LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Gautam Dhawan   18 April 2016 at 11:17

Limitation act - malicious prosecution

Request the experts to clarify the following for me :

What is the limitation Period for bringing a case for damages for malicious prosecution ?

1. Will limitation period be calculated from the date of Order of Discharge by Metropolitan Magistrate ?

OR

2. Will limitation period be calculated from the date of Order of Dismissal of Revision Petition by Sessions Judge ?

There are conflicting judgments on this issue as on one side certain high courts feel that a case for malicious prosecution cannot be brought up while Revision Petition is pending

Whereas there are also judgments where suits have been dismissed taking the date of order of discharge by Metropolitan Magistrate as the date from when Limitation begins to run.

Certain Observations of the courts :

The order of acquittal terminates the prosecution for the time being. The filing of an appeal does not ipso facto vacate that order: and yet while the appeal is pending it can hardly be said that the prosecution has terminated.

In our opinion, the starting point of the limitation for a suit for compensation for malicious prosecution is the date of the operative order whereby the plaintiff has been acquitted or the prosecution against him has terminated in his favour. In a case where the order of acquittal or the order whereby the prosecution is terminated in any other manner, is not challenged in appeal or revision before the Superior Court, the limitation will have to be computed from the date of the passing of the said order. But in cases where the said order of acquittal or the order terminating the prosecution is challenged in appeal or revision before the Superior Court, by virtue of the applicability of the doctrine of merger, the original order is merged in the order that is passed by the superior Court in appeal or revision and the operative order would be the order of the superior court and therefore, the period of limitation will have to be computed from the date of the order of the Superior court in appeal or revision

Shekhar Chourasiya   18 April 2016 at 10:23

Land acquisition by municipal corporation

In Indore (M.P.) Municipal Corporation acquiring building Commercial and residential for widening roads without giving any compensation to the owner of building. They are acquiring buildings for widening road for new master plan of Indore, but not giving any compensation to any owners. Also they are not providing even a month tiime to them and the peoples resides their since many years, who are legally owner of the building, are on the road. My question is -
- Is this justified ?
- Are they having power to acquire building without any compensation ?
- Any suitble judgements
- Suggestions

Anonymous   17 April 2016 at 21:18

Police aid to maintain Injunction

Res.Sir With the reference of the above subject, plaintiff get Injunction order from trial court, defendants preferred appeal before the Hon'ble District Court for Stay on Injunction.which is still pending. Thereafter, plaintiff move application with prayer of Grant Police aid to maintain Injunction, we has filed say with rebut the application.,but,Hon'ble court matter fix for final argument with police aid. My question is that. Can court grant police aid to plaintiff for maintain Injunction order while all civil remedies are available to plaintiff?if not please provide some case laws on this topic. As soon as possible. I am waiting your valuable suggestions.

Ashishsaxena   17 April 2016 at 13:00

Regarding pay protection

hello sir,
i am working under medical education department in madhya pradesh in a college.
i joined the institute as demonstrator on 30/9/2009 at salary of 15600-39100 with grade pay of 5400 which later changed by govt order from 5400 to 6000.
i worked there till 12/12/2013 and got timely increment of 3% annual with time to time increment in DA as per govt order.
i selected in the same departmet on higher post of assistant professor under class I from 12/12/2013 with salary of 15600-39100+7000.
as i was in the same dept and in the same college and under medical education department.
i joined and got advantage of only carry forwarding of earn leave and in salary no advantage as well as no experience and increment of my 4yr service.
i have to serve as probation period also for two years after my joining which i think should not be asked because i already worked there and served for probation period.
kindly give advice regarding this as i want to know that m i eligible for pay protection n wanna
know rules for pay protection also.

Anonymous   17 April 2016 at 12:45

Co-borrowers rights and responsibility

Hello Sir
I am co-borrower for a home loan where primary borrower and third borrower exist.
Primary borrower pays the emi from his salary. The same three names are present on property. Second borrower i.e. me has not given any security to the bank. I was included on property and loan only to increase the loan eligibility of primary borrower.

