anand
01 October 2012 at 14:03
Hi,
I am resubmitting a question with additional information after researching answers submitted by learned members.
Brief facts:
Money from my salary in joint account sent to wife's individual account for real estate purchase. There are no other transactions in that account. She returns money and claims it as dowry. Family is arrested and put in jail.
Ld. members have rightly said no breach of trust is made out.
I see breach of trust has 2 ingredients: entrustment and misappropriation/conversion.
I have some evidence of exchanging property papers, though no contract was made.
Follow up questions:
1. If the above facts don't constitute entrustment, is a case of 403 at least made out?
2. Doesn't her statement that the said returned amount is dowry (there are no other transactions in that account) amount to "conversion" even though I have not suffered monetary loss (but there is loss of reputation)?
I understand this is probably good defence, but the only reason I am looking to be offensive is because my aged parents are in poor health and will have trouble making in through trial.
3. If this is only good defence, is there any way to get the magistrate to consider this evidence first and fast track trial?
Grateful for the help.
Prakash
01 October 2012 at 00:42
Ld counsels,
Wife in her cross examination before the family court denied the suggestion that the marriage is solemnized and stated that marriage is not solemnized.
But in the cross examination before the magistrate court she had stated that she doesnt know whether she made any statement that the marriage was not solemnized.
Will this contrary stand goes to show that wife is misleading the court by giving false statements during cross examinations.
Thanks in advance.
Raman
30 September 2012 at 22:28
Sir, If someone quash the criminal proceedings/FIR by filing mandanmus, certerorai writ.In that case whether its wise to consider the writ under Civil writ Jurisdiction?
K.Hemachandran
30 September 2012 at 19:37
Sir / Madam,
A person having many PAN card, Driving licence, Bank accounts. In all different names, different fathers name, different date of birth, but photo is the same person. He cheats banks and financial companies, etc... by taking loans or some other financial dealings. He cheats many peoples, in that one is my friend. This person is from a police family. So if give complaint in police station, they do favor to this person. I want to complaint this person for the interest of others. I like to know where I can complaint of this person.
Thanks
K.Hemachandran
(90922 11123)
JMJMJMJMJM
30 September 2012 at 19:03
How can Indian courts request documents such as visas issued to Indian citizens from foreign consulates?
Harassed
30 September 2012 at 18:28
My ex- has filed a false dowry case and attached various documents of alleged dowry transactions. The documents attached to the chargesheet agree with the amounts she has claimed as dowry but they show the following:
1. The bank statement shows the alleged dowry amount was paid to her uncle, not to us.
2. Another so-called dowry amount was a cash withdrawal she has claimed as a business expenditure for a guest at her company.
Can I file any cases against them for falsely getting my extended family arrested besides using it for my defence?
anand
30 September 2012 at 17:10
I am the victim of a false 498a case.
Wife tells me her father can purchase a site for us in city X. We live in city Y. She takes money out of our JOINT account and sends it to her individual account operated by her father in city X. The source of the money is entirely my salary. Father doesn't purchase house after many months. She returns the money back to me after a lot of effort. All transactions done via cheque and documented. Now, she files 498a and dowry case and claims she was forced by me to give that money from her individual account which she states is dowry. There is no mention that I gave her in the money.
Can I file a case claiming breach of trust? The agreement between us for the site was oral, but the money transfers are all via cheque.
Harassed
30 September 2012 at 14:48
My wife filed a divorce case first. I asked for all the assets including my salary and jewellery back she had taken from our joint account. This is a huge sum of many lakhs.
Now, several months later, she filed a 498a with very serious allegations that were not present in her divorce petition. The next day she has filed a DV case with the exact same allegations as the 498a. Only difference - she is also asking for protection orders (no residence, maintenance or compensation requests).
The DV case does not disclose either the divorce or the 498a cases she had already filed.
Is DV maintainable if it is filed AFTER she has initiated divorce, and AFTER 498a and with the exact same allegations as the 498a?
JM
30 September 2012 at 14:18
Ex- had filed 498a, DV and several other cases against all of us.
In 498a, she has mentioned that I had some old clothes and utensils(!!!!) of hers at my home. Nothing else. She had also sent a legal notice about it before the 498a (the legal notice was 1 year ago; the 498a came 6 months later). The list of items accompanying the 498a FIR was blank.
Now, she is threatening to file a 406 one year after the notice. She is planning to use wedding photos and videos of jewellery as evidence. Since we moved abroad after the marriage, none of the jewellery gifted to her by my parents and her parents was with us - we left it with her parents itself. She actually has several lakhs of our jewellery with her for which we have receipts also.
Will the 406 against us stand? Can I use the fact that she is making this belated claim which was not present in the original 498a (which has several other sections included) or the legal notice which includes ridiculous stuff such as clothes/utensils?
Crpc 188 for offences abroad
1. Can an Indian citizen be prosecuted in India for a forgery that happened in the USA if he has relocated for good here?
2. What is the procedure for requesting permission from the Central Govt. for requesting permission under CrPC 188? Is it the MHA? MEA?
3. Who should request this permission? The complainant/his advocate? Police? The magistrate?
Please advice.