference ?

B S Kainth   27 November 2012 at 18:34

Sa dispense

Respected Members ,
I would like to put-up my query which is as follows "In Complaint case ,If complainant fail to establish his allegation on accuse which are written in the complaint ,can the statement of accuse be dispensed" If yes U/s ? any judgment for reference ?

With Regards
B Kainth

Sorry, I was unable to explain the circumstances .I am elaborating my query which is :-

1. Complaint was filed u/s156/3(200) CRPC
2. Pre Charge summoning was made in the absence in accuse
3. Later accuse came to know that Lawyer of complainant got typed the statement on its own.
4. At the stage of chief and cross examination all the witnesses of complainant and complainant himself failed to prove what they had said in pre charge statement.
5. Now it’s time for the statement of accuse
can the statement of accuse be dispensed" If yes U/s ? any judgment for reference ?

Bhuwan Bhatt   27 November 2012 at 15:52

Does admonishment amounts to conviction.

Does Admonishment under IPC 279 amounts to conviction?

Nakibur Rahman   27 November 2012 at 14:30

Ingredients of 409

Respected Sir,

Please advice whether my submission in the following are correct or not or if any expert can modify the same
Since the matter is Evidence before charge.

On 14/08/2007 learned council for complainant submitted document in connection with construction of civil hospital those are (1) Deed of Partnership (2) General Power of Attorney (GPA) and (3) some other document.
The Deed of Partnership produced is irrelevant for the said work. The entire work was allotted in the name of x not in the name of M/s Y. Enterprise. Fact is that the firm M/s Y Enterprise died before born and the GPA is also irrelevant for X’s work, because GPA is to handle the work of M/s Y Enterprise only, to work in my own firm I don’t need any ones General Power of Attorney nowhere in the agreement with any Department or in the work order of the department is mentioned the name of the firm M/s Y Enterprise.
In the sheweth of the complainant at serial No. 6 (six) stated by the complainant that “..it would be relevant to mention here that at the time of get allotment of the aforesaid works in his name the accused person induced the complainant to execute a Power of Attorney in his favour...) ...” is false, the notice inviting tender for the work at AAA ITI was called on 22/07/2005 and work was allotted X on 29/08/2005 and the power of attorney was executed on 09/09/2005. (P.O.A. was executed after allotment of the work).
In response to some other document submitted by the complainant, I don’t know what document the complainant produced before the court but I clarify that a loan was applied before the SBI AA main branch against property mortgage of the complainant and the same was granted to M/s Y Enterprise and the loan amount was deposited in the personal Bank account at the same bank in the account of complainant (Mr. B) with our consent but it is not known to me for what he (Mr. B) made expenses and no accounts was given to me for the said loan till date. Rather he send a letter on 08/10/2006 without my knowledge (Enclosed as Annexure - I) to the Manager State Bank of India requesting to intimate D.C. to realize the balance amount from my account without sending me a copy of the letter but the D.C. did not do so, the complainant further stated in the same letter that “.. we have no interest at all to continue this firm any further...... Since our firm no longer exist so, I am afraid to mortgage my property any further....” this information was not given to me even I was not informed about the dissolution of the firm, information about dissolution of the firm was mandatory according to the deed of agreement, complainant motto was to cheat me as they could not successes. Therefore these entire allegations they have put before the Hon’ble court with such sets of documents which has no connection with my business. I am in the business since long back the complainant himself stated in the process of evidence that “since I was a 1st class Govt. registered contractor..... One 1st class contractor have to be solvent, so there claim regarding poor financial condition of mine is false (Enclosed two Solvency certificate one is for the year 2004 and another for the year 2006.As Annexure – F & G)
I pray to the Hon’ble court not to charge the matter U/s 409 for the following reasons
For ingredients of section 409 one has to be public servant, or banker, merchant or agent, I am none of these I am owner of my own firm with name & style X as such I have the absolute ownership rights regarding my firm I am not holding a position of trust of others, of course some financial transaction was there which was just hand loan as usual.
No criminal breach of trust ever done from my part, since no entrustment can be done of one owns firm by other person so breach of trust does not arise.
Till date I have not use the Deed of Partnership and the Power of Attorney for any contract works.
The complainant stated in his sheweth that they sent messenger to my house but they never mentioned the name of those messengers and never produced before the court as evidence.
If I ignored the complainant, they could have sent me the accounts by Post for their claim or they could have send me legal notice, they did not do so and without submitting any accounts to me they choose to knock the door of court reason is best known to them.
Please allow me to humbly coat some excerpt of citations: 1965 AIR 1433, 1965 SCR (2) 429 which might be relevant to decide the matter. .
CRIMINAL APPELLATE, JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No. 43 of 1963.
Appeal by special leave from the judgment and order dated February 1, 1963 of the Bombay High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 972 of 1962.
....there is really no partner's share in the property until an account (sic) and it may well be that a partner, who retains an asset, is entitled not only to his share according to the partnership agreement in that asset, but, on taking an account, it may be found that he is entitled to the whole of the asset and considerably more. In such a case, how can it be said that he has been of a breach of trust and has acted dishonestly towards his co- partners, if an account would show that he was entitled to everything which he had retained?”
in Bhuban Mohan Rana's case(1) by the later Full Bench of the Calcutta High Court is the right one... it is obvious that before a person can be said to have committed criminal breach of trust it must be established that he was either entrusted with or entrusted with dominion over property which he is said to have converted to his own use or disposed of in violation of any direction of law etc.
In order to establish "entrustment of dominion" over property to an accused person the mere existence of that person's dominion over property is not enough. It must be further shown that his dominion was the result of entrustment. Therefore, as rightly pointed out by Harris C.J., the prosecution must establish that dominion over the assets or a particular asset of the partnership was, by a special agreement between the parties, entrusted to the accused person. If in the absence of such a special agreement a partner receives money belonging to the partnership he cannot be said to have received it in a fidu- ciary capacity or in other words cannot be hold to have been "entrusted" with dominion over partnership properties.

