The trader's CA is right. What is paid at the check-post does not come back by adjustment.
1. This is GST, not VAT. Detention for an expired e-way bill is under s.129 CGST Act. Since 1.1.2022 the demand under s.129(1)(a) is a PENALTY equal to 200% of the tax on the goods; it is not "tax plus penalty". The supplier's tax on the invoice is paid separately through his GSTR-3B. So nothing is charged twice, and nothing is adjustable.
2. A s.129 penalty is not input tax credit and is not refundable unless the order is set aside in appeal.
3. Who bears it: keeping the e-way bill valid is the transporter's responsibility (Rule 138(10): validity can be extended up to 8 hours after expiry, and for exceptional circumstances such as natural calamity). Commercially the loss falls on whoever had the vehicle.
You have a good defence; do not pay tamely:
- Expiry by a few hours due to a storm, with invoice and goods matching, shows no intent to evade. Penalty under s.129 is then unsustainable; at most the general penalty under s.125 (up to Rs.25,000) applies: Asst. Commissioner (ST) v. Satyam Shivam Papers Pvt. Ltd. (SC, 12.01.2022, affirming Telangana HC); several High Courts have followed it.
- File a reply to the notice in Form GST MOV-07 within 7 days with weather/road-closure proof, GPS log and driver's statement.
- If the order (MOV-09) still goes against you: pay under protest to release the goods and appeal under s.107 within 3 months; pre-deposit is 25% of the penalty.