LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Member (Account Deleted)   19 February 2011 at 07:12

Unsound Mind

Whether a lunatic/unsound mind by birth (now 23 yr old)
1. Can get Votters ID?
2. can get a passport?
3. can open bank account through the guardian?

Sudhin2218   19 February 2011 at 01:50

Need an Answer

We've a joint property and it was jointly registered in the name of my grandmother (father's mother) and my father’s name,after my father passed away in 1991, my mother became joint owner with my grandmother, In 2004 my grandmother (my grand mother was not in possession) sold the half of the joint property to stranger (not belongs my Hindu family) , there was no partition deed made between my mother and grand mother,
so we filed the suit for an injunction and Sr division court granted injunction in favor of us. Then stranger filed suite for partition in 2006, Now we came to know there is a provision in "Section 4(1) in The Partition Act, 1893
Where a share of a dwelling- house belonging to an undivided family has been transferred to a person who is not a member of such family and such transferee sues for partition, the Court shall, if any member of the family being a shareholder shall undertake to buy the share of such transferee, make a valuation of such share in such manner as it thinks fit and direct the sale of such share to such shareholder, and may give all necessary and proper directions in that behalf."

Question 1: My mother or my sister is ready to buy the share of such transferee, so please let me know are there any Good Supreme Court or Karnataka High Court Judegement Citations, which can strongly support “Section 4(1) in The Partition Act, 1893” ?

Question 2: Do we need request H’ble Judge to refer this case to Lok adalat based on “Section 4(1) in The Partition Act, 1893”?

Anonymous   18 February 2011 at 23:44

answer to my query reuested

Sir,
I filed a contempt case against the ACP (TP) and the Zonal Commissoner of GHMC for not acting on the orders of the Honourable High Court of AP for stopping further construction of an unauthorized constructon being made in the common area of our apartment.

The ACP (TP) who has also represented the Zonal Commissioner, in his counter affadavit filed in reply to the conempt case before the Honourable High Court of AP sateted that the open balony where the illegal construction is carried is only by the party who has been constructing the structure and nobody in the apartment including the peitioner is using the same.

My question is, how can the ACP (TP) tell who is using which part of the common area in the flats? Even if one does not use a particuar portion of the common area, do the other residents loose their right to it?

He also stated after reciving the complaint from some of the residents it issued a notice under section 452 of HMC act,1955 to the party on 9-2-2010 for stopping the iternal construction work i.e., closing of open balcony even prior to the orders ofthe Honurable High Court of AP on 5th March 2010 and stopped the construction.

The party applied for regulariastion of the construction made by them on 4th March 2010 wich was rejected by the Corporation.

The ACP (TP) has mislead the Honourable High Court by stating that they have stopped constrution after issuing the party a notice 0n 9-2-2010.

I have been continously reminding them that the construction is still being carried out vide letters addressed to the ACP (TP), Deputy Commissioner and the Zonal commissioner, but they ignored them, but in the counter affadavit stated that they have stopped the construction.

Should these discrepancy in the counter affadavit brought to the notice of the High Court?

He also stated that as the regularisation was rejected the Corporation shall take immedaiate steps for demolition of the unauthorised structure. This was on 5th July 2010 and it is not done so far as the pary has taken a status quo from 3rd Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts.

The status quo has not been vacated yet.

Anonymous   18 February 2011 at 23:40

answer to my query reuested

Sir,
I filed a contempt case against the ACP (TP) and the Zonal Commissoner of GHMC for not acting on the orders of the Honourable High Court of AP for stopping further construction of an unauthorized constructon being made in the common area of our apartment.

The ACP (TP) who has also represented the Zonal Commissioner, in his counter affadavit filed in reply to the conempt case before the Honourable High Court of AP sateted that the open balony where the illegal construction is carried is only by the party who has been constructing the structure and nobody in the apartment including the peitioner is using the same.

My question is, how can the ACP (TP) tell who is using which part of the common area in the flats? Even if one does not use a particuar portion of the common area, do the other residents loose their right to it?

He also stated after reciving the complaint from some of the residents it issued a notice under section 452 of HMC act,1955 to the party on 9-2-2010 for stopping the iternal construction work i.e., closing of open balcony even prior to the orders ofthe Honurable High Court of AP on 5th March 2010 and stopped the construction.

The party applied for regulariastion of the construction made by them on 4th March 2010 wich was rejected by the Corporation.

The ACP (TP) has mislead the Honourable High Court by stating that they have stopped constrution after issuing the party a notice 0n 9-2-2010.