My questions are as follows

1. In case primary and third borrower are unable to service the loan, can i file suite against them to sell the properties and pay bank?
2. Can i claim ownership rights of the property on the basis that my creditworthiness and financial status was used by primary and third borrower to increase their eligibility for the loan?
3. Can primary and third borrower file case against me to giveup my rights on property without considering my non monetory contribution mentioned above?
4. Do i need to make payments towards loan and create my interest in the property? Or by virtue of having my name on property i have owenership right?

Thanks
Anil

Anonymous   17 April 2016 at 12:38

Co-borrowers rights and responsibility

Hello Sir
I am co-borrower for a home loan where primary borrower and third borrower exist.
Primary borrower pays the emi from his salary. The same three names are present on property. Second borrower i.e. me has not given any security to the bank. I was included on property and loan only to increase the loan eligibility of primary borrower.

My questions are as follows

1. In case primary and third borrower are unable to service the loan, can i file suite against them to sell the properties and pay bank?
2. Can i claim ownership rights of the property on the basis that my creditworthiness and financial status was used by primary and third borrower to increase their eligibility for the loan?
3. Can primary and third borrower file case against me to giveup my rights on property without considering my non monetory contribution mentioned above?
4. Do i need to make payments towards loan and create my interest in the property? Or by virtue of having my name on property i have owenership right?

Thanks
Anil

Anonymous   17 April 2016 at 11:27

Police aid to maintain injunction

Res.Sir

With the reference of the above subject, plaintiff get Injunction order from trial court, defendants preferred appeal before the Hon'ble District Court for Stay on Injunction.which is still pending. Thereafter, plaintiff move application with prayer of Grant Police aid to maintain Injunction, we has filed say with rebut the application.,but,Hon'ble court matter fix for final argument with police aid.
My question is that.

Can court grant police aid to plaintiff for maintain Injunction order while all civil remedies are available to plaintiff?if not please provide some case laws on this topic. As soon as possible. I am waiting your valuable suggestions.

Varun Mittal   16 April 2016 at 22:13

section 25 provincial small cause court act

What the court fees be to file a revision u/s 25 provincial small cause court act

Gautam Dhawan   16 April 2016 at 12:53

Malicious prosecution - limitation period

Request the experts to clarify the following for me :

What is the limitation Period for bringing a case for damages for malicious prosecution ?

1. Will limitation period be calculated from the date of Order of Discharge by Metropolitan Magistrate ?

OR

2. Will limitation period be calculated from the date of Order of Dismissal of Revision Petition by Sessions Judge ?

There are conflicting judgments on this issue as on one side certain high courts feel that a case for malicious prosecution cannot be brought up while Revision Petition is pending

Whereas there are also judgments where suits have been dismissed taking the date of order of discharge by Metropolitan Magistrate as the date from when Limitation begins to run.

Certain Observations of the courts :

The order of acquittal terminates the prosecution for the time being. The filing of an appeal does not ipso facto vacate that order: and yet while the appeal is pending it can hardly be said that the prosecution has terminated.

In our opinion, the starting point of the limitation for a suit for compensation for malicious prosecution is the date of the operative order whereby the plaintiff has been acquitted or the prosecution against him has terminated in his favour. In a case where the order of acquittal or the order whereby the prosecution is terminated in any other manner, is not challenged in appeal or revision before the Superior Court, the limitation will have to be computed from the date of the passing of the said order. But in cases where the said order of acquittal or the order terminating the prosecution is challenged in appeal or revision before the Superior Court, by virtue of the applicability of the doctrine of merger, the original order is merged in the order that is passed by the superior Court in appeal or revision and the operative order would be the order of the superior court and therefore, the period of limitation will have to be computed from the date of the order of the Superior court in appeal or revision

Kalpesh   16 April 2016 at 12:15

SCA & FA

What is difference between sca & FA