LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Raj Kumar Makkad (Adv P & H High Court Chandigarh)     02 April 2012

Judge wins justice after 14 years

AHMEDABAD: It took a judge 14-longyears to obtain a court order on medical reimbursement after he had undergone treatment at a private hospital . Yet, his ordeal is not over yet, as the Gujarat high court has just asked the state government to consider his case in next three months.

Though not a final verdict about whether the government should reimburse the amount incurred on treatment at a private hospital, Justice J B Pardiwala has in unequivocal term lashed out at the rigid approach adopted by government officials in implementing rules and regulations.

A district judge at Sabarkantha, C T Punjabi was a senior civil judge at Patan in 1998, when he injured the toe of his left foot while starting the engine of his scooter. He obtained preliminary treatment in a public hospital, but the injury developed into gangrene. Since he needed urgent medical care, he was admitted in a private hospital at Vadodara and later a senior surgeon performed surgery and amputated part of his leg. The judge footed a bill of Rs 87,462, but it was not cleared since he obtained the treatment at a private hospital. He moved the HC and during pendency, the government cleared Rs 35,000 of the claim amount in 2002. However, it was not acceptable to the judge, who continued to claim full amount with 12% interest.

HC said that the government should have gracefully sanctioned the bill, and asked authorities to decide on it in three months. Criticizing the approach by officials in such cases, the HC observed, "All other things are subsequent and under the circumstances, the first priority is to save his life. It is not expected from an ailing person to run from pillar to post seeking permission or prior approval to get himself operated."
 
SOURCE: The Times of India


 1 Replies

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     02 April 2012

It is like one of my recent case, where the accused saw his wife burning in flame and also  the Orni kept in the room being burnt in the same room, but in stead of saving his wife he doused the fire on the Orni first, and after dousing the fire on the Orni he doused the fire on his wife.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register