LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

K.Babu   27 April 2013 at 09:33

Is it valid document?

Dear sir, Please read it and send your personal opinion. That will help me for solving problems we are living in cuddalore dist. My name is babu My grand fathers father was partitioned his self acquired properties in 1965 with his sons. In that partition deed my grand father got a house and some lands. Lands are sold away before 1985. My grand father has 2 sons and 2 daughters. All are married before 1983. My father is second son to my grand father, From 1985 to 2000 my father only maintained our grand father and grand mother. in 2000 My father expired. my grand father (age 80) wrote a settlement deed in favour of his one deased sons two children (age 25 & 30) to maintain himself and his wife in 2002. In 2010 my grand father died. In 2011 my grand fathers another son and 2 daughters filled a suit to divide the property. And my 2 aunties take my grand mother with them to get her share for them. They are asking equal share in the property (house) My grand fathers settlement deed is registered in 2002. is it Valid? Actually How much share can I get ? Please give a solution to my problem sir. Thank U Very Much for your reply.

satya prakash   26 April 2013 at 20:45

Cancellation of lease deed

Dear Sir

If we want to terminate a lease deed registered for 03 years after 01 years, where condition is that we should give one month notice to the owner of the property, than how to proceed further. plz suggest if cancellation of registered lease deed is required or simply notice to the owner a month in advance will serve the purpose.

Nandkishor Maroti Ambade   26 April 2013 at 14:18

Purchase of agri land by pvt ltd co- contradiction in expert advice

Query :
Whether a Pvt. Company can buy agricultural land and transfer the title to its name in Maharashtra? What is the procedure for same?
The comments on the same issue received about 3 years back and as received now some 15 days back, on your website, are quite contradictory, which are listed below. I shall be glad to know which version is correct or there has been change in the law during past 3 years?

Expert comments : received about 15 days back :

Comment From Mr Ajay Shetty:
a) if any director is an agriculturist purchase land in his name. in Maharashtra only an agriculturist can buy agricultural land

Comment From Mr R. K Nanda.
b) Agree with expert Shetty.

Comment From Sevjyoti Barman
c) yes. he is right.

Comment From Mr K Mahesh
d) Only agriculture can buy the land in Maharashtra

Comment From Mr Rajkumar Makkad
e) If company has to purchase the land in its own name then also it needs to have the status of agriculturist. It means the company is required to first purchase the land (may it be just a small piece of land) in either of the States wherein there is no requirement of the agriculturist to purchase the agriculture land and then obtain the status thereto and then purchase in Maharashtra.


Expert comments : received about 3 years back
-From Mr Hemant Agarwal

Reply -1
1. A Pvt.Ltd. company CAN CERTAINLY BUY AGRICULTURAL LAND and develop and perform agricultural activities on it, BUT SUBJECT TO the approved provisions of articles and the Memorandum of the pvt.ltd. and MUST be approved by the Registrar of Companies (ROC). There is no requirement of any director being an agriculturist. The Articles of the P.Ltd. co. should clearly outline the agricultural activities the P.Ltd. proposes to indulge in.

Reply -2:
1. Under the Companies Act, a regd. co. may perform those activities that are listed in the Objects, Articles and the memorandum. By virtue of its objects and articles, as regd. under the companies act, the P.Ltd., (now non-person) can function and perform agricultural activites and need not be a agricuturist as in the case of an individual person.
2. The co. has a object of doing say. Rose Garden or say Horticulture or say Soyabean cultivation. The co. after doing the above, has to file the yearly land revenue fees, according to the usage of the land. i.e. land revenue is different for agricultural activities and for non-agricultural activities. False declarations and filing will lead to prosecution by the Revenue dept., which has a mandatory duty to periodically inspect and file reports with the district collectors office.
3. In the future event, if the pvt.ltd. co. folds-up or say closes down, then it cannot dispose of its agriculture land bank to non-farmers for non-agricultural purposes.
The agricultural activities are limited to the existence of the Co. If there is no company, all the property etc... can be attached by statutory authorities (I.Tax, S.Tax, Revenue Dept., Environment Dept, Pollution Dept among others)
The directors of the P.Ltd., DO NOT BECOME FARMERS / AGRICULTURISTS automatically just because their co. had earlier owned of agricultural land and neither the heir of such directors may ever claim right as Farmer or as an agriculturist. There is no such thing as inheirtance in a company or say to a non-individual-person.
If the annnual report / balance sheet / P&F of the company shows any profit / loss pertaining to any non-agricultural activities on the said agricultural land, THEN it will be clear violations of the objects & articles and the collector may attach / acquire the said land.

There are several parameters which have to be taken into account, when agri land is owned by corporate and agri activities are performed by such co.

