Poor girl defrauded by extorting fees for two years, provided forged Certificate
Rajneesh Madhok
(Querist) 27 May 2011
This query is : Resolved
Poor girl became victim of extortion from School management. One School extorted fees for two years and one school for half year. The certificate provided by one school about passing of +1 exam is useless. She paid for two and half years fees, Bus fees and addition to it the charges for extra coaching. The school extorted money and provided forged document of passing of 10+1 class which is useless. Now she is running from pillar to post to get justice but in vain.
The representations to the authorities have also been made
As
Complaint U/S 420, 465, 467, 468 and 471 for For defrauding and forgery. But no action has been taken so far.
Kindly suggest the way out.
Regards,
Rajneesh Madhok
----- Original Message -----
From: rajneesh madhok
To: chmn-cbse@nic.in ; secy-cbse@nic.in ; mcsharma.cbse@nic.in ; ropanchkula.cbse@nic.in ; vipsphagwara@gmail.com
Sent: Monday, May 23, 2011 11:20 PM
Subject: Complaint U/S 15 of Right to Education Act, 2009; School not issuing Transfer Certificate and refund fees collected on illegal parameters
Phagwara: Date May 23, 2011
1. The Chairman &Chief Vigilance Officer Mr. Vineet Joshi, IAS Tel. 91-11-22023737, 22467263
CENTRAL BOARD OF SECONDARY EDUCATION
SHIKSHA KENDRA, 2 COMMUNITY CENTRE
PREET VIHAR, DELHI- 110092
2. Affiliation, Administration and Scholarship Matters
Dr (Mrs) Veera Gupta
Secretary Tel. 91-11-22549627, 22549628
Email: secy-cbse@nic.in
3. Examination Matters M C Sharma,
Controller of Examination
Tel. 91-11-22515828
Email: mcsharma.cbse@nic.in
4. CBSE - REGIONAL OFFICE, DELHI
PS 1-2, INSTITUTIONAL AREA, I.P. EXTN., PATPARGANJ, DELHI - 110 090, Tel: 91-11-22239177-80, Fax: 22248883
Email: chmn-cbse@nic.in
5. Regional Office
Central Board of Secondary Education, Sector- 5 , Panchkula - 134109 (Haryana)
Haryana,U.T.of Chandigarh, Punjab, J&K, Himachal Pradesh.
Tel: 91-172-2585163/2585193
Fax:91-172-2585193
ropanchkula.cbse@nic.in
6. The Director General School Education,
Sarv Shiksha Abhiyan,
SCO-162-164, Sec-34 A,
Chandigarh.
7. Victoria International Public School,---------Respondent
VPO Chachoki ,G.T. Road,
Phagwara-144401 (Pb)
Ph: 01824-261744, 223821, 223824, Fax: 01824-223821, E-mail: vipsphagwara@gmail.com;
8. Kamla Nehru College for women,
Plahi Road,
Phagwara
Subject::
· COMPLAINT UNDER SCHEDULE 15 OF THE RIGHT TO EDUCATION ACT, 2009. UNDER THE ACT NO CHILD SHOULD DISCONTINUE EDUCATION BECAUSE OF DELAY IN ISSUING THE TRANSFER CERTIFICATE.
· STUDENT WANT TO TAKE ADMISSION IN PUNJAB SCHOOL EDUCATION BOARD SCHOOL BUT SCHOOL NOT ISSUING TRANSFER CERTIFICATE.
· RIGHT TO EDUCATION IS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT BUT SCHOOL IS DEPRIVING STUDENT FROM HER FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS.
1. Complaint against Victoria International Public School regarding Non-issuance of School Leaving Certificate / Transfer Certificate & extorted fees for two years on illegal parameters.
2. Due to delay in issuance of Transfer Certificate Student will lose this academic year also.
3. New School from which the student wants to apply not admitting without Transfer Certificate from School in which she studied earlier.
4. As per State Department of Public instructions guidelines the schools should not delay the TC-issuing process. Even if the student requests for a TC in the middle of the academic year. The school should consider it as an emergency and issue the TC immediately.
5. If the negligence in issuing the TC, the Principals of both schools, that is from where the TC is needed and the school that the child wants to join will be held responsible.
R/Sirs,
It is humbly submitted that the complainant is a resident of V &P.O. Dhesian Kahna Tehsil Phillaur, Distt. Jalandhar. Hence is competent to invoke the right of life and liberty.
I am fighting struggling to get justice and there is high scale violation of the human rights from Victoria Internation Public School, G.T. Road, Phagwara. The under mentioned details are the proof of continuous harassment. The facts of the case are as following.
1. That the complainant has been the student of said Victoria International Public School, Phagwara and appeared in March 2009 vide Roll No. 2188271 in 10th class through that school in CBSE, Secondary School Examination 2009 and got compartments in Mathematics and English Comm Papers.-- Annexure Page 1
2. That the student was admitted to the next class by Victoria international public School in +1 from April 2009 and collected fees and other charges from the student.
3. That the student appeared in Aug 2009 in one subject of Maths whereas the school collected examination fees from the student for appearing in two subjects. As English language subject was not compulsory to clear so the school collected Examination fees for two subjects but sent fees for one subject to CBSE.