I have been continously reminding them that the construction is still being carried out vide letters addressed to the ACP (TP), Deputy Commissioner and the Zonal commissioner, but they ignored them, but in the counter affadavit stated that they have stopped the construction.

Should these discrepancy in the counter affadavit brought to the notice of the High Court?

He also stated that as the regularisation was rejected the Corporation shall take immedaiate steps for demolition of the unauthorised structure. This was on 5th July 2010 and it is not done so far as the pary has taken a status quo from 3rd Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts.

The status quo has not been vacated yet.

Anonymous   18 February 2011 at 23:16

Civil Procedure

The Plaintiff has filed a Regular Civil Suit Affidavit with Application for Injunction and Affidavit against Defendants. The Injunction seeking certain reliefs restraining the defendants adopting aggressive, threatening, using vulgar and abusive language approaches by the Agents. The defendants argued the injunction application to the limited purpose. But the defendants stated in the trial court he wanted to argue Injunction. The Plaintiff stated that he has argued only to the Injunction and not on the Suit. But the Defendant argued both the Injunction and Suit.

What is the procedure? is it admissible under the point of law ? What is the remedy if the judgment and order is against the Plaintiff?

Anonymous   18 February 2011 at 20:19

Property dispute

My father has some property in Kerala which is been encroached by his brother. Our property lies behind my uncles property so he has made gates so we cannot enter ours and a part of his building stands in our land. Since my father is no more, I ( living in US) and my mother (living in kerala) have filed a case against my uncle in end of 2008. My uncle is trying to delay the case as much as possible as he thinks that one day we will be fed and give up the case.

The comissioner had visited the property and wrote in our favor. But then my uncle filed requesting a second comissioner. But the court resend the earlier comissioner and the report is again in our favour and mentions he had made constructions in our land. The court is set for trial next month and my mother is called to give evidence

1)My question is as per the second report can we prosecute my Uncle.
2)If we prosecute him can he counter file against us.
3) As an NRI what will be the consequences.

Any help and insight willbe useful.


Anonymous   18 February 2011 at 19:55

Suit for Means Profit

Dear Experts please answer my query,

Suit was decreed against the defendant and ordered for delivery of possession, but no prayer and order for means-profit,

1.Can the plaintiff claim means-profit by filing another suit?.

2.Can means profit claimable on property by which the defendant did not made any profit?

Thanks in advance.

ASHOK KUMAR SOMANI   18 February 2011 at 16:25

TRANSFER ND ALLOTMENT OF PLOTS OF DDA

I HAVE PURCHASED A DDA PLOT FROM THE ACTUAL ALLOTTEE AND IN THE SAID PROCESS THE REQUIRED MONEY WAS ALSO DEPOSITED FROM MY ACCOUNT CHEQUES TO DDA. I ALSO BOUGHT STAMP PAPERS REQUIRED TO TRANSFER THE SAID PLOT.BUT THE ALLOTTEE PAY NO HEED TO EXECUTE THE PROCEES AND THE MAIN ALLOTEE MALAFIDLY WRITE SEVERAL LETTERS TO DDA MENTIONING THAT HE DID NOT SELL THIS PLOT TO ANY ONE TO STOP ME TO CONSTRUCT.NOW THE MAIN ALLOTTEE DIED LEAVING BEHIND A WILL AND HIS LEGAL HEIRS FILE A PROBATE PETITION. PLZ SUGGEST HOW COULD I SAVE MY RIGHT ON THE PLOT ALSO IF THERE IS ANY CITATION THEN PLEASE LET ME KNOW.

J.D.S Sareen   18 February 2011 at 14:58

with regard to summoning of witness

Proposition:-

Plaintiff has filed a civil suit and arrayed three defendants belonging to same
Department.

Defendant No.1 has been arrayed in official capacity i.e through. Secretary etc, who
also signed the written statement on behalf of defendant No.1

Now the plaintiff has summoned the said secretary who signed the w/s by, name as
his own witness

Query is:-

Whether the plaintiff can summon the defendant No.1 by name, as his own
Witness(plaintiffs witness)?


Anonymous   18 February 2011 at 14:26

Nomination

A opened a saving account in a bank and nominated his wife B. Later a died and B claims for the amount. The Bank asked for succession certificate as amount is more than one lack.
While the deceased had filed nomination in favour of his wife, succession certificate from the competent court is required or not
Please advise.
Thanks,
B.S,Bhatnagar