Prasad N Patil
02 June 2011 at 09:33
Sir,
Is it lawful to record phone conversations & save the same of others in maharashtra circle?
pl advice.
Ajay Pal Jangra
02 June 2011 at 07:58
Subject: Asked for RTI information but information received is insufficient, bungling & misleading.
Sir, I asked for some information on dated 28.3.2011 from PIO o/o AMM BPCL co. near IOC Refinery, Panipat, Haryana.The information received vide there letter no. BPCLD/R/2011/00979 dated 19.5.2011 received on dated 1.6.2011 is insufficient, bungling and misleading. I asked for information in the following format –
1. Please inform me the followings:-
1. Frontage required (in meters/ feet) for Rural R.O. of BPCL. For Other Companies i.e. for HPCL and IOCL it is minimum 30m. / 100’.
2. Minimum Size of Plot required for Rural R.O. (in meters/ feet)
3. Size of Plots offered by following applicants for Location No.32 of Rural R.O. Arya Nagar Dist. Hisar. In this Performa-
Sr. No. Name of applicant Size of Plot offered (in mt. / feet) Frontage offered (in mt. / feet) in Application form Actual Frontage found at the time of Inspection by the Committee
1. Babita D/o Sh. Chet Ram
2. Rani Bala W/o Sh. Ajay Pal
3. Inform about the marks awarded by the Site Inspection Committee against following parameters to the applicants of Location No.32 of Rural R.O. Arya Nagar Dist. Hisar
Sl.No
Retail Outlet Site Evaluation Parameters
Retail Outlets (Maximum
Marks)
Name of Applicants
Highway/Ru
ral/ Others
Babita D/o Sh. Chet Ram Rani Bala W/o Sh. Ajay Pal Shweta Jangir W/o Sh. Satya Parkash Luxmi Rani W/o Sh. Baljeet Singh
1 Sales potential 15
2 Frontage 12
3 No earth filling required 7
4 No earth/rock cutting required 4
5 No Low Tension Over Head Line 3
6 No Over Head Telephone Line 3
7 No Trees 2
8 Proximity to culvert (farther from culvert desirable)
11
9 Soil Type (Soft) 5
10 Availability of Power 8
11 Availability of Water 8
12 Visibility from Road 9
13 No presence of Divider 4
14 Outside Octroi Limits 9
Total 100
The reply / information received vide above mentioned letter is as follows –
"The information sought is a third party information and will infringe the privacy of the individuals concerned , and hence denied u/s 8 (1)(j)of RTI Act.
1. What should I do to get the required information as per my Performa attached which PIO has denied quoting section 8(1) (j) of RTI Act. However the PIO has written to go for appeal. Can I get the required information from the Appellate Authority or he will also cover the information by taking the shelter of the said section.
2. The PIO has denied the information which however related to the applicants for dealership of Petrol Pump outlet but the frontage of land offered by each applicant was measured by representative of the BPCL co. and the marks allotted are also awarded by Selection Committee of BPCL.co. and the this information is being hide by the PIO taking the shelter of section 8 (1) (j) of RTI Act. The reason behind not supplying the information is suspicious.
3. Is this the act of arbitration of the part of BPCL co. and PIO.
Anonymous
01 June 2011 at 23:27
My grand mother registered a settlement deed for myself & my brother after my fathers death with a provision that it is not revocable at any stage. But due to some family problem she is now threatening us that she is going to cancel the settlement deed. But in the deed it is clearly mentioned that it is not revocable.
The property is owned by my grand mother only and it is not inherited. I heared that the settlement deed is revocable unilaterally without the knowledge of the claiments whether it is possible or not. Please give the appropriate answer. Thank you...
Anonymous
01 June 2011 at 23:24
My grand mother registered a settlement deed for myself & my brother after my fathers death with a provision that it is not revocable at any stage. But due to some family problem she is now threatening us that she is going to cancel the settlement deed. But in the deed it is clearly mentioned that it is not revocable.
