LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Zahur Ahamed (Manager)     27 February 2013

Holding educational certificates by a software company

 

I am Zahur Ahamed, cousin brother of Sameer Ahmed. My Brother Sameer joined the software company on Nov 4th 2010  @ hyderabad. A bond was signed by him for his service with conditional of 1-Lac repayment if my bother leaves the company before 1 year from his time of employement.

He was continuously doing his services at the site. After some time, in June 2011, he left the site as he was sick. The company called him over the phone and asked him to join immediately. after 8 days he rejoined. 

He was not paid the salary for June 2011. He continued to work at the site. On July 29 he call the HR abt the payment of his salary. But he was asked to continue. 

Finaly he was not paid for July 2011 salary. He left the organization without completing 1 year tenue as per the agreement. The company is hold my brothers 10th and Eng Diploma Certificated.

 Then my brother has written a mail to cancel the agreement and would pay 30000/- for settlement. There was no reply. we called the HR 3-4 times and asked them to close the issue. We followed up again in Feb 2013 to return the certificates which the company hold. My bother visited in person to close this as it was nearly one and half year since the certificates are held up by the software company.

The HR now has asked to pay 1-Lac and take back the certificates.

My bother did not leave the organization on his own, as he was not paid the salary for 2 mothw he has to move out of the organization. In this case request to help how could i legaly approch to get back my brothers certificate.

Any help/advise is appreicated.

Regards

Zahur

 

 

 



 4 Replies

Kumar Doab (FIN)     28 February 2013

You have posted that:

--“ The company is hold my brothers 10th and Eng Diploma Certificated.’

“The HR now has asked to pay 1-Lac and take back the certificates.”

The act of the company to hold originals certificates is unfair and even unlawful.

This is property of the employee, result of many years of education and must for earning livelihood thru employment…… and company can not have any kind of lien on it.

Has the employee signed on any document or clause that he is willingly handing over his educational certificates for say……as a collateral, security, guarantee, or for verification etc…..

Did the company mention in any of the documents that employee shall have to produce the certificates for verification, or keep it with the company for……days/month/during employment?

Has the company issued any acknowledgment in writing?

The employer may ask to show originals for verification and may mark OSV on photocopies.

Employer may ask to produce copies which are self attested/notary attested/attested by a gazetted officer, and why it should retain the certificates.

And why it should keep the certificates as a coercive tactics and that too without issuing any acknowledgment.

Your lawyer may opine that this act of the employer may be termed as even criminal, and may advice to lodge a criminal complaint.

The courts and lawful authorities may not agree to such acts of employers.

Your lawyer may opine that these HR personnel can be charged by name, along with good offices of MD, Chairman, and appointing authority.

--“A bond was signed by him for his service with conditional of 1-Lac repayment if my bother leaves the company before 1 year from his time of employement.’

The employee may show this bond to a competent and experienced labor consultant/service lawyer and your lawyer may opine that this bond is legally unenforceable, inequitable, void, unconscionable……….

--‘After some time, in June 2011, he left the site as he was sick. The company called him over the phone and asked him to join immediately. after 8 days he rejoined. ‘

Did the employee submit leave application and got it approved and does he have the copies? Did he resume duties in writing and submit joining report?

--‘He was not paid the salary for June 2011. He continued to work at the site. On July 29 he call the HR abt the payment of his salary. But he was asked to continue. Finaly he was not paid for July 2011 salary. ‘

Did he submit any representation to god offices in writing? Does the company supply salary slips and did it supply for these months?

Did the company inform any reason for non disbursement of salary?

--“ My bother did not leave the organization on his own, as he was not paid the salary for 2 mothw he has to move out of the organization.’

Did the employee submit this as a reason for separation and thus declaring the employer unworthy of being employed with? Has the company accepted resignation and issued FNF statement showing amounts to be paid to employee and to be collected from employee?

Our hunch is that ( you have to check) company had decided to terminate ( while the employee proceeded on leave) /has terminated the services and has inserted the comments/documents in personnel file, or has declared the employee absconding/having abandoned the employment, leveled charges of misconduct and has squared the salary as per some stupid policy of the company.

The employee may request in writing under acknowledgment the good offices to allow him to let him examine his personnel file.

As the company communicates by a cost effective but effective mode of communication i.e. email it should have supplied the communications by email or other effective modes e.g. regd. Post.

--‘ In this case request to help how could i legaly approch to get back my brothers certificate.Any help/advise is appreicated.‘

Approach your lawyer as ap, with all docs and give inputs in person and spend some quality time with your lawyer.

You may go thru SE Act AP: IT companies are covered under SE Act.

You may go thru it.

SE Act AP (You may obtain the latest version from Dept. of Labor website of AP or buy from market):

2. Definitions:

(5) commercial establishment means…..

