Daughters right
Jyo
(Querist) 14 March 2012
This query is : Resolved
Can a doughtier get a eqaul share in her fathers property which was inherited by his father from his grand mother.?
ajay sethi
(Expert) 14 March 2012
yes daughters have equal rights on father property
Jyo
(Querist) 15 March 2012
Thanks for the reply but will doughters get share if fathers property is gifted to him from his grand mother( I e mothers mother ) and can he make a will for that gifted property
Guest
(Expert) 15 March 2012
Dear Jyo,
If you ask questions in delinked manner without giving full background, you are likely to get contradictory replies, which can confuse you more than serving your purpose.
At first, you asked about grand father's property received by grandson (father of a daughter), but you did not mention, how he got that property and also omitted the role of grand mother and also of father and mother of the beneficiary, while you have now come up with another question about gift by his grand mother.
Why don't you make a mention of what is the real problem for which you want solution, instead of putting acdemic type questions to enhance your knowledge in a partial manner, which may not help you in solving your real problem?
HOWEVER, for your information, if the father had received that property in the shape of a gift from his grand mother, his daughter won't have any right to exercise over such a property during the life time of her father.
Anirudh
(Expert) 15 March 2012
When the usually always correct Mr. Ajay Sethi himself commits error in the answer, I cannot expect Mr. Makkad to be correct in his answer.
Mr. Dhingra is trying to find some fault in the query though there is no such error. However, Mr. Dhingra has answered correctly in his last paragraph.
The answers by many of the experts is such that only if the querist is truly lucky he will get a correct answer!
Guest
(Expert) 24 March 2012
Mr. Anirudh,
Better, if you review your own position with reference to your own post vis-a-vis the posts of others, read with my present post.
I find your sole intention was only to find fault with the replies of experts when in your post, as reproduced below, you have not provided any legal solution for the querist except that you have not only criticised me, but also not spared S/Shri Ajay Sethi and Raj Kumar Makkad against their replies. For your information reply of both the experts is correct, as per the original query, but you have termed that as incorrect.
EXTRACT OF YOUR REPLY:
"When the usually always correct Mr. Ajay Sethi himself commits error in the answer, I cannot expect Mr. Makkad to be correct in his answer.
Mr. Dhingra is trying to find some fault in the query though there is no such error. However, Mr. Dhingra has answered correctly in his last paragraph.
The answers by many of the experts is such that only if the querist is truly lucky he will get a correct answer!"
You should better have tried to understand, that the answers of S/Shri Kriti Kumar, Ajay Sethi and Raj Kumar makkad were correct in the context of the original question.
On the contrary, you should also have understood that my answer was based in the context of the supplementary query of the querist, while she did not mention the stated fact in the first query.
BY THE WAY, in your opinion, what was wrong in my asking the querist not to put questions in delinked manner without giving full background? I repeat the query below on which my answer was based:
EXTRACT OF SUPPLEMENTARY QUESTION OF THE QUERIST:
"Thanks for the reply but will doughters get share if fathers property is gifted to him from his grand mother( I e mothers mother ) and can he make a will for that gifted property"
ajay sethi
(Expert) 24 March 2012
Mr anirudh /Mr dhingraji
both of you are highly respected experts .
generally querists fail to disclose complete material facts of the case . our answers are based on the inputs received from the querists .
may i humbly ussgest that it would be advisable to use private message option if you desire to make any suggestions to other experts .
i would like to avoid un necessary controversies in the forum .you are at liberty to correct me if i am wrong and do not mind being corrected . it is just a suggestions to both the learned experts .
Guest
(Expert) 24 March 2012
Dear Ajay,
I respect you and know that your answer was quite correct in accordance with the question raised by the querist. That I confirmed also in my latest post. I also know that there was nothing wrong in my reply, if I had advised the querist to put all the facts in a single question to get correct solution. I did not even have any objection had Mr. Anirudh asked for any clarification through PM, if he had any doubt or objection.
But, probably Mr. Anirudh preferred to prove as if he was quite talented to prove yours and Shri Makkad's answer as wrong, besides criticising me also along with both of you on the open forum, that too without giving any right solution of his own against your answer. That was the compelling reason to reply his post openly along side his wrong post.
Moreover, the wrongly raised controversy of Mr. Anirudh would also have been quite sufficient to confuse the querist even for the correct answers received by her earlier.
prabhakar singh
(Expert) 31 March 2012
SAYING GOODBYE TO ALL GOOD THINGS GONE ABOVE..MY ANSWER TO YOUR THIS NEXT PART OF QUESTION "but will doughters get share if fathers property is gifted to him from his grand mother( I e mothers mother ) and can he make a will for that gifted property" IS
THAT PROPERTY INHERITED BY FATHER FROM HIS MOTHER ?or/Grand Mother OR GIFTED BY HER TO HIM IS HIS SELF ACQUIRED PROPERTY AND HIS DAUGHTER OR SON OR WIDOW CAN INHERIT THE SAME ONLY WHEN HE DIES INTESTATE SINCE THE FATHER HAS ABSOLUTE RIGHTS OVER THE PROPERTY WITH ALL KIND OF TRANSFERABLE AND TESTAMENTARY RIGHTS OVER IT DURING HIS LIFE TIME.
