A consumer applied for a new electricity connection. Earlier, the electricity department prepared an estimated cost of ₹43,210/-, which was not communicated directly and came to light only through an online grievance (IGRS). Subsequently, in the following year, the department again revised the estimated cost to ₹98,000/-, without providing any clear justification. Relevant documents are available.
Later, as per the official electricity department portal, the estimated charges displayed were ₹1,122/-, which the consumer deposited online through the same portal. The payment receipt generated from the portal clearly mentions charges related to the release of electricity connection, and the payment was accepted by the department.
Despite payment and completion of all formalities, the electricity connection has not been released. The consumer made multiple complaints on the 1912 toll-free grievance number; however, every complaint was disposed of with a standard remark directing the consumer to “contact the subdivision office,” without resolving the issue.
Subsequently, the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO) contacted the consumer telephonically and stated that the amount paid through the portal is “not an estimated cost receipt,” and therefore the electricity connection cannot be released. This objection appears arbitrary, especially when the amount was generated, shown, and accepted through the official portal itself, and the purpose of payment is clearly mentioned therein.
Queries:
1. Whether the electricity department can legally deny release of a new electricity connection after generating and accepting payment through its official portal by claiming that it is not an estimated cost receipt?
2. Whether such refusal amounts to deficiency in service and violation of Section 43 of the Electricity Act, 2003?
3. What is the appropriate legal remedy in such a case — CGRF, Electricity Ombudsman, writ petition under Article 226, or consumer forum?
4. Whether repeated disposal of grievances without resolution is legally sustainable?
