SSng Aulakh
17 February 2015 at 20:18
K.a.Experts,
I am appearing in person in Bombay High court as Plaintiff. My suit against my employer company for salary and victimisation is in final stage of hearing. I am cross examining a witness who is deposing on behalf of defendants without written authority from them. He is an employee of one of the defendant companies against whom I have this matter but this witness does not have any written authority from either of the defendant company to depose on their behalf. Defendants companies' Advocates have just planted this witness.
Please go through the ist day cross examination of this witness by me, and advice me what should be my next step.
Shall I cross examine him further or discard his deposition. Please tell me what the law says to:,
If I discard deposition of this witness on the basis of not having authority and do not cross examine him further,
then what about his affidavit of evidence which he has filed under oath denying all my contentions in the Suit ?
Will his Affidavit be also automatically discarded by court under law ?
It should not happen that the court takes his submissions in his affidavit on face value, and deny reliefs to me since I have not cross examined him ?
Regards
Capt Sukhdev Singh
First day cross examination of the unauthorized witness goes as below:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
SUIT NO.527 OF 2005
Capt. Sukhdev Singh ...Plaintiff vs The Great Eastern Shipping Co. Ltd. & Ors. ...Defendants
...... Capt. Sukhdev Singh in person, for the Plaintiff. Mr. Raj Patel, Counsel with Ms. Viloma Shah & Mr. Dhiren Durante, i/b. M/s. Hariani & Co., for Defendant Nos. 1 and 3. ....
CORAM : S.C. GUPTE, J.
DATED : JANUARY 30, 2015 P.C. : .
The examinationinchief of the Defendants' witness after the witness is sworn
:Name: Adil K. Anklesaria Age : 49 years Occupation: Assistant Manager Address : GOL Offshore Ltd., Energy House, 81, Dr. D.N. Road, Mumbai � 400 001.
I tender my affidavit of evidence in lieu of examinationinchief dated 19 January 2015. The signature contained in the affidavit is of mine. The contents of this affidavit are true and correct.
The crossexamination by the Plaintiff in person :
Q.1: You have stated in this affidavit that your deposition is based on your personal knowledge. Where have you gained this knowledge?
A: I have gained my knowledge from the records maintained by my office.
Q.2: Are you fully aware about this matter?
A: Yes.
Q.3: Which are the records that you have gained the knowledge from?
A: My office has maintained a personal file of the Plaintiff. I have gained my knowledge from that file.
Q.4: Can you produce that file before the Court?
A: Yes.
Q.5: When will you produce that file?
A: I can produce it on the next date.
Q.6: What are the details in that personal file? A: All personal details concerning the Plaintiff are there in the file.
Q.7: Is it correct that all the knowledge you have about the case is from the personal file of the Plaintiff maintained in your office?
A: Yes.
Q.8: Are you making this deposition on behalf of Defendant Nos. 1 and 3?
A: Yes.
Q.9: Have you been authorised by Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 to depose on their behalf?
A: I have been authorised by Defendant No.3.
Q.10: Can you produce a document of authorisation?
A: I have been in the service of the Company and have been called here to give evidence.
Q.11: So you do not have an authorisation on behalf of Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 to depose?
A: I have no such written authorisation.
Q.12: So what is your interest in coming here and deposing on behalf of Defendant Nos. 1 and 3?
A: I am an exemployee of Defendant No.1 and the present employee of Defendant No.3.
Q.13: Are you aware that if a witness makes a false deposition or gives a false evidence whilst in the witness box, he can be charged with the offence of giving false evidence?
A: Yes.
Q.14: What are the reasons for your resignation from Defendant No.1 Company?
A: I resigned for better prospects.
Q.15: After leaving Defendant No.1 Company, where were you working?
A: I was working in Jubilient Enpro Ltd.
Q.16: Why did you leave Jubilient Enpro Ltd. and join Defendant No.3 Company?
A: Because I was given a better offer by Defendant No.3 Company.
Q.17: Do you have anything to show that you actually joined Jubilient Enpro Ltd. in between your services with Defendant No.1 and Defendant No.3 Company?
(The question is objected to by the learned Counsel for Defendant Nos. 1 and 3. The objection is overruled).
A: I can try and get the relevant documents.
Q.18: When will you produce these documents?
A: I shall try to produce them on the next occasion.
Q.19: Since you were not there either with Defendant No.1 or Defendant No.3 between August 2005 and May 2007, from where did you gain knowledge about the events that transpired between August 2005 and May 2007?
A: I gained knowledge concerning events during this period from the personal file maintained by my office in respect of the Plaintiff.
Q.20: Who has prepared the affidavit of evidence that you have signed?
A: The affidavit is prepared by my Advocates on my instructions.
(This answer is recorded by the judge himself, since the witness remained mum and did not answered anything)
Q.21: Do you mean to say that whatever knowledge you have about this particular case and about the Plaintiff is gathered only from the personal file maintained by your office?