PRADEEP KUMAR BANSAL   27 November 2012 at 03:37

Compliance of section 207 crpc not possible as statements u/s 161 crpc reported by io/sho/dycp- lost

QUERRY :-


- IT IS SUBMITTED BY ACCUSED BEFORE THE REVISIONAL COURT
- THAT COMPLIANCE OF SECTION 207 Cr.P.C. IS MANDATORY
- A FAIR TRIAL IS NOT POSSIBLE AS THE COPIES OF STATEMENTS OF WITNESSES U/S 161 Cr.P.C. CANNOT BE RECONSTRUCTED AS POLICE FILE IS NOT TRACEABLE AS
REPORTED BY I.O./S.H.O./Dy.C.P.
- THE POLICE REPORT WAS NOT FILED AS PER SECTION 173 Cr.P.C, THEREFORE IT SHOULD BE REJECTED
- THE PROSECUTION CANNOT OPEN THE CASE BEFORE THE SESSIONS COURT AS THE COMMITAL HAS NOT BEEN MADE U/S 209 Cr.P.C WHICH CAN BE MADE ONLY AFTER COMPLIANCE OF SECTION 207 Cr.P.C.
- THE FAIR TRIAL CAN NOT BE HELD AND THEREFORE ACCUSED PERSONS BE DISCHARGED