The property is owned by my grand mother only and it is not inherited. I heared that the settlement deed is revocable unilaterally without the knowledge of the claiments whether it is possible or not. Please give the appropriate answer. Thank you...
Anonymous
01 June 2011 at 21:48
my grandfather buy some agriculture land he registerd it to my fathers name when he is only 11 years old.now at this time can my father tranfer this property to any person.....they have right??? what is my part in property...
virendermahajan
01 June 2011 at 21:31
MY FATHER CONTRACTED WITH DEBT IN YEAR 2000 AND UNDER PIOS OBLIGATION I SON I HAVE TO PAY BUT MY QUESTION WHETHER MY PERSONAL ASSET WHICH I EARNED BY DOING JOB THAT IS MY HOUSE IS ALSO LIABLE FOR PAYMENT DEBT WAS OF YEAR 2000 I AM CA WORKING IN INDUSTRY AND I AM MARRIED WITH KIDS .WHETHER I HAVE TO FACE CRIMINAL TRIAL IF DEBT COULDNOT RECOVEREDFULLY IN CASE OF INSUFFICIENT ASSETS.PLS REFER ME SECTIONS ,ACT, ANY CASE LAW.I AM VERY AFRAID SIR.PLS HELP ME.WHETHER I HAVE TO SERVE JAIL .PLS CLEAR MY QUERY SIR AS SOON AS POOSIBLE.I KNOW THERE WAS AMENDMENT IN HINDU SUCCESSION ACT IN YEAR 2005 BUT MY CASE IS OF YEAR 2000 AND DEBTS ARE BUSINESS DEBT AND BUSINESS IS CLOSED.PLS HELP SOON SIR.
Anonymous
01 June 2011 at 17:22
We were appointed dealers to sell tractors in 1999.A letter was issued that we are authorised dealers for sales service and spares.supply resumed and we were alloted dealer code also.after six months supply suddenly stopped.Letters were issued to despatch tractors as stock was nill and advance money was sent to the suppliers.As no response was received and notice was sent to suppliers for losses incurred on manpower salary and rent etc. No response was received so a suit for recovery was filed which was decreed with interest.An appeal by suppliers in session court was also dismissed and RSA in high court was also dismissed in 2011.We have received the whole decretal amount with interest as per court order. My question is Can we file a suit to recover damages as no notice of termonation of dealership was issued.This point was taken into consideration at High court also.We were issued a certificate of dealership only and dealer code was alloted.No agreement was signed by the company with us. As we suffered heavy losses due to non supply of tractors and spareparts we were thrown out of business and our reputation and goodwill was damaged. Kindly suggest our course of action now
Gurinderjit
virendermahajan
01 June 2011 at 16:32
DearSir i want to know about liability of son in case of fatherpersonal debts, in case father dies to what extent son is liable debt is of year 2000.please tell in both cases whether debt is private or government and whether son personal asset remain liable.
And son rolein case of father debt come after only his death if there is no guarantee of son to father debt..
pls answer soon .
Anonymous
01 June 2011 at 12:12
Can a munsiff court give injunction on the elections of a social and religious organisation registered under the societies act after the election process has started...???? and if it can how such injunction can be vaccated????
plz reply soon............
i hav also come to know tat once an election process has started court cannot grant injunction...is it so???
If yes does this rule applies in case of a social and religious organisation having its own constitution and registered under the societies act????
ANY RULINGS FOR PROVING OUR POINT???
© 2026 LAWyersclubindia.com. Let us grow stronger by mutual exchange of knowledge.
actions agains son under pios obligation if son left with no asset
UNDER PIOS OBLIGATION IF DEBT IS OF YEAR 2000 AND SON IS LIABLE PERSONALLY AND ASSET OF SON ARE SOLD FOR FATHER DEBTS AND SON REMAIN WITH NO ASSET AND DEBT IS NOT FULLY SETOFF THEN WHAT ACTION ON SON FOR FATHER DEBT UNDER PIOS OBLIGATION