4. If the collectors inspects the activities of a particular agricultural land and finds that the agricultural land is being used for other purposes, then he has to attach/ acquire the said land from the owners.
example :
5.
a) A regd. Pvt. Ltd. whose objects and articiles comply with the companies act, identifies a agricultural land. Buys it. Registers it after paying necessary duties and taxes. Co. also submits undertaking to use land only for so and so purposes.
b) submits documents to Tahsildar's office for change in revenue records. Tahsildar inspects the co. registration and articles and the sale papers etc.. and approves the ownership title change-over, BUT after taking permission from the collectors office.
c) In future Co. violates the undertaking and uses the land for other purposes. Tahsildar / Collector, after due notices may attach /acquire the land. Co. loses title.
6. Literally more than 15% land in India, is held in the name of corporates, holding companies, charitable trusts and other non-individuals. The most common name in Mumbai area is Godrej group, who holds vast tracts of agricultural and other waste land in the name of Godrej Holdings. There are several hundreds of companies who are doing plantation and Tea Gardens, Horticulture, Floriculture and Forestry plantations.

7. There are land belonging to Collector, the State Govt. the Central Govt, The defence forces, the airport authorities and other PSU. They are no restrictions to them.
8. BUT, the agricultural land transfer to non-farmer and to non-agriculturist is RESTRICTED ONLY TO INDIVIDUALS and not otherwise.
9.. Agriculture income is presently Tax-Free in the hands of Invididuals.
10. Agriculture income in NOT TAX FREE for companies.
Keep Smiling .... Hemant Agarwal.

Reply -3
1. P.Ltd. cannot be classified as a "Agriculturist", since it is not a physical person and cannot have farmer-inheritance rights, which includes its directors, share-holders and their legal heirs. The right to do "agricutural activities" is derived from company articles/ objects. However, these rights do not confer any right or title to a status called "Farmer or Agriculturist".
Similarly a "non-farmer-paid-labourer" who works in a agricultural field for scores of years, does not gain automatic status of a "Farmer or an agriculturist".
2. The right to the status of a "farmer or agriculturist" is not by virtue of the labour-work or activities (farming) being done by anybody (eg. non-farmers, or companies or anybody), BUT SUCH STATUS OF A FARMER IS DERIVED DUE TO Form no. 6A and Form no. 7 & 12 and further classification by the statute.
3. P.Ltd., can buy agricultural land anywhere in India and do agricultural activities, subject to parameters as suggested in earlier above posts. There is no time-frame problem. The law relating to acquiring or holding "agricultural" category lands SHOULD (I presume) be uniform throughout India and WOULD be NOT limited only to Maharashtra.
4. The activities of a P.Ltd. may be to do "various types of farming", which can / may be changed as and when the articles or objects or memorandum or constitution of the P.Ltd. changes or is modified. Each such changes will have to be registered with the Collector / Tahilsdar, which may pertain to objects related to Agricultural activities. Note : The district collector is well within his rights to seize / acquire or nullify all rights of the land holder, IF violations are detected by his office.
5. A non-farmer or say a compay cannot claim subsidies, benefits, exemptions, credits etc... that may be announced by the Central and the State Govts, which are meant only for individuals, which in turn is determined by Village form no. 6A and Land holding Extract form no. 7 & 12.

Keep Smiling .... Hemant Agarwal


As may be observed from above, the expert comments received on your website some 3 years back appear to be contradictory to the comments received recently. The correct position thus need to clarified.

Request :
a. Need clarity as to whether a Private Limited Company can buy agricultural land in Maharashtra, irrespective of whether promoted by Agriculturist or non-agriculturist?

If yes, then :
b. What is the exact procedure for the same? Whether prior approval for the same is required to be obtained from any Govt Authorities?
c. Whether there is any ceiling for land holding by a Private Limited company? Can it acquire agricultural land on lease basis and whether the same would be added to land owned by the company for ceiling purpose, if any?

d. Whether the Agriculturist Director’s prorata land holding in a Pvt limited Company (in terms of % shareholding) would be added to his separate individual land holding for land ceiling purpose at individual level?

e. If the company leases out the land to others for agriculture use, whether the same would be treated as violation of law, since the lease income would not be agriculture income and in such case whether the District collector can acquire / forfeit the land from Company?

f. Can the company sell part of land to other agriculturist for agriculture purpose? In such case, whether the income by way of appreciation in land value/ capital gain will be in violation of the guidelines and in such case whether the Collector would have right to forfeit the balance land holding available with the company?

h. Can the company sell entire land owned by it to an agriculturist before winding up its operations, without inviting adverse implications from revenue/ Govt authorities? Any implications for the purchaser?


I shall be glad for quick response in the matter.

kunal   26 April 2013 at 14:14

Builder collaboration

sir in the case of builder collaboration. owner wants to transfer undivided share in land to the builder on the date of execution of GPA which is after completion of Building, not on the date of execution of development agreement to save Capital Gain Tax Liability.(as asset transferred becomes Long term,if right transferred on the date of execution of GPA)

for that he inserted one clause in collaboration agreement which is produced as under

"That till the time the first sale deed is executed for undivided share in land and roof (built up area) for the builder’s share, the builder shall only be a licensee on the scheduled property and it shall not get any ownership rights over the scheduled property. It is also clearly understood that permitting the Second Party to enter upon the scheduled property and construct the building shall not be construed as delivery of possession in part performance of the contract as understood under the provisions of Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act or under the provisions of The Income Tax Act.’"

sir please tell is it valid?

can GPA be termed as sale deed?

what language should be used in place of word "first sale deed" as builder want to sell his share to a prospective buyer through GPA.(basically to avoid stamp duty charges)

Can we replace the word "first sale deed" with GPA.

i'm enclosing herewith a draft of collaboration agreement. please advice, if there is any modification..