 (9) employer means a person having charge of or owning or having ultimate control over the affairs of an establishment and includes the Manager, agent or other person acting in the general management or control of an establishment;

(23) Wages means every remuneration, whether by way of salary, allowance, or otherwise expressed in terms of money or capable of being so expressed

34. Compulsory enrolment of employees to Insurance cum savings scheme :-

35. Responsibility for payment of wages :-

36. Fixation of wage period :-

37. Wages for overtime work :

38. Time of payment of wages :-

40. Deductions which may be made from wages :-

41. Fines :-

43. Deductions for damage or loss

47. Conditions for terminating the services of an employee, payment of service compensation for termination, retirement, resignation, disablement, etc., and payment of subsistence allowance for the period of suspension :-

48. Appointment of authority to hear and decide appeals arising out of termination of services :-

CHAPTER IX
Appointment Powers and Duties etc., of the authority to hear and decide claims relating to Wages etc., of employees in Establishments

50. Appointment of authority to hear and decide claims relating to wages etc.

51. Claims arising out of deductions from wages or delay in payment of wages etc., and penalty for malicious or vexatious claims

52. Single application in respect of claims from unpaid group

53. Appeal :-

54. Conditional attachment of property of employer

63. Penalty for obstructing Inspector etc

68. Maintenance of registers and records and display of notices, etc

72. Rights and privileges under other laws etc., not affected

Your lawyer may opine that you fall within the category of workman and ID can be invoked. Designation alone does not decide employee is a workman or not.

The company may yield to legal notice of your lawyer, demand notice by you thru your lawyer, during conciliation proceedings, Notice by Wages Inspector, Inspector under SE act…..


Attached File : 939104253 se act ap.doc downloaded: 206 times

Zahur Ahamed (Manager)     04 March 2013

Hi Kumar, 
Thanks for the complete and clear information on my case.
1. The Agreement  was signed by my brother within the office premises and no copy/duplicate copy has been issues to my brother. Currently we dont have the any copy of agreement.  There is no timeline fixed for the return of certificate.
 
2.  Yes we have the company issued letter/acknowledgement in written that they hold the certificates in orginal.
 
3. My brother has left the Location/Site without informing the employeer as he was not paid salary and mental harashment at work.
 
4. He did not put any resignation nor they have issured any termination letter.
 
5. This happened not only to my brother but to other 20+ people who joined the company. They went and loged a complain in the Labour office, but was not accepted by the dept as the company agreed to outside settlement.
 
6. For the leave he has sent a email request for the leave and also in the email he has sent an applogies for extendeing the leave peiod (4 days) without keeping the company informed.
 
7. Till date the employer has not terminated or issued any letter that my brother has absconds from the activites asigned to him.
 
The main concern is we dont have the agreement copy and the company is not provideing the copy of the agreeement. 
 
How do we proceed here. Raise a police complain first and talk to any legal person to close this issue, and get back the certificates.
 
Request to sugget before we consult any lawer on this.
 
Regards
Zahur

Kumar Doab (FIN)     04 March 2013

Appointment letter is also a contract and employer must have issued a copy to employee. Why the employee did not keep a copy or demanded a copy or declined to sign the agreement if no copy was being provided to him.

Employer should not create situation that employee has to flee.

The employee should not fearsome to that extent that he has to abscond.

Referring to the acknowledgment issued by employer the employee may write to company under acknowledgment, and ask to return the certificates on dated…..in person. If employee is unwilling to go to company employee may ask to return the certificates by redg. post only and may mention that a postage pre paid, self addressed envelope bearing postal stamps of say Rs….30/ is enclosed, mentioning employer has been holding on to the certificates and has not been returning and that certificates should not be soiled, spoiled, mutilated, damaged, and should be returned as crisp and as new they were while employer collected these.

If the employer does not accede employee may approach lawful authority including police.

If employee has sent the resignation he may produce a photocopy/copy from his record.

If employee was verbally told that his services were terminated, he may claim dues and documents.

If employee was asked to not to come to office he may state so.

Did your brother go to labor office with 20 other employees?

If no let your lawyers understand the reasons why? Kindly share full facts before your lawyer and do not conceal.

Would these 20 employees stand as witness to your brother?

O/o Labor commissioner can not refuse to accept the complaint. They can and they conduct conciliation proceedings, which is a written record.

The employee should have consulted before reaming on leave without extending the leave or before submitting written apology.

What are the fears and apprehensions of your brother and why?

What did company do to leave application submitted after joining the duty? Did it treat it as LWP?

Abscondment is misconduct and company may produce some stupid policy to square of his dues.

If company is not providing the copy of agreement and has inserted termination order then it would be without conducting any inquiry or supplying show cause notice……and actions of the company may be in violation of standing orders, SE Act, Law of the land, principle of natural justice……

It shall be appropriate to approach a lawyer and proceed under expert advice.

If you wish to avail the services of LCI lawyer you can conduct search at:

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/lawyers_search/#.UTSZJErxG8A

Related lawyers list is also featuring below the page.

Your near and dear ones can also guide you to a competent and experienced labor consultant/service lawyer.

 

 

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     01 June 2013

fully elaborated by Kumar Doab.

 

Submission or original certificates is submission to slavery and such practice is forbidden by constitution.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register