LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Dabboo Goyal   12 February 2013 at 14:24

Land registration

Sir,

I m in process of purchasing an agriculture land near Nagpur(Maharashtra). The seller has the registry papers on her name and she got this property from her husband (died) and her husband got this property from his mother through her will.

Now one of the nephew of her husband sent notice to that lady(owner) not to sale that land.

Please suggest what should i do? can i purchase that land?

Pls suggest

D.K. Goyal

sanjoo   12 February 2013 at 11:54

Self aquired property

Dear Sir,
'B' died in 1930 without leaving wife, any son or daughter alive. 'B'left some property on his name. Mother of 'B' got the property of 'B' on her name after death of his son 'B' as class 1 heir as per Indian succession act. Now my question is "is this property now self aquired property of her mother or it is ancestral property?" I don't know how this property aquired by 'B'.

bhavesh   12 February 2013 at 11:16

Proprty of missing person

My Uncle(Unmarried) went missing since 8 years and we didn't do any complaint in police but we did advertisement in news paper before 7 years. He has a house in his name. In such a case how the property could be divided and what is the procedure to be followed in such circumstances. We belong to Hindu religion. And also tell me the required documents and procedures as well as the different act(Law) for this property case. The advertisement(for missing) was given indirectly like "Please come home where ever you are, Grandmother is ill(means near to death). and she memories you and want to see you." And also note that My grandparents is dead.

RAJESh TRIVEDI   11 February 2013 at 19:22

Rent

SIR,
I AM STAYING IN PAGHADI SYTEM IN MUMBAI AND MY CASE IS AS UNDER:
Plaintiffs have obtained this premises on through registered deed in 1958 from Shri Mulraj Ghedia & Brothers. After obtaining the premises on lease, leaseholder have constructed one building of ground plus three floors and three chawls on this plot of land. M/S .F.E.Dinshaw Trust is the original owner of whole land of Irani Wadi admeasuring 42­1/2 Acres from Malad, now at Kandivali (West). That F.E.Dinshaw Trust as leased this entire Irani Wadi to P.A.Irani in 1945. Said Irani has sub­let the property to Mulraj Ghediya & brothers. Ghediya brothers have sub­divided the said plot of land into small plots and have leased those plots to various persons for construction and residential purpose. Plaintiffs have obtained this plot of land from Ghediya Brothers on lease.M/s.F.E.Dinshaw Trust had filed a suit being suit No.464/73 in Hon'ble High Court against P.A.Irani and Ghediya Brothers for recovery of possession. After contesting the matter as per Judgment dt.9.10.1985 the suit is decreed. M/s. Dinshaw Trust is found to be entitled for possession of entire Irani Wadi and defendants of that suit are directed to hand over possession to Dinshaw Trust. However, that decree is not yet executed.M/S F.E.Dinshaw Trust has issued a public nottice for auction of the property and Mr. R. S Dwivedi and others have purchase a property through this auction and claiming their ownership rights on the plot with structure standing there on. The Plaintiffs have file a suits in civil court that they are in lawfull possession of the said plot and they can be dispossess through due process of law and suit is disposed with the order that the valuation of plot is above Rs.3 lakhs and this court has no jurisdiction to trial and suit the case and suit can not be decreeed and plaint is return to the plaintiff for presentation before proper court.
Palintiff ahs filed a civil suit in mumbai high court and pass a following intrim order.

1. The Appeal No. 826 of 2012 has been admitted as prima facie a arguable point with regard to at least jurisdiction of the trial court has been made out. The trial court has held that the appellant has failed to prove that he has in lawful possession of the suit premises.

2. After hearing both sides, I am of the opinion, prima facie, that the question is not of lawful possession but protecting the physical possession of the appellant – plaintiff and that cannot be interfered with or obstructed or taken away, save and except by due process of law.

3. In these circumstances, there will be ad-interim order directing the respondents to this appeal/application from dispossessing the appellant/applicant of the land admeasuring 3170 sw.yrds. bearing CTS No.149, 149/1 to 45 situated at Village Malad (North), save and except by due process of law. However, if there are structures which are standing on the said lands and which are stated to be in possession of third party, then, any amounts that are being collected by the applicant towards rent or compensation shall be collected but an account of such collection shall be filed in this court every year on affidavit by the appellant-plaintiff. The Civil Application is made absolute in these terms but without prejudice to rights and contentions of the parties.

4. At this stage, Mr. Thorat and Mr. Panickar seek a clarification that if the interim relief is not granted in terms of prayer clause (a) of the Civil Application, then, the contesting parties may be allowed to display or put the board, containing their name or name plate on the suit premises but without stating therein that these parties are in physical possession.
Mr.Lulia states that on the last occasion complication arose because the board which is sought to be displayed contained a statement that the contesting respondents are in physical possession. Equally, putting security guards would mean that the appellant's possession is interfered with and that also creates a doubt in the mind of those occupants who are liable to
pay rent/compensation for the occupation of the rooms and the structures and thereafter such occupants refused to pay the rent/compensation to the appellant-applicant.

5. To my mind, if a board only showing name plate and displaying the name or business styled by the contesting respondents can
be placed but without containing any statement with regard to the physical
possession of the said parties. Secondly, putting up a name plate would be enough protection and it is not as if the appellant-applicant will then be able to create any obstacle or hindrance in the event the contesting respondents succeed in their own proceedings or in this appeal. For such reasons, to my mind, the prayer to place security agency in-charge of the
suit property also need not be granted at this stage.