A: I was working with Defendant No.1 from April 1998 to August 2005. During this period, when I was working as Fleet Personnel, the Plaintiff also worked with Defendant No.1 Company and I also have personal knowledge of signing on and signing off of the Plaintiff during this period.
Stand over to 4 February 2015 at 3.00 p.m.
( S.C. GUPTE, J. )
(later adjourned to 27 Feb 2015)
J K Agrawal
17 February 2015 at 20:08
Dear Sirs
In a case, in a road accident X, his wife and 2 daughters died, 2 sons survived.
I represent the case on behalf of insurance company and I want say that while calculating compensation due to death of Mr X, the entire compensation amount, as calculated ordinarily, should be computed but as 3 dependants also died so the remaining sons should be entitle to only 1/5 each of entire computed amount.
Please guide me if I am right?
I will be much obliged if you suggest any citation in favour of me or against me.
Obliged.
tagoretiwari
17 February 2015 at 19:41
Plaintiff initiated suit is going to be dismissed by the court shortly because plaintiff not coming with evidence. he is telling that if i do not pay the demanded amount based on forged agreement of sale, he is threatening that he will go for appeal. the matter is right now with sr. civil judge and once the case has been dismissed, where the plaitiff will make appeal. he wants to prolong the litigation. whether can i pay the amount or continue the litigation, in case he files appeal. the plaintiff entered the court with unclean hands with forged agreement of sale. what is your suggestion.
chirag thakkar
17 February 2015 at 19:08
Is there any provision under the Maharashta Co-operative Housing Society act which states that '' The society can sell the flat of an individual, if the owner of the flat has not paid the dues''.
If Yes, then under which circumstances or otherwise.
Help Appreciated
Thanks and Regards.
sreedhar musipetla
17 February 2015 at 12:30
Whether a simple money suit is maintainable, without seeking any relief for redemption of Registered mortgage deed executed by borrower in favour of lendor is maintainable?
Yash
16 February 2015 at 19:35
Hi, lost arbitration and the EP has been filed by degree holder in court.
Have not received notice from court till today, however, able to check through internet the status of EP.
The current order states
"
List of property along with affidavit not filed. Be filed on or before the next date of hearing subject to last opportunity on 4.4.2015.
"
Please help with the below queries:
1) I have not received the notice from court. please suggest the meaning of above order.
2) I donot hold any property in Gurgaon.
3) Will I get the notice from court and be allowed to contest the EP.
4) Please make me understand the meaning of above order.
5) Will they directly clock my bank accounts without giving me any chance?
prem chandy
16 February 2015 at 17:30
sir,
I have a rented place for the last 45yrs,this place was rented to me by the landlord himself after his death his wife used to take the rent trough his eledr son.after her death out of the four only two is receving the rent for which they are giving the M.R also (I pay 1/4th to each).This is an undivided property as I am an outsider and they being locals issue threats that they will forcefully occupy the place..although the other two sons are with me they tell nothing to worry you carry on business as long as you want....as a settlement I myself reached out to them for some sort of settlement ...they have agreed only to the point that they would give a room to run an office till my end without the rent and will consier giving to son later at that time...Is there any thing which can be done legally to protect any unprecedented move b them...
Advocate@Law Field
16 February 2015 at 12:13
In my case, alleged buyer purchased a flat in a co-operative housing society. He filed a case against Society to make him a member of the Society by filing an Application under S.22 (2) of Mah. CHS Act, 1960 and got an favorable Order.
Now, the concerned Society filed a Revision against this order to which I want to file Intervention Application under O.1, R.10. I am in the role of Developer. My case is I allotted a said flat the alleged buyer, however he defaulted in making part payment towards the consideration amount of the flat. Therefore, we terminated this buyer from purchasing a said flat.
The said Society did not make us party to the Revision proceeding and I was not a party of the earlier litigation.
My query is..Can a make a Application under O.1,R. 10 to intervene in Revision proceedings (to make a strong case in favor of Society)? If so, on which grounds?
advmarcela
16 February 2015 at 00:48
Dear Sir/Madam
My client has the license for the bar which he has allowed another person in the next house to carry on the business. There is one portuguese document that says its given to next house for x period. The document does not mention much about period, etc?
Please advice me under which act do I file to recover it from that person next door?
Thanks and regards
M. Mesta
Ria
15 February 2015 at 21:45
Respected Experts,
Plaintiff had filed a case against me claiming that I have no right to park my car on the vacant parking lot of my building.
The court due to an oversight granted an interim injunction without notice/ hearing against me till the date of next hearing.
However the injunction expired after the said hearing and I parked my car back in the vacant plot.Now the plaintiff has brought a car and blocked my car from moving from the car park.
Please advise what can be the course of action that I can take when plaintiff resorts to such illegal tactics while matter is pending in the court.
Regards,
Ria
Witness deposing defendants without any written authority from defendants
K.a.Experts,
I am appearing in person in Bombay High court as Plaintiff. My suit against my employer company for salary and victimisation is in final stage of hearing. I am cross examining a witness who is deposing on behalf of defendants without written authority from them. He is an employee of one of the defendant companies against whom I have this matter but this witness does not have any written authority from either of the defendant company to depose on their behalf. Defendants companies' Advocates have just planted this witness.
