If victim recorded confessional statement u/s 164 crpc, may it be treated as an evidence during trial.
During the trial, can victim withdraw his/her 164 crpc statement, given earlier, or can he/she claim it as false and can s/he change his/her statement in his favor during trial?
Can the complainant may get a copy of said statement?
Can police made charge sheet on the basis of 164 statement of victims?
Note: Complement has the legal relation with victim.(spouse)
please respond.
Dear all,
According to my FIR against my in-laws u/s 365,366,506,497 IPC, police has recovered my wife from her 2nd husband house and 164 crpc statement was recorded where she stated that she marry me on her self will on 27/03/12 and there after on 28/03/12 evening her brothers forcefully taken her back from me and by force given her a 2nd marriage with X of ABCD village, who is a teacher of Y school(govt.) on 1/4/12. And also stated that X (2n husband) force her to s_x with him. But now as she is conceived by X she doesn't want to came back and stay with me. although the stage of pregnancy can be abortion.
1) So, in which section police may made charge sheet and against whom? after charge sheet what will be the process?
2) As she refuse me, may it possible to charge against her u/s 494 IPC.
3) is 164 crpc statement is an evidence for trial.
4) at the time of trial, can she withdraw her 164 statement on the ground that it is false and can she Dennie her 2nd marriage?
5) may 497 can be imposed against X and be punished?
6) at the time of trial, if she want to came back, is it possible? and as she refuse to stay with me, is my husband ship became void/invalid?
7)Her parents threat me to withdraw the case/FIR. what should i do? actually her parents and currently she also insult me and my family. so i want to give them a good lesson.
note. being husband may i have right to ask medical test to proof 497 against X?
please help.
thanks
BPS
surjit singh
31 August 2012 at 07:58
In a criminal matter initially the FIR was registered on non bailable section, subsequently the charge-sheet was submitted in bailable sections. At the time of taking the cognizance by the CJM out of 6 persons 2 were exonerated at the cognizance stage. When the matter came up for charge it was pointed out by the counsel that since there is only 4 person in the case so the question of unlawful assembly does not arisen. It is really surprising to see that the trial court refuse the entertain the argument on the ground that the cognizance has already been taken in this section by the CJM.
The matter was taken up in the High Court by one of the accused and the counsel in the High Court was not able to place the case properly and the High Court ordered as under.
"Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that charges have already been framed in this case. This case according to the counsel for the petitioner, arises out of a land dispute. In fact there is no firing etc. and, therefore, cognizance has been taken under Section 307 of the Indian Penal Code on 28.11.2007. It is further submitted that Section 380 of the Indian Penal Code is not applicable in a case where there is admitted land dispute.
Since charges have already been framed and trial has begun, this application has become infructuous.
In the result, this application is dismissed as infructuous"
The cogizance was not taken under section 307. The case relates to 2005, the charge was framed in Jan 2008, since then summons were issued to the witnesses with reminder and till date non of the witnesses turned up before the court. The accused are attending court of each date.
What is the next remedy available to the accused. CAN ANY OTHER ACCUSED IN THE CASE APPROACH THE HIGH COURT AGAIN FOR QUASHING.
manish jeswani
31 August 2012 at 00:49
Hello experts
My client was charge sheeted for offence under sections 294 and 506 of penal code. Honourable court discharged him for offence under section 294 and framed charge under section 506. I raised objection that section 506 being non cognizable permission to investigate was required and accused solid also have been discharged from 506 also. The court it's of opinion that police can also investigate non cognizable offences along with cognizable offences and it is after taking cognizance the court found that prima facie offence under section 294 was not made out and hence permission for investigating offence under 506 does not arise at all.
1 my first query to experts is whether there is any citation that if cognizable offence it's not made out and only non cognizable offence is made puout in such circulant also y the permission is required and court can not take cognizance.
2 Whether the provisions under section will not be held nugatory if police in garb of investigating registers cognizable case even though on the facts of the case no cognizable offence it's made out.
3 why shouldn't in such cases the entire investigation should be held illegal.
Please guide me along with citations preferably of Bombay or supreme court
deva
31 August 2012 at 00:08
my aunty lived as a spinister she bulit her own house.she execute reg will.in that she says she has been bequeathed her properties her youngest brother.in that same will she says she not bequeathed properties to any other brothers it say with her brother names.in that house govt office has been as teant.after her dead to get rent payment.her other 3 brothers are giveing a affidavity cum indemnity bond before notary.in that they all are saying they all her sister voluntarly executed registered will.in respect of the above said property favour her youngest brother bequething with good state of mind with out any one interence by anyone and they saying her youngest brother who is the only legal heir of deceased entitled to get the estate of deceased.and also they saying that their is neither nor other person claiming the right and tittle and interest of the deceased except youngest brother in that affidavit cum indenity bond sing infornt of notary in bond that has been give to govt office then rent come with out any trouble.now one off two brothers sending a legal notice to govt office said that they are inherited the demised legal heirs for that building and the says we all oraly partition the building before sing the affidavit cum indenity bond executed thy saying to stop pay ment. after long enqury ,go through all doc govt department execut new order that pay all arrears and that said youngest brother is the londlort of that govt office building now my unle like to take criminal action against them pls guid as what to do next?which act we can take crimial action.pls help as they all trying to get that property.ask by ravikumar
Raman
30 August 2012 at 21:58
Sir,
I have been given Anticipatory bail for limited duration of 1 month only and the contents of the order are as follows
" In the event of arrest, accused shall be released on bail by the arresting officer and this order shall be effective for the period of 1 month and during which the accused-petitioner has to approach before the Ilaqa magistrate for regular bail"
After going through the above order, whether its advisable to approach before the Police who will first arrest me and grant me bail or straight away I should made the application before the Ilaqa magistare for regular bail ???
Tarun
30 August 2012 at 19:05
IS REVISION AGAINST NOTICE OF ACCUSATION IN 138 N.I ACT IS MAINTAINABLE AGAINST ORDER OF MAGISTRATE IN SESSION COURT OR NOT? IS IT NOTICE OF ACCUSATION IS LIKE CHARGE OR NOT ? IF YES PLZ GIVE ME SOME CITATIONS/JUDGEMENTS.
tarun
30 August 2012 at 18:31
FRIENDS IS REVISION AGAINST NOTICE OF ACCUSATION IN 138 N.I ACT IS MAINTAINABLE AGAINST ORDER OF MAGISTRATE IN SESSION COURT OR NOT? IS IT NOTICE OF ACCUSATION IS LIKE CHARGE OR NOT ? IF YES PLZ GIVE ME SOME CITATIONS/JUDGEMENTS.
pranjal
30 August 2012 at 18:07
R/s,i have joined this site as i need the help of lawyers who are on this site.My cousin has used fake graduation certificate to get a job in public sector.At present he is in prison so can he gets bail and for how many years he has to spent in prison.please tell any solution to cope up with this problem.
Food adulteration act
What is the effect of BR reading at 40 degree in the milk, and how milk is declared adulterated. What is the effect in the milk