LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

J SRINIVASAN   03 December 2012 at 15:21

Case and departmental enquiry

Dear Sir

Kindly find attached my case history file.
MY CASE HISTORY :
I was working as Manager Finance in NTPC Simhadri-Vishakhapatnam.
Earlier from 18.12.1986 to 24th April 2011 I was working in NTPC VSTPS, Madhya Pradesh
On 28th April 2011 , I have joined in Vishakhapatnam office as manager finance
On 22nd June 2011, I was taken to Delhi Head office by my HOD by saying that there is a capitalisation meeting to be held at delhi.
On reaching delhi head office, I was shown some wrong payments / financial irregularities by the corporate ERP team which has took place during the year 2008 to 2011 at VSTPS Madhya Pradesh., i.e., during that period I was working in Madhyapradesh Project. The management wants explanation for that . Originally I was brought to delhi for some capitalization meeting and no such meeting occurred at delhi.
Later, I was told to write down the irregularities appearing on the system in a paper, by saying that these irregularities happened during my tenure at Madhya Pradesh project. The management told me that we will be discussing this matter with Director finance, NTPC who was on tour to Mumbai and likely to return on Saturday i.e., 25th june.
On 25th June 2011, the management told me that it is better to visit VSTPS, Madhya Pradesh project so that the irregularities can be finalized , and then we can meet Director finance. I have also agreed to that.
On 25th night, we have reached Madhyapradesh Unit by flight, then the management has simply served me SUSPENSION LETTER. The officials have never talked or discussed or questioned anything. The suspension letter is simply typed as “ Kept under suspension pending enquiry on report of financial irregularities “. It is not mentioning , what type of irregularities reported and during which period and also the SUSPENSION LETTER is not as per the proforma mentioned in NTPC CDA/Disciplinary Rules.
Immediately after issing the suspension letter, the town inspector appeared at that place, and the management handed over me to the police.
Police produced me before magistrate, Waidhan district- Singrauli and issued warrant to send me to Pachor Jail.
No body has questioned me anything including police. I was totally stunned. My bail application was initially rejected by the lower court , on the reason , that charge sheet not produced by police and also due to the objection imposed by NTPC.
I have moved my bail application with Jabalpur High Court. There also , NTPC oppsed my application and my bail got refused on 18.12.2011 even after 3 months and the chargesheet received. Again a revision was filed by my lawyer and it was withdrawn by him . Again 3rd application was filed by my lawer and I have changed my Lawyer since, the one who has not been appointed , seems to be not responding to my family’s request. After changing the Lawyer at Jabalpur and the hearing , I finally got BAIL on 12.10.2012. In total I WAS IN JAIL NEARLY 16 MONTHS.
After coming out on bail, I have sent a letter to Director HR, NTPC-Delhi , by explaining the facts and questioned my suspension , which is not done as per NTPC norms,CDA/Disiciplinary rules and request them for re-instating me to work . Also I have sent my bail out order copy for release of my subsistence allowance from 01.05.2011 to till date .
The letters were duly sent through Registered Post and Acknowledgement also received . In the meanwhile, I have received a letter from GM Finance NTPC-Delhi, stating that , he is appointed by NTPC as enquiry officer and the letter says that I have to appear before them for departmental enquiry .
MY QUERIES ARE :
1. Can my suspension done by NTPC in cunning way is challengeable before court of Law?
2. Can I approach Court for release of subsistence allowance from 01.05.2011 ?
3. Can I approach Court for STAY - to the improper departmental enquiry ?
4. If it cannot be stayed, then Can I accompany a lawyer for departmental enquiry. ?
5. Since, the trial has started, Can I stop the departmental enquiry , since, displaying my evidences to the department may prejudice to the court case?

THE STATUS OF THE CASE AT COURT :
The case has been committed and charges are framed under IPC 409,420,464,468,471.
The trial has also started on 16.11.2012 and nobody appeared.
The next trial is to take place on 22nd January 2013. I HAVE COLLECTED MY EVIDENCES TO SOME EXTENT FROM NTPC THROUGH PETITION IN TRIAL COURT U/S. 91 OF IPC.
ANY DETAILS ABOUT THE CASE MAY PLEASE BE EMAILED TO ME .
Please suggest me good replies, since my mental agony is increasing day by day . any further details if u need , please mail to my email id .
Srinivasan J

shuvendu   03 December 2012 at 14:40

Cheating money

Sir
I am shuvendu mallick from odisha need some advice about my problem.I have given my friend 20lacINR as lending with interest @ 4 % by keeping 2 Rs 100 blank agreement papers on which he has signed and 2 axis bank priority account cheque of him.Sir he has taken it saying that he will start a import /export business at port and will make me a partner of it.He has taken it as deposit money towards the contract with the port.He that time promised me that he will repay with in one month,but till date he has not returned me.and also playing with me.I have given him it on 02.01.2012.it is almost one year i haven't got a single pie.
So what should i do now to get my money back?
Many people saying that if u file a case then no doubt he will go to jail but there is no provision in law that you will get your money back.
So plz tell me how can i get my money back.

