LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

newnimproved   08 March 2013 at 09:24

Can i file an fir and criminal case against my ca for cheating?

My chartered accountant has taken bearer cheques from me and claims he has filed all my tax returns from 2009-2012. When I ask him to gives me the returns and challans he goes on postponing it and coming with one excuse or another. It is really stressful and I think he is duping me.

Question:

Can I file criminal case against my CA for cheating?

Can I put out a newspaper ad about his shenangians?

What legal recourse do I have at my hand?

Thank you for your time and advise.



Tanmay   08 March 2013 at 09:06

Quashing of 498a for divorce settlement

Hello all,

My wife has filed a false 498a on me and my family members. Now they have come for settlement.

They are demanding rights on a joint property for which I am ready to relinquish the rights by providing a release deed. I want to give this as part of the Quashing/Withdrawal of 498a.

I want to know if withdrawal is easier in the lower court or Quashing in the High court.

Either way I am fine. But I want to know which is quicker and easier, so that the process can get completed faster.

Stage of 498a: Chargesheet filed and only the first hearing is over. No charges framed as yet.

Can experts please advise. Any advise in this regard is highly appreciated.

Thanks in advance for your time and help.

Regards,
Tanmay

shujauddin   08 March 2013 at 01:07

Jurisdiction of court for trial complaint against offence u/s 406 ipc

dear sir, my client resides at bilaspur c.g and accused at Gaya Bihar. the forged LIC policy also belongs to Gaya and also executed at Gaya but complainant had transferred the amount of premium in many installments through his bank acc at Bilaspur to the accused's bank acc at Gaya. now the complaint of sec 406 IPC can be filed at Bilaspur, if yes, so is there any citation similar to this. plz help.

Member (Account Deleted)   07 March 2013 at 23:13

Evidence stage

After regular bail when do evidence stage come.
What is the procedure of evidence stage?

Divya   07 March 2013 at 21:32

Fir contents about apex court decisions

hello Experts

1. Can an FIR include any points of apex court decisions to support criminal allegations against the accused..

2. can FIR include any details of our country's acts or other acts in support of criminal allegations.

Please assist.

Thankyou

PVG Satish   07 March 2013 at 19:06

Out of the court settlement in petty cases

In petty cases viz. simple assault, verbal abuse etc. can the aggrieved person in his complaint to the police express his intention to settle the matter out of the court with the offender? If yes, can he also mention the amount of money he wishes to receive from the offender as compensation?

I understand that the police will counsel the parties involved and persuade them to settle the matter without going to the court. However, I'm just curious to know if it can be mentioned in the complaint itself.

A specimen is given hereunder, kindly let me know how it sounds.

"Understanding the petty nature of the crime and in the interest of saving time for the court, the police and myself, I would like to settle this matter out of the court for a compensation of Rs. 5000 and a letter of apology from Mr. X"

In this case, if the offender is not ready to compromise and in turn threatens the aggrieved of filing a (false) case against him, is it not prima facie a case of wrongly setting the law in motion? Understanding that a case of malicious prosecution can be initiated only after one's acquittal and proving malice, what can the aggrieved in this case do to convince police to not to initiate a case against him?

Many thanks.

Adv. Mohan Chandra   07 March 2013 at 15:10

U/s 138 at argument stage

Friends

During the last hearing the Ld. Metropolitan Magistrate had inquired on the method of Argument (oral or written)I had suggested oral argument.

Now instead of proceeding with the oral argument the Ld. M.M. has suggested that both the parties submit a copy of written argument for reference and subsequently oral argument will follow.

Now my query is is it necessary to disclose all the facts in the written argument. My intention to conduct oral argument was to keep some surprise elements and if disclosed in the written argument the other party may be prepared.

Thanking you

Mohan


Dharmesh Arora   06 March 2013 at 16:53

Rti - 498a/406

Sir/Madam

Please let me know which documents out of the following we can get from the Police as per RTI for the F.I.R being registered under sections 498A/406

1. Copy of complaint
2. Copy of case diary
3. Copy of Daaj List
4. Copy of Bills given by complainant
5. Copy of Evidences given by complainant
6. Copy of Police Report
7. Copy of complainant’s Byaan
8. Copy of other parties Byaan
9. Copy of Attendance/Roll Call

Thanks

Hareshkumar Shrimali   06 March 2013 at 16:06

Conviction in ipc 498-a, 306 by surendranagar sessions court in 2008 , criminal appeal before gujara

