Unfair academic penalty and delay in investigation
Sudhakar Ram Nawal Mishra
(Querist) 21 June 2025
This query is : Open
Hello Legal Experts,
I am seeking legal guidance regarding an incident during my postgraduate studies through a prestigious deemed-to-be private university in India. I believe I have been subjected to an unfair academic penalty due to procedural lapses, miscommunication, and delayed investigation, which has significantly disrupted my academic and professional life.
Incident Summary
During an open-book comprehensive exam, I was found wearing a smartwatch on my wrist. I immediately complied when asked to remove it and handed it over. The device was not used, and its presence was purely unintentional, caused by a rushed entry and the absence of any reminder or security check at the exam center.
Despite this, I was later informed that I was found guilty of using the smartwatch—an allegation I strongly contest. I submitted a detailed report on the same day and requested that CCTV footage be reviewed to confirm non-usage and lack of intent.
Key Concerns
Premature and Conflicting Communication: A university representative initially informed me that I had been debarred from registering for the next semester and that a formal notification had already been issued. This was later retracted, and I was told that no explicit notification is issued in such cases.
Missed Semester Due to Confusion: Due to this, I was not sent the registration link for Semester 2. My repeated emails remained unanswered. I missed the regular registration window and, due to course unavailability and time constraints, I had to opt out of the semester. When the actual formal notification arrived 64 days after the incident, it did not mention any debarment—only cancellation of the course.
Lack of Response and Closure: Despite multiple follow-ups, I received no clear answers regarding my grade, the investigation status, or the appeal process. The university has still not concluded the investigation or communicated a final resolution.
Lack of Transparency: When I escalated the matter through my employer (through whom I enrolled), I was told that the reports, procedures, and policies are confidential and cannot be shared.
Procedural Oversight: No reminder or security check was conducted before the exam, which contributed to my oversight. This was acknowledged by the university observer present at the exam center.
Questions for Legal Experts
Can a university delay an investigation to the extent that it causes a student to miss an entire semester?
Can I challenge the penalty on grounds of disproportionate punishment and denial of due process?
What legal remedies are available under Indian education law or consumer protection?
What are the UGC-mandated timelines for investigation and resolution of student grievances?
Can a student be denied access to investigation reports and decisions citing confidentiality?