dattaraj   03 December 2012 at 13:14

5 years 498a 77 dates wife not attending

dear lawyers please help

each time new judge come and open the matter for summons first 3 years lost wife not attended,
after summons wife visited but that time judge was on leave after three dates judge issued warrant against wife and her family witness in 498a then two years has lost no visit from wife side,
husband side has attended 77 dates yet no action from judge against wife

help me what to do now, no lawyer is giving proper answer and out of 31 lawyers 27 lawyers said delay causes to dismiss the process of law so we have to wait even though the all allegations are totally totally false and non a single word of dowery harassment is true.
all gentleman well aware about the problems and mental position of a human being so please help give some suggestions to move before the court to dispose the matter as early time the old aged parents finish their life without justice in this india.

KRISHNAN   03 December 2012 at 12:55

Model appeal

Thank you for both of your reply sirs.

Then under which provision we have file that appeal.

Member (Account Deleted)   03 December 2012 at 09:13

Quash fir

hi,

Myself, my mom, dad & chithapa was charged under 498a, dv 3, 4. I was remanded and came on bail. After that my wife accepted for settlement and filled 13b. After that i filled petition in high court for quashing my fir. 3 hearining has gone. Since the second respondent is my wife( 1st - inspector) and as she is not appearing for the hearing to quash my fir, judge is postponing the hearining every time. I doubt she wont come for hearring for quash.
what should i do? will the judge give order for quash without her presenc?

velmurugan   03 December 2012 at 05:51

My humble question to the experts is:

Dear experts,

we ,public servants,have been accused in a bribery case under sections 120B of IPc and sections 7,12,13(1) r/w 13(d) following a ACB raid,along with 8 different private parties.The transaction as alleged had happened in a single day.It was registered as single FIR.NOw,8 different chargesheets have been filed as 8 different calendar cases wherein we,public servants are arraigned as main accused in each case(alleged bribe takers) while the private parties as other accused(alleged bribe givers) in their respective cases.The charges are yet to be framed.Now my humble question to the experts is:
1.Can all these 8 CCs can be clubbed together and can it be done as a single trial.
2.As CRpc have provisions for the joinder of maximum 3 CCS,as per my limited knowledge,is there any other sections in Crpc so that i can pray for a common trial?
3.and is it better to have single trial or 8 separate ones?

Kindly enlighten me and i would be really thankful to the experts.

Ranganath   03 December 2012 at 00:38

Options available for criminal court at the final stage

Ld Counsels,

What possiblities are there for a criminal court while passing final judgment of acquittal.

Upon appreciating evidence can the court arrive at a conclusion that charges are based on hearsay evidence and there is no legal evidence even prima facie.

Is the criminal court prohibited from arriving at this conclusion as this will amount to reviewing its own order of framing of charges against the accused.

Please clarify, thanks in advance.

Manjeet kumar sahu   02 December 2012 at 21:02

Dowry death

In what context,Dowry death is different from murder?
Please throw some light as to why Dowry Death was inserted under IPC.
Is it merely because of the unprecedented growth of such kind of secret killing.
(If this is the reason Honor killing awaits at the periphery.)

I think Murder in itself can cover such offences.Creating different kind of offences will only create quandary.

ACID ATTACK IS ALSO IN VERGE OF GETTING ITS PLACE UNDER IPC.

Mehrunisha   02 December 2012 at 17:03

Time limit

Hi,

In compromise cases if we file application in high court for quashing of Proceedings, how much time the high court gives to clear the objection, Is there any time limit

ramakrishna   02 December 2012 at 14:38

498a n dv 3 n 4

sir i got regd marriage 2008 and the traditional marriage in 2010 hardly 10 days i stayed in india my wife left to hyd after i left.she joined me in july 2011 after coming to australia after 3 days she was caught speaking to someone hours together.i asked whom she is speaking she kept mum,when i asked my dad to verify the no it was of a counsltant.when confirm asked who he is.she simply said i am in love with him before marriage.when i verified throughly her emails they r in deep love.i have taken print out of emails/her lover photo now she reached india she booked me n my mum/dad 498 and dvc they r out of bail plz advice