WHETHER ANY JUDGEMENTS OF SUPREME COURT ARE THERE IN SUPPORT OF THE ABOVE, PLEASE GIVE CITATIONS

THE DETAILS OF THE CASE ARE AS UNDER :-

- AN FIR WAS LODGED AGAINST THE THREE ACCUSED PERSONS U/S 308 IPC IN 1994. THE CHARGE SHEET WAS FILED IN THE MAGISTRATE’S COURT IN MAY 1995.
- TWO ACCUSED WERE PROVIDED 15 DOCUMENTS OUT OF TOTAL 33 FILED WITH CHARGE SHEET. ONE ACCUSED WAS NOT PROVIDED ANY DOCUMENTS AT ALL.
- THE ACCUSED IMMEDIATELY MOVE ONE APPLICATION BEFORE THE MAGISTRATE FOR PROVIDING THE REMAINING DOCUMENTS GIVING THE LIST OF THE SAME
- THE ACCUSED ALSO MOVED ANOTHER APPLICATION THAT STATEMENTS OF WITNESSES U/S 161 Cr.P.C. HAVE NOT BEEN PROVIDED.
- THE SAME WERE NOT PROVIDED TO THE ACCUSED AND WITHOUT COMPLIANCE OF SECTION 207 Cr.P.C., THE CASE WAS COMMITED TO THE SESSIONS COURT IN 2004.
- THE ACCUSED PERSONS FILED APPLICATIONS BEFORE SESSIONS COURT THAT COMPLIANCE OF SECTION 207 Cr.P.C. HAS NOT BEEN MADE BY MAGISTRATE BEFORE COMMITTAL OF THE CASE AND COPIES OF SEVERAL DOCUMENTS AND STATEMENTS OF WITNESSES U/S 161 Cr.P.C. HAVE NOT BEEN PROVIDED TO THE ACCUSED.
- THE SESSIONS COURT SUMMONED THE I.O. WHO REPORTED THAT THE POLICE FILE IS NOT TRACEABLE AND THEREFORE HE IS UNABLE TO PROVIDE COPIES OF STATEMENTS OF WITNESSES U/S 161 Cr.P.C. (WHICH WERE NOT FILED WITH THE CHALLAN)
- THE SESSIONS COURT SUMMONED THE S.H.O. ALSO WHO REPORTED THAT THE POLICE FILE IS NOT TRACEABLE AND CASE DIARY IS NOT AVAILABLE IN THE VRK AND THE RECORD CAN NOT BE RECONSTRUCTED AND THEREFORE HE IS UNABLE TO PROVIDE COPIES OF STATEMENTS OF WITNESSES U/S 161 Cr.P.C. (WHICH WERE NOT FILED WITH THE CHALLAN)
- THE SESSIONS COURT SENT BACK THE CASE TO MAGISTRATE IN 2011 FOR COMPLIANCE OF SECTION 207 Cr.P.C. AND COMMIT THE CASE AS PER MANDATE OF Cr.P.C. AND SEEK ASSISTANCE OF TOP POLICE OFFICER
- THE MAGISTRATE SUMMONED Dy.C.P. WHO ALSO REPORTED THAT THE POLICE FILE IS NOT TRACEABLE AND CASE DIARY IS NOT AVAILABLE IN THE VRK AND THE RECORD CAN NOT BE RECONSTRUCTED AND SHO CRIME REGISTER HAS BEEN DESTROYED AND THEREFORE HE IS UNABLE TO PROVIDE COPIES OF STATEMENTS OF WITNESSES U/S 161 Cr.P.C. (WHICH WERE NOT FILED WITH THE CHALLAN)
- THE MAGISTRATE RE-COMMITTED THE CASE TO SESSIONS COURT IN 2012 WITHOUT COMPLIANCE OF 207 Cr.P.C. BUT RECORDING IN THE COMMITTAL ORDER THAT COMPLIANCE OF SECTION 207 Cr.P.C. HAS BEEN DONE AND COPIES OF STATEMENTS OF WITNESSES U/S 161 Cr.P.C. ARE NOT REQUIRED TO BE PROVIDED TO ACCUSED AS THOSE WERE NOT FILED WITH THE CHALLAN.
- THE ACCUSED HAVE FILED REVISION U/S 397 Cr.P.C. AGAINST NON-COMPLIANCE OF ORDER OF 2011 OF SESSIONS COURT BY THE MAGISTRATE.









neeraj dahiya   27 November 2012 at 00:42

Fresh bail

hi,
court of session granted bail in 304B in the year 2009. trial commenced. accused appeared daily. after examination of two witnesses, one of the moved to high court for discharge. Delhi HC directed the trial court frame the charge to 302 against all the accused persons.
WHETHER FRESH BAIL APPLICATION IS REQUIRED?

Victor   26 November 2012 at 23:30

498a dp 4 & 6

MM court of City of Great Hyderabad is making both parties to attend court since last Nov 2011 even though both 498a parties compromised in writing. Court Initially told 90 observations, then extended due PP unavailability, then again extended 90 days due compromised signed papers missing? Every time some reason for next date???

My counsel as well as PP says that DP act 4 & 6 are main section than 498 so it can't be compromised? Hence possible delays.

Does this mean husband & wife should not be compromised & living together as earlier wife booked case under 498a 4&6 sections ???

Experts please reply.

Rahul Sabharwal   26 November 2012 at 13:48

Quashing in punjab and haryana hc

Hello to the respected lawyers,

My father has been accused of forging and cheating under s. 420 and 467,468 and 471 IPC and also under Prevention of Corruption Act. The FIR was registered on 22.6.2007 and my father was remanded to custody by the court at Moga, Punjab on 25.6.2007 and he was given bail only on 13.12.2007. The IO has deliberately not filed the challan till now just to harass him. For the past one year the court has been giving long dates as the challan has not been filed. I want to now can this case be quashed by the Punjab Haryana HC because the challan has not been filed all these years.

Waiting for your valuable opinion.