Mihir Shah   26 April 2013 at 13:59

Parking space in co operative housing society (chs)

Dear Sir,

Our society (CHS) had passed a order few months back with respect to allotment of unreserved open parking space on a first come first serve basis for a lump sum amount (one time only). However, in the allotment it had been mentioned that the CHS can take back the allotted parking space from the member on "justifiable grounds". I paid the said consideration to the CHS through cheque and was allotted the parking space. However, recently the CHS has altered the rules for allotment of parking space and has decided to allot the same on a lottery system for a fixed annual consideration (recurring yearly charges). Hence, the CHS has asked me to return the parking space allotted earlier and they shall refund the amount paid by me earlier. However, I don't want to return the said parking space since I had already paid the amount demanded by the CHS. What options do I have now?Dear Sir,

Our society (CHS) had passed a order few months back with respect to allotment of unreserved open parking space on a first come first serve basis for a lump sum amount (one time only). However, in the allotment it had been mentioned that the CHS can take back the allotted parking space from the member on "justifiable grounds". I paid the said consideration to the CHS through cheque and was allotted the parking space. However, recently the CHS has altered the rules for allotment of parking space and has decided to allot the same on a lottery system for a fixed annual consideration (recurring yearly charges). Hence, the CHS has asked me to return the parking space allotted earlier and they shall refund the amount paid by me earlier. However, I don't want to return the said parking space since I had already paid the amount demanded by the CHS. What options do I have now?Dear Sir,

Our society (CHS) had passed a order few months back with respect to allotment of unreserved open parking space on a first come first serve basis for a lump sum amount (one time only). However, in the allotment it had been mentioned that the CHS can take back the allotted parking space from the member on "justifiable grounds". I paid the said consideration to the CHS through cheque and was allotted the parking space. However, recently the CHS has altered the rules for allotment of parking space and has decided to allot the same on a lottery system for a fixed annual consideration (recurring yearly charges). Hence, the CHS has asked me to return the parking space allotted earlier and they shall refund the amount paid by me earlier. However, I don't want to return the said parking space since I had already paid the amount demanded by the CHS. What options do I have now?
Please note that the said parking space is the 2nd parking space allotted to me & in our society all the members have atleast one parking space reserved. The lottery system would also be for 2nd parking spaces for the members.
I reside in Mumbai.

Archana Das   26 April 2013 at 11:41

Issue of property

My father-in-law died last year, now brother-in-laws are forcing us to sell out the house or to give a huge amount to them against the same. We are staying there and that is father-in-laws house, what is the possible way to keep the house with us?

B.S.NARAHARI   26 April 2013 at 11:25

Compund wall construction

Dear Sirs,

I own a vacant ( 30feet * 40feet = 1200 sqfeet) plot in Bangalore North, My plot adjacent owner is constructing the house and now he started to construct compound wall and he has extended his compound wall by 3 inches in my plot. When i questioned him, He says since the compound wall being common to both of us, Legally it is allowed to put his compound wall in my plot. The 3 inches * 40 feet = 10 feet, So my neighbour encroached 10 feet of my property. Please advice me

Anmol   26 April 2013 at 09:16

Steps and precautions for buying a commercial property.

Sir, I am buying a lease hold booth , the seller holds the GPA with sale power and the booth is currently under rent agreement for 11 months with the seller, what precautions are to be followed for purchase of the same property .

Dillibabu Mohan   26 April 2013 at 09:08

Change age in sales deed property registration.

Hi, This is Dillibabu. I bought a flat in Feb 13 but in the sales deed registered my age has updated as 24 instead of 28. I bought this flat through bank loan and now my original registered sales deed with bank. Please advise how i can do the changes in the sales deed. This incorrect age will impact in future or if i sell the flat whether any impact due to incorrect age. I bought the flat getting home loan and the tenure is 20 years. Can i able to get the original document for rectification from Bank or I need to wait till my loan tenure over. How long i have time to do the changes in the documents. also advise whehter we can have other procedure like declaration etc to change the age in the registered document. Please advise.

Deepak   26 April 2013 at 08:03

Registration (karnataka amendment) act, 1976 issued in government notifications

Respected Sir/Madam,

We are buying a plot of agricultural land in Karnataka and one of the primary sale deeds, it is mentioned that this land does not have any objections under the following acts:

- "The registration of the following documents are declared as opposed to public policy by Government in exercise of powers conferred under S. 22 A(1) of the Registration (Karnataka Amendment) Act, 1976 issued in Government Notifications
(1) RD 132 ERG 76, dated 14th March, 1979;
(2) RD 44 ERG 81 dated 30th March, 1981,
(3) RD 132 ERG 76 (P), dated 3rd July, 1985;,
(4) RD 132 ERG 76, dated 20th June, 1988 "

Can you please explain what are the implications of the above mentioned acts and where can I read more on these acts?

Please Advice.

Thanks,
Deepak.