LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Tripti Nagwekar   24 August 2012 at 15:22

S 22 of hindu succession act and valuation of property

Dear Advisors, nephew A together with his uncle B have a piece of land in ancestral say 1000 sq. ft. and the name of nephew A and uncle B are registered on 7 / 12 index. When A proposed to sell half portion i.e. 500 sq. ft. of his share without dividing total land of 1000 sft because division of land takes 3 years by government, uncle B refused nephew A to sell his share to outsider and tried to offer only Rs.10,000/- ten thousand for A’s share of land and at the same time outside party was offering me Rs.400,000/- to nephew A. So ultimately nephew A sold his share of 500 sqft to outsider buyer for Rs.4 lac under section 44 Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and outsider party i.e. buyer put Rs.100,000/- one lac on sale deed to avoid more stamp duty and registration fees. One the same day nephew A and buyer registered the agreement. After one month uncle B filed case against A and requested the court to cancel the sale deed and to allow uncle B to buy 500 sqft from the buyer at Rs.1 lac mentioned on sale deed under section 22 of Hindu Succession Act, 1956. On the basis of court the tehsildar has not put buyers name of 7/12 index. Further can nephew A and outsider buyer request the court to value the sold land at current market rate say Rs.6 lacs as civil suit is going on for past 2 years? Now please advise nephew A what the court would do in this case? What are the outputs? What are the ways for nephew A to come out?

Dr Sangh Mittra   24 August 2012 at 15:18

Land acquisition act 1894 : is boundary wall constructed over my land a structure?

Sir,

Please apprise me as to whether a Boundary wall, Five to six feet high constructed by me prior to the issuance of Notification under Section 4(1) of Land Acquisition Act 1894, to enclose my Plot upon my registered piece of Land for security and to stop trespassers thereon , is a structure over the Land in the terminology /meaning as applicable to the LA Act 1894?

The Land Acquisition Collector has in his letter to the Collector termed this boundary wall as DPC (DPC KI HUI HAI).

In any case the DPC is the hardest thing to accomplish when building. It is also the most important part of a building . And thats , to my mind is the partially built structure.

Further I have been in the peaceful possession of the Land ever since 1989. The State issued Notification under Section 4(1) in 2007.

Facts.
The State Government while carrying out the survey had exempted from acquisition structures over individual plots, partially built houses of those who were present in the locality.

I am a Defence Services Officer, who had purchased the residential Plot in 1989 and the sale/ purchase deed in respect of my plot was registered with the Revenue Department through its sub registrar.

I came to know that the Land Acquisition Officer who had acted on behalf of the Government in his report had recommended that my Plot with boundary wall be not acquired.

But he was subsequently made a member of the Joint Survey Committee headed by the Chief Administrator of the Urban Development Authority for which the land was being acquired for developing residentail sectors under it.

Just one month before the declaration under Section 6 of LA Act the Report submitted by the JIC with LAO as member included even my Plot in the declaration of acquisition.

Neither I came to know, nor was informed, nor could read the Two Papers published in the region, nor the Gazette, nor the Notice Board nor do I had any relative or friend in the area and I was not present either in the area or in the state and was serving the Union of India far away. No Notice was ever sent to me under Section 9 or 12 of the LA Act 1894.

After my retirement in 2010 I unofficially learnt about the acquisition and the award and have have been inquiring from the collector in writing.After two years of Correspondence he has replied to me in June 2012 and sent to me a one page report of the Land Acquisition Officer dated June 2012 stating that my plot forms part of the acquired Land , that Award was passed and on the same day possession given to the Urban Development Authority.

I have come to know that:

The Award takes effect, after communication to persons interested.- Refer 1957 – ALT 34 (NRC)

Collector was required to give immediate notice of his award to the persons interested as are not present when award made. (Section 12(2) of the Act).

This all was not done.

Are there any chances if I approach the High Court?

Is Boundary wall constructed by me to enclose my plot a Structure?

If it is I could pray that all those whos plots have been spared from acquisition had structures and so had mine too but since I was not present and was serving away from the sate I have been discriminated.

Please help and calrify.

SACHIN   24 August 2012 at 11:35

Regarding registry of land in palwal, haryana

Dear Sir

I m 27 Male frm Delhi and going to purchase a land in Asaoti (Palwal). Please tell me what is Baynama & Mukhtyar Khas in Haryana. Are these documents are registry or Only Power of Attorney. SHould I purchase this land or not on these papers. I was told that only Baynama & Mukhtyar Khas will be made in court and 3% of Stamp Duty will be given. Paper will be in the name of my mother.

Please suggest me its urgent. Thanks in Advance.