Hello Experts,
I was Convicted under IPC 498-A, 306 by Surendranagar Sessions Court in 2008 , Criminal Appeal before Gujarat HC. I am on Regular Conditional Bail.I am 51 to-day & am B.Sc., FICWA, CAIIB, LLB. I got married on 07-05-1987.My only & only Son Kevin came on the earth on 31-10-1988. My late FIL was a Retd. Deputy Collector & practising lawyer till my wife committed suicide in Dec-1996.My late Eldest BIL was M.Sc., LLB, my elder(52) id MA, LLB, B.Ed. & serving at A'bad Mercantile co-op. Bank Ltd. since last more than 20 years. I was serving at Punjab National Bank, Surendranagar Branch from my native Limbdi. My late wife was also serving as " Mukhya Sevika" under Dist. Panchayat, Surendranagar at Limbdi & some villages of Limbdi. We were staying seperately after 7-8 months of marriage.
My Complete Facts are toooooo much long & much more complex . Plz, Sir Guide me if you are absolutely Sure my following queries :
My late BIL ( the original Complainant in Criminal Case ) & my elder BIL filed a Civil Suit under Section 5 of GAWA to be appointed Guardians for the person & Property of my Son Kevin at City Civil Court,A'bad in 1997.They prayed for interlocutory injunction in this suit. My 1st Query is :
1) Under GAWA , if any person/s want to be appointed a uit can be Guardian for Minor's Person & Property, a Civil Suit can be maintainable/sustainable under section 5 of GAWA ( The Guardians & Wards Act )?
2) After taking this Legal Point still City Civil Court( & thereafter Family Court ) did not take any action case continued. After getting Guj.HC's Directives twice, Family Court didn't complete all Proceedings.
3) I gave an Application to City Civil Court ( Chamber Summons ) to lodge Perjury case against both my BIL & SIL as they misguided the C.C.C.A'bad to take interlocutory injunction ( on oath, on seperately filed Affidavit in support of Exh. 6), after a period of 7 years, Family Court rejected this Perjury Application saying only that in this, no main point is concerned. I took speaking Order from Gujarat HC that if Plaintiffs ( my BIL & SIL ) not produce all the listed documents & proofs within a week's time, the case must be discarded & Counter Claim by defendents' prayers must be heard. Nothing happened till my Son became 18 & this matter became infroctuous.

Please Answer me,step by step in . Company at Ahmedabad.
One thing I forgot to mention, I filed Criminal Appeal after rejection of my Perjury Appln. by Family Court,A'bad at Guj. HC Division Bench. My Advocate was not loyal, I changed 6 lawyers in-between 1997 to 2007, even at Gujarat HC. He or his Junior Lady Asst. never appeared nor informed me abt dates of my Appeal after Admission. Last Order of my Criminal Appeal No.300/2002 is as under :
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL No 300 of 2002
--------------------------------------------------------------
HARESHKUMAR JAYANTILAL ALIAS JAGJIVAN SHRIMALI
Versus
SHAILESHKUMAR NATHALAL
--------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
1. Criminal Appeal No. 300 of 2002
MR BM MANGUKIYA for Appellant No.
MS BELA A PRAJAPATI for Appellant No.
MR PJ YAGNIK for Appellant No.
MR SHITAL R PATEL for Respondent No. 1-2
MS HARSHA DEVANI, APP for Respondent No. 3
--------------------------------------------------------------
CORAM : HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE KSHITIJ R.VYAS
and
HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE AKSHAY H.MEHTA
Date of Order: 14/09/2004
ORAL ORDER
(Per : HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE KSHITIJ R.VYAS)
1. The Division Bench of this Court had on 25/6/2003
granted three weeks time to the appellant to furnish the
paper book and registry was directed to list the appeal
for final hearing after the paper book is supplied. Even
though more than a year is passed, the appellant has not
supplied the paper book. The R & P is lying idle in the
office and consequently the pending matter before the
Family Court is not proceeded further.
2. With a view to give one more chance to the
appellant, we grant two weeks time to the appellant to
prepare and supply the paper book, failing which the
appellant will lose his right for early disposal of the
appeal. On the expiry of two weeks, the Registry will
return the R & P to the Family Court.
[ KSHITIJ R. VYAS, J.]
[ AKSHAY H. MEHTA, J.]
* Pansala.
1 of 1
CRIMINAL APPEAL/300/2002 06/03/2013 04:00:46 PM

===X===

What must I do ? HC could hv rejected my Appeal, but it's strong, hence one more chance has been given by HC Ex-Parte ( without my Adv. B.M. Mangukiya or Junior Belaben Prajapati ). I was not informed abt Date, I was staying at Limbdi at this time. Sir, please answer & guide me step by step.

Joy Vadakkan   06 March 2013 at 11:00

Theft .

Recently one of the Apartment was burgled when the owner was away. The Secretary of the Apt.Assocn reported to Police. the Police could nab the thief with finger prints. The Police reported that he was produced before the Magistrate and sent to jail/custody. The inspector told case closed.On further contacting the Police they told owner has to file a petition for getting the articles they could seize from the thief. Only 10% value of the lost articles could able to be recovered from the culprit (as the cash was reportedly spent away by the culprit). Query (1). Can the owner, a Sr.Citizen propose not to proceed further for restitution of articles which is not of much important cost wise. He chose the option in view of the fact at old age he does not want frequent PS and court. it is time consuming and waste of valuable court time. The Sr.Citizen may has to absent for going out of town. Q(2) What if the Owner does not file petition . Q(3). If the police satisfied by the ownership of
article can hand over the same to the owner and get his due receipt for the same.