Registration in bmc records

dipali (Querist) 15 August 2013 This query is : Resolved
BMC land and building given to a private developer.
In this building Mr. X was having tenancy rights. MRS. Y purchased this tenancy right from Mr.X who is her brother in law, in 1985, before it was given to a private developer.
However it wasn't registered in Mrs. Y's name, in BMC records, due to shortage of funds. Now for last 2-3 years she is trying to get her name registered and has submitted various documents as and when asked by the BMC employee.
Recently they have raised new requirement i.e. they want consent of all those who had there names in the old ration card.
Question here is, tenancy right holder has given his consent, power of attorney, affidavit... whose name is there in the old ration card.
Are these documents not sufficient to get the name registered in BMC records?
Why consent of all other relatives in old ration card is required? And if required, under which ACT,SECTION, RULES...?

Follow Query

Report Abuse

ajay sethi (Expert) 15 August 2013
BMC wants to protect itself in case any claims are made by relatives of tenancy holder .if you can satisfy BMC requirements do so

Rajendra K Goyal (Expert) 15 August 2013
This is procedural protective measure taken by BMC, no harm in completing it.

dipali (Querist) 16 August 2013
Mrs.Y and her husband are in other dispute related to the inherited property ,with these relatives. So it seems difficult to get the consent from them.

If tenancy right holder is giving his consent, that he and all his family members will not have any claim in this property.

Then why the other relatives who are not owners of any right,require to give their consent. on what basis will they claim? ---ON THE BASIS OF OLD RATION CARD?

The new ration card is in Mrs. Y's name. The society has also given NOC, then why BMC requires it. I can understand if that tenancy right was HUF's property. But here it is Mr. X's i.e individual's property.

dipali (Querist) 16 August 2013
This query is Open

Rajendra K Goyal (Expert) 18 August 2013
If consent can not be obtained and BMC is not agreeing, order from court is another avenue.

ajay sethi (Expert) 18 August 2013
you waited for 25 years to transfer tenancy rights . although you had prucased property in 1985 you did not take any steps for 25 years . do you have any registered agreement with the seller ?

if Bmc is not agreeable move court for necessary releifs