Please go through the ist day cross examination of this witness by me, and advice me what should be my next step.
Shall I cross examine him further or discard his deposition. Please tell me what the law says to:,
If I discard deposition of this witness on the basis of not having authority and do not cross examine him further,
then what about his affidavit of evidence which he has filed under oath denying all my contentions in the Suit ?
Will his Affidavit be also automatically discarded by court under law ?
It should not happen that the court takes his submissions in his affidavit on face value, and deny reliefs to me since I have not cross examined him ?
Regards
Capt Sukhdev Singh
First day cross examination of the unauthorized witness goes as below:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
SUIT NO.527 OF 2005
Capt. Sukhdev Singh ...Plaintiff vs The Great Eastern Shipping Co. Ltd. & Ors. ...Defendants
...... Capt. Sukhdev Singh in person, for the Plaintiff. Mr. Raj Patel, Counsel with Ms. Viloma Shah & Mr. Dhiren Durante, i/b. M/s. Hariani & Co., for Defendant Nos. 1 and 3. ....
CORAM : S.C. GUPTE, J.
DATED : JANUARY 30, 2015 P.C. : .
The examinationinchief of the Defendants' witness after the witness is sworn
:Name: Adil K. Anklesaria Age : 49 years Occupation: Assistant Manager Address : GOL Offshore Ltd., Energy House, 81, Dr. D.N. Road, Mumbai � 400 001.
I tender my affidavit of evidence in lieu of examinationinchief dated 19 January 2015. The signature contained in the affidavit is of mine. The contents of this affidavit are true and correct.
The crossexamination by the Plaintiff in person :
Q.1: You have stated in this affidavit that your deposition is based on your personal knowledge. Where have you gained this knowledge?
A: I have gained my knowledge from the records maintained by my office.
Q.2: Are you fully aware about this matter?
A: Yes.
Q.3: Which are the records that you have gained the knowledge from?
A: My office has maintained a personal file of the Plaintiff. I have gained my knowledge from that file.
Q.4: Can you produce that file before the Court?
A: Yes.
Q.5: When will you produce that file?
A: I can produce it on the next date.
Q.6: What are the details in that personal file? A: All personal details concerning the Plaintiff are there in the file.
Q.7: Is it correct that all the knowledge you have about the case is from the personal file of the Plaintiff maintained in your office?
A: Yes.
Q.8: Are you making this deposition on behalf of Defendant Nos. 1 and 3?
A: Yes.
Q.9: Have you been authorised by Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 to depose on their behalf?
A: I have been authorised by Defendant No.3.
Q.10: Can you produce a document of authorisation?
A: I have been in the service of the Company and have been called here to give evidence.
Q.11: So you do not have an authorisation on behalf of Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 to depose?
A: I have no such written authorisation.
Q.12: So what is your interest in coming here and deposing on behalf of Defendant Nos. 1 and 3?
A: I am an exemployee of Defendant No.1 and the present employee of Defendant No.3.
Q.13: Are you aware that if a witness makes a false deposition or gives a false evidence whilst in the witness box, he can be charged with the offence of giving false evidence?
A: Yes.
Q.14: What are the reasons for your resignation from Defendant No.1 Company?
A: I resigned for better prospects.
Q.15: After leaving Defendant No.1 Company, where were you working?
A: I was working in Jubilient Enpro Ltd.
Q.16: Why did you leave Jubilient Enpro Ltd. and join Defendant No.3 Company?
A: Because I was given a better offer by Defendant No.3 Company.
Q.17: Do you have anything to show that you actually joined Jubilient Enpro Ltd. in between your services with Defendant No.1 and Defendant No.3 Company?
(The question is objected to by the learned Counsel for Defendant Nos. 1 and 3. The objection is overruled).
A: I can try and get the relevant documents.
Q.18: When will you produce these documents?
A: I shall try to produce them on the next occasion.
Q.19: Since you were not there either with Defendant No.1 or Defendant No.3 between August 2005 and May 2007, from where did you gain knowledge about the events that transpired between August 2005 and May 2007?
A: I gained knowledge concerning events during this period from the personal file maintained by my office in respect of the Plaintiff.
Q.20: Who has prepared the affidavit of evidence that you have signed?
A: The affidavit is prepared by my Advocates on my instructions.
(This answer is recorded by the judge himself, since the witness remained mum and did not answered anything)
Q.21: Do you mean to say that whatever knowledge you have about this particular case and about the Plaintiff is gathered only from the personal file maintained by your office?
A: I was working with Defendant No.1 from April 1998 to August 2005. During this period, when I was working as Fleet Personnel, the Plaintiff also worked with Defendant No.1 Company and I also have personal knowledge of signing on and signing off of the Plaintiff during this period.
Stand over to 4 February 2015 at 3.00 p.m.
( S.C. GUPTE, J. )
(later adjourned to 27 Feb 2015)