partition
sairamprasad
(Querist) 21 June 2011
This query is : Resolved
ancesstrol property was partitioned in 1956 .later one of the share holder write a will .2007.tohis faily members. is it valid or not?it is self aqired are anceetrelproperty?
M.Sheik Mohammed Ali
(Expert) 21 June 2011
yes its valid one, and this property is ancestral property no doubt.
Ravikant Soni
(Expert) 21 June 2011
The will is valid because his property is separate now and he can dispose it by way will.
Guest
(Expert) 21 June 2011
You said its ancesstrol property so its ancesstrol property and its totally valid.
R.Ramachandran
(Expert) 21 June 2011
I have been repeatedly requesting the querists to first state the complete facts, and then to ask their questions. Because, no question can be answered in law, without knowing the full facts.
In the above case, the minimum required facts are:
(i) Where is the property situated?
(ii) in which year he made that WILL?
(iii) whether the co-parcener who made a will was married at the time of making the will? If so, whether he had any children? If so whether sons or daughters?
(iv) Whether gave away the entire property or only a portion?
(v) whether his sons (if any at that time alive) consented to the same?
(vi) If the sons did not give their consent, whether challenged the action?
Quite possibly, after analysing the answers to the above point, the answer given by the above experts may turn out to be correct, but the above points need analysis, before coming to a definite conclusion.
Guest
(Expert) 21 June 2011
Yes,R.Ramachandranji you are right.
@sairamprasad
For getting best answer you have to ask question in clear and detail language.
sairamprasad
(Querist) 22 June 2011
Q no.1to Ans Andhrapredesh no2 2007no two daughters were married he had 6 daughters two sons.
sairamprasad
(Querist) 22 June 2011
Q no.1to Ans Andhrapredesh no2 2007no two daughters were married he had 6 daughters two sons.
R.Ramachandran
(Expert) 22 June 2011
In the above case, the minimum required facts are:
(i) Where is the property situated?
ANDHRA PRADESH
(ii) in which year he made that WILL? 2007
(iii) whether the co-parcener who made a will was married at the time of making the will? NO
If so, whether he had any children? (You say the person made the WILL in the year 2007. You also say that he was not married at that time. BUT, to the subsequent question YOUR ANSWER IS:
If so whether sons or daughters? HE HAD 6 DAUGHTERS AND 2 SONs. [when the person is not married in the year 2007, how can he have 6 daughters and 2 sons - and that too two daughters married?]
(iv) Whether gave away the entire property or only a portion? YOU HAVE NOT GIVEN THE ANSWER
(v) whether his sons (if any at that time alive) consented to the same? YOU HAVE NOT GIVEN ANSWER
(vi) If the sons did not give their consent, whether challenged the action? YOU HAVE NOT GIVEN ANY ANSWER.