6. Civil Application is allowed in the above terms. No costs

In above circumstances, to whom we should pay the rent and protect our tenancy ? shold we continue to pay the rent to the plaintiff to whom we are paying rent ? or we should pay the rent to the plot owner ? or we should deposit our rent in court through legal process ? It seems that some person having vested interest is misguiding us and we are total 80 tenants and it is a matter of litigation and we are unable to understand the same and it is a question of survival of approximate 300 human life. so i request you to guide us what to do on humantrian ground and oblige.

THANKS

soniya   11 February 2013 at 19:19

Co. op. hsg. society tax issue on commercial and residential premises.

Dear and respected Members,

I am residing in a co. op. Hsg. society and also operating my office from there. Being an advocate i can carry my practice or business from the said residential premises and i am exempted from the tax on commercial premises and i am entitled for the tax only on residential rat.
There are judgments on this fact that advocates can practice from the residence and that is not fall under the commercial premises and regarding advocate's exemption from the commercial tax payment.
some body has informed me that there is a judgment of Justice Lakotia of Supreme court of India on this issue.

Please help me with the judgment or citation if any on this line. As i have got tax notice on commercial premises wherein it a residential premises and i m residing there and i have all the relevant proofs to show that.

Please help me with the judgment if you aware of it or any relevant information.

Thanks and regards.

Adv. Soniya.

shyam lal sharma   11 February 2013 at 16:27

Purchase of property

Respected learned Advocates…

in Karnataka state only Agriculturist and whose annual income other than agriculture should be less than 2 lakhs then only he can purchased the agriculture land.

Here my question is Mr ‘A’ is not having the agriculturist status and his income exceeds 2 lakhs he purchased the agriculture land through Registered Sale deed and the khatha / mutation has not transferred to the Mr ‘A’ name since 1997. And now both the person who sold land to Mr ‘A’ and PURCHASER is offering to sale the property where Mr ‘A’ is not in possession of the property and in revenue documents he is having only Sale Deed and copy of EC and SELLER is in the possession of the property.
My question:
From whom should I purchase the land?

Thanks in Advance.

srinath   11 February 2013 at 15:34

Sanctioned plan & vat

Sir,
I have purchased a flat with a built up area of 1367 sft as per layout plan. But the balcony which should have been provided at living room as per layout plan is removed/ not shown in the sanctioned plan. On enquiry, the contractor is replying that the flat does not have the living room balcony.

But the builder is claiming the balcony will be provided once the Occupation Certificate inspesction is over by the BBMP officials.

NOw my confusion/problem is where do I stand? what are the options i have in case the builder refuses to provide the balcony because until the inspection for issue of OC is done, no balcony will be provided and as per sanctioned plan, there is no balcony.

Pl clarify.


thanks,
srinath.

pinky   11 February 2013 at 14:05

Noc for sale of flat

We intend to sell our flat within the next 2-3 months. I am aware that NOC is not mandatory for sale of flat. But most of the purchasers are insisting on an NOC. Though we have a clear title and all our maintenance bills are up to date. The purchaser thinks that maybe something is wrong so we are not willing for an NOC. Sois it compulsory for me to approach the Secretary for NOC

sr_v@user   11 February 2013 at 12:08

Building society demanding heir certificate

Dear Sir, Pls note that one of my freind & wife both purchased a flat in their name in a building. Now my freind has expired & society is asking his wife to submit some heir certificate. I wanted to know the proceedure. Kindly help.

B.S.NARAHARI   10 February 2013 at 22:55

Do we need to file case in civil court

Respected sirs/Madams,

1) We people comprising of 50 members formed Residents Association in our residential layout formed in the year 2004.

2) Currently these 50 members are owner of 50 sites ( each member is owner of individual site allotted & registered by the developer in the year 2004).

3) All these 50 members paid money to the land developer and got their sites registered in their names by taking site purchase loans from Banks.

4) Now the houses are coming up

5) The earlier landlords had already filed PTCL case ( Some grant land case) in DC court in the year 2006 and got the case dismissed by the court.

6) After 7 years of gap, now again the landlords filed case in civil court. ( Now they filed partition case )

7) The sale pattern from landlords to current site owners are as below

Landlords A,B & c
|
Party X
|
party Y
|
Land developer
|
50 numbers site owners

8) Now the landlord A has filed case on landlord B

9) The total residential layout is formed on 4 acres 20 guntas
A share is 1 acre 20 guntas
B share is 2 acres
c share is 1 acre

10 The land developed had obtained DC permission in the year 2003 itself for land conversion and then registered in our individual names, we DC conversion copy.

11,Since landlord A filed case on Landlord B. Neither party (X & Y) nor land developer did not receive any court notice.

12. In a sale deed it is clearly mentioned that the legal issues to be solved by the land developer and land developer should ensure peace full possession of individual sites in the layout by the site owners.

13. Now is it wise to file objection or put Kviat by the individual site owners through registered resident association.
Because ultimately the site owners who are under the process of house construction or sale of site is put under dilemma.

14. The Land developer says " I have not received any court notice to respond myself"

15 Now already 8 houses have come up and families are living in our layout.

16. The layout falls in Bangalore North coming under Yelahanka Hobli. Bangalore

I kindly request to help us and advice

regards
Narahari