Upgrad LLM

good article on writing judgement


Good Article on How To Write Judgement?

 
 
THE WRITING OF JUDGMENTS
By The RT. Hon. Lord Macmilan P.C., K.C.V.O.
A Judgment may be defined as a reasoned pronouncement by a judge on a disputed legal question which has been argued before him. It is a literary composition, but a composition subject to certain conventions. It possesses its own characteristics and its own standards of merit. The art of composing judgments is not taught; it is acquired by practice and by study of the models provided in the innumerable volumes of the law reports in which are recorded the achievements of past masters of the art.
 
The style of any composition is necessarily dominated by its purpose. A work of imagination, such as a poem or a romance, aims at enthralling the reader by its appeal to the aesthetic and emotional side of his mind. A patent specification, to take an example from the opposite pole, makes no such appeal. It is a strictly business document and the merit of a business document is to be prosaically clear and unambiguous. A judgment pronounced on the bench, regarded as an intellectual product, stands in a class by itself. The judge speaks with authority and what he says should therefore, be spoken with befitting dignity. He should not affect grandiloquence but he should be impressive. The strength of a judgment lies in its reasoning and it should therefore be convincing. Clarity of exposition is always essential. Dignity, convincingness and clarity are exacting requirements but they are subservient to what, after all, is the main object of a judgment, which is not only to do but to seem to do justice. In addition to these cardinal qualities of a good judgment there are the attributes of style, elegance and happy phrasing which are its embellishments.
 
Reply   
 
Advocate

NICE.

 
Reply   
 


LEAVE A REPLY


    

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  



 

  Search Forum








×

Menu

CrPC MASTERCLASS!     |    x