LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Should Justice Dinakaran be impeached?

Page no : 2

DR.SANAT KUMAR DASH (Eye Specialist)     16 December 2009


dhiraj choudhary (n/a)     16 December 2009

he should be impeached in order to restore the faith of common man in judiciary, which is losing day by day


Why we have to Impeach Justice Dinakaran.

He is one of the good Citizen of india.

Can any one Impeach the P. Chidambaram he is also same as Justice Dinakaran what he did.


Suraj (student)     16 December 2009

Not only him, but all those judges who have a questionable character should be punished. This to instill faith in the minds of common man that our justice system is strong.

aman kumar (SUPERVISER)     16 December 2009

yes, he should be impeached my thanx to shree

Jaylal Jaisingh Bisukarma @ B. (LAWYER /ADVOCATE)     16 December 2009

when Justice V. Ramaswamy, was shows linency then dinakaran should also be spared on same footing and in toto to ramaswamy. let the judicary be immuned against politicals and execuitive body

Asokan (Lawyer)     17 December 2009

No, certainly need not. It is nothing but an attack on weaker sector. No body could say all the judiciary are wifes of Brutus or wife of Rama. Even our former CJI concented that the correption in judiciary. But the dominating group is using the allegation after keeping them as dump and deaf so far . The property whatever it may be purchased before his elivation used as sword againt him, only when he is said to be enter in to higher judiciary is highly partial and intentional.


Mukul Aggarwal (legal)     17 December 2009

yes he should be impeached

Arvind Singh Chauhan (advocate)     17 December 2009

Agree with Venkot Rao Sir.

Arvind Singh Chauhan (advocate)     17 December 2009

I agree with Venket Rao Sir.

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     17 December 2009

 Appointee of Congress. Go fly kite.

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     17 December 2009


If he is impeached, nothing will remain to lament about corruption in judiciary.


Dinakaran shall not only be impeached, but also should be made an accused under Prevention of Corruption Act, 'cause I remember having read a judgment of Madras HC dismissing a peon of a Government department for having taken Rs.10 as bribe. When such is the punishment of dismissal affirmed for accepting a bribe of a paltry sum that too the man accused of underwent ordeal of full trial, simply impeachment may not be enough. The prosecution shall file a Charge Sheet against him as an ordinary public servant and label him "an accused" and conduct criminal trial in full public view how he acquired so much wealth when he was from an ordinary family and didn't have roaring practice too before becoming a judge, since all are equal under our Indian Constitution.

Adinath@Avinash Patil (advocate)     18 December 2009


Adinath@Avinash Patil (advocate)     18 December 2009


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register