4. That in Aug 2009 exam conducted by CBSE the student could not qualify in the said paper of Maths.
5. That in March 2010 the student cleared the exam of Secondary Education vide Roll No. 2175660 and the certificate of Pass issued on 28-05-2010 but the said certificate has not been delivered to the student. –Annexure Page 2.
6. That the student keep on visiting the office of school to get the result card, one day the school directed her to visit office of CBSE, Panchkula to get the result card. On numerous visits she was told that her certificate will be sent to her home address.
7. The Certificate issued by CBSE certifying that the student has qualified the Secondary School Examination of the board held in March, 2010. –Annexure –Page-3-
8. That the Regional office Central Board of Secondary Education, Sector 5, Panchkula (Haryana) sent the Result card which was delivered to student on 4th Jan 2011. Annexure Page 4 with postal stamps of delivery of document.
9. That on the basis of compartment candidate the student got admission in Kamla Nehru College for Women, Phagwara in +1 class in April 2010.
10. That as the result of compartments in Maths and English was declared in May 2009 which the student could not qualify. The student was directed to visit to Victoria International Public School by Kamla Nehru College for women to file examination form to Reappear in 10th Class.
11. That on visit to Victoria International Public School the school management forced the student to get admission in their school if she wants to get her forms filled up for appearance in exam. The admission in the School was given in Mid session and the student has to pay fees for complete session to Victoria International Public School, Phagwara and half session to Kamla Nehru Public School, Phagwara.
12. That in March 2010 the student passed +1 exam conducted by Victoria International Public School, Phagwara and the result declared vide Admission No. 1825 declared by School. Annexure Page –5 to 7.
13. That on passing the said exam the student got admitted in +2 class in April 2010. As the result card of 10th Class has not been in the possession of the candidate the candidate had been harassed to bring the said card from CBSE to appear in +2 exam.
14. That on visit to CBSE office at Panchkula the student was told that she can not appear in +2 exam in this session as she has passed 10th Class exam in 2010 as per record and there should be a gap of one year in appearance in +2 exam. But the Principal, Victoria Interantional Public School who has collected fees for 10+2 Admission fees, Tuition fees and examination fees of Rs 600=00 do not admit the instruction of CBSE says that the student can appear in 10+2 class of CBSE.
RELIEF SOUGHT:
1. Victoria International Public School, Phagwara refused to give School-Leaving Certificate/ Transfer Certificate AND NOT REFUNDING This is UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES. Kindly direct the school to issue School-Leaving Certificate / Transfer Certificate as the said school has withheld the Transfer Certificate on flimsy grounds and refund the fees collected from the student for the current session and past session.
2. No dues certificate and Transfer Certificate kindly be issued immediately.
3. Harassment casued to student and parents kindly be duly compensated with Rs 1,00,000.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
Raman Deep Kaur,
VPO Dhesian Kahna,
Tehsil Phillaur,
Distt. Jalandhar Punjab,
Pin: 141311
Ph: 01826-270096, 98147-004493
Through: Rajneesh Madhok,
B-xxx/63, Nehru Nagar,
St. No. 2, Railway Road,
Phagwara-144401 (Pb)
Ph: 01824-262569 (O), 268210 (R), 094173-06415 (M)
Tele-fax: 01824-262569, E-mail: rmadhok_pgm@bsnl.in; rajneesh_madhok@yahoo.com
Rajneesh Madhok
(Querist) 28 May 2011
The student got compartments in two subjects in English and Maths in 10th class. As Victoria International public school from where she appeared in that class do not want to continue the studies in that school. So she took admission in 10+1 class at Kamla Nehru college for women. When she got result of 10th class reappear, she came to know that the class has not been cleared. The said Kamla Nehru college directed her to go to her parental school Victoria International Public School to appear in 10th class compartment papers. She went to Victoria international Public School. Victoria international Public School directed her to get admission in 10+1 class in their school if she like to appear in 10th class exam. This way she paid half year fees to Kamla Nehru College and then Victoria International public school charged fees for full year and provided admission to her in class 10+1. She cleared the exam of 10+1 from Victoria International public School but could not clear 10th class reappear paper. Victoria international played one gimmick as well that the school collected reappear fees for two subjects to be sent to CBSE and kept one subject paper of English with them and sent one paper fees to CBSE, as student had cleared two language papers i.e. Hindi and Punjabi so it was not a condition to clear third paper of English.
The lacunae is that Student cleared 10+1 class from Victoria International public school and school provided her certificate of Qualifying that class. That way she was promoted to 10+2 class.
She paid fees for the session of +2 as well but at the time of submission of examination form for 10+2 she was denied to appear in 10+2 class in CBSE by education board.
Now when she request to Victoria international public school to provide her School Leaving Certificate / Transfer Certificate, the said school don't provide her Transfer certificate. Secondly the fees collected by Victoria Interantional public school for two years study is not within the parameters of law. The school keep on charging fees from student and provided forged certificate which is useless.
Now kindly guide what should be the next course of action.
Regards,
Rajneesh
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 28 May 2011