Sachin

rakesh   24 August 2012 at 11:08

Right to claim a property

my great grand father has purchased a land in 1947, he has 2 sons and one daughter, one is my grandfather and other is his younger brother. My grandfather has three sons and his younger brother has two daughters.Can the son in laws of my grandfathers brother and son of daughter of great grand father have the right to claim the property.

angel   23 August 2012 at 22:09

Rights of married women on the property of her father

My great grand father had quite a good deal of property in his name. after his death and after a lot of discussions and negotiations his sons and daughters (my grandfather and his brothers and sisters) agreed to divide it. Which I believe in legal parlance means partition. In the process, my grandfather, his brothers and sisters and all their children were asked to come to a particular office and sign a record along with their photographs. I am not aware of what record and before whom it was signed. So my grandfather and my uncle were a part of this. But my mother was kept out of this whole process while all the others which includes my grandfather his brothers and sisters and their children were involved in the process.

Now the property was divided and the property which came to my grandfathers share was jointly held by my grandfather and my uncle. Later my uncle even got a Power of Attorney from my grandfather. As of now he has also sold few properties without even informing my mother.

My queries are as follows:

1) Does my mother have any legal right with respect to the property in the entire scenario as stated above?
2) In case yes, is there any remedy as on date?
3) I have heard that after partition the property would become my grandfather's what is legally called self acquired property over which my mother or any children for that matter have any right. It is the sole discretion of my grandfather as to how he intends to dispose the property. Is this true?
4) Any idea as to the whole process where my grandfather and all his brothers, sisters and all their children were asked to attend a particular office and sign a record? What could be the relevance of this procedure?

kumar   23 August 2012 at 21:22

Girl right in property please help

my grand father purchase a property in 1960.
my grand father have three children one son and two doughter. in 1996 these two doughter relinguished their right in property to their brother(my father). then my father who has five chidren three sons and two doughter distribute property in four parts.three part for sons and one part for himself. my brother s made this transaction as sale to their wife from my father.
no one ask me.is there any possibility for me to claim my share.

now my father has died in 2003 without making any will for his one part property.
now again my brother not interested to give me anything. they have occupied this property and think to start construction on this property for earn rental income.

radha   23 August 2012 at 20:54

Court order to demolish shops

Dear Experts,
Kindly provide legal advice.
A female Baba {fake} was allotted a plot of land by State Urban Development Agency for religious purpose as a relative of Baba was a position holder in the agency. Baba constructed 24 shops facing main road and obtained advance from shopkeepers. Licencee agreement was signed.To many shopkeepers no receipt was issued. Some shopkeepers succeeded in getting the receipts. Shops have one door and shutter in front and one rear door and both doors are locked by shopkeepers. Monthly rent was being taken but no receipt was issued to many shopkeepers. Some shopkeepers succeeded in getting the monthly receipt but purpose was mentioned as donation and rent was not written. Baba had formed a trust with herself as Chairman and her daughters as trusties. No map was approved for shops and residential {palatial} structures erected by baba. Baba was in habit of using foul language with shopkeepers and would now and then barge into the shops and threat the shopkeepers and refuse to pay for items taken from shopkeepers. Shopkeepers objected and baba lodged false police complaints and police picked up some shopkeepers. Baba disconnected electricity of some shopkeepers and shopkeepers got relief from DCDRF and electricity meters have been installed. Baba forcibly got some shops vacated and put her locks and opened the rear gate and lifted goods from shops. Litigation is going on and courts have provided stay. Shopkeepers formed a society.
Some shopkeepers approached a PIL lawyer. Lawyer of baba agreed in HC that shops are not rooms and are illegal and they are wiling to demolish the shops. HC has directed that all shops be demolished { within a week from receipt of order}except those for which litigation is going on, and shopkeepers may claim damages from Baba in local courts. State Urban Development Agency has been pulled up by HC. Acting Chief justice has ignored the pleas of shopkeepers that they shall be without source of livelihood, and they are not at fault.
Shopkeepers feel that they should approach SC.
What should be done by these hapless shopkeepers? Kindly provide a remedy.

kumar   23 August 2012 at 16:06

Property papers

sir i purchased a first floor in a four story building from builder. at the time of registry i received only sale deed of first floor that time builder says other paper like allotment of land , possession letter,past chain, freehold paper of land will be equally divided among all four floors owner.when all floor will sell out.
now all floor has sell out but builder giving excuses and not interested to distribute papers.
what should i do?
is there any trouble for me to sell floor in future ?

Kashyap   23 August 2012 at 13:42

Tenacy rights in case of fire

Dear Experts,
I'm a tenant under the pagadi system. Our building is going for re development. To make us vacate the house soon, the builder has placed some goons in the neighboring house. So, we are planning to go for a rented flat somewhere else until the re development negotiations are over.
I have heard that in case the tenant does not occupy the flat and if fire takes place then the TENANCY RIGHTS are extinguished.

Kindly enlighten me on the SUBJECT and remedy(ies) therefor.

Regards,
Kashyap Joshi.

shivam   23 August 2012 at 12:34

Wife's right in her husbands self earned property?

Dear Club
Our father has a house cum land property which is in the name of our parents i.e, my father and mother are the joint holder of the property.There is no will written by my parents. Can my father give the entire property to my elder sister[who is married,working]without giving it to my mother after his death or before his death? If my father gives the entire property to my sister can my mother claim it as my mother is the joint holder of this property?This house cum land was purchased by my father after his marriage in West Bengal. PLEASE HELP.....