LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

gurinder singh (partner)     27 July 2022

Penalty under vat for expired e way bill

e way bill expired due to a sudden storm on hills as vehicle had to take shelter for few hours for storm to pass. VAT officer intercepted and asking to deposit tax and penalty. I asked trader to pay tax and I will pay penalty as he will get his tax refund, adjusted subsequently. Trader is not agreeing. He says his CA has advised him that he will not get his tax amount back. This seems illogical to me as govt will logically not take tax twice on same goods. Am I right or the trader is right?



 1 Replies

Aashok Kumar Sharma (Corporate Law Regulatory & Statutory Compliance Consultant)     20 November 2026

The trader's CA is right. What is paid at the check-post does not come back by adjustment.

1. This is GST, not VAT. Detention for an expired e-way bill is under s.129 CGST Act. Since 1.1.2022 the demand under s.129(1)(a) is a PENALTY equal to 200% of the tax on the goods; it is not "tax plus penalty". The supplier's tax on the invoice is paid separately through his GSTR-3B. So nothing is charged twice, and nothing is adjustable.
2. A s.129 penalty is not input tax credit and is not refundable unless the order is set aside in appeal.
3. Who bears it: keeping the e-way bill valid is the transporter's responsibility (Rule 138(10): validity can be extended up to 8 hours after expiry, and for exceptional circumstances such as natural calamity). Commercially the loss falls on whoever had the vehicle.

You have a good defence; do not pay tamely:
- Expiry by a few hours due to a storm, with invoice and goods matching, shows no intent to evade. Penalty under s.129 is then unsustainable; at most the general penalty under s.125 (up to Rs.25,000) applies: Asst. Commissioner (ST) v. Satyam Shivam Papers Pvt. Ltd. (SC, 12.01.2022, affirming Telangana HC); several High Courts have followed it.
- File a reply to the notice in Form GST MOV-07 within 7 days with weather/road-closure proof, GPS log and driver's statement.
- If the order (MOV-09) still goes against you: pay under protest to release the goods and appeal under s.107 within 3 months; pre-deposit is 25% of the penalty.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register