LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Guest (Guest)     11 August 2009

SC: Cant make rules for showing respect to Bapu

 The Supreme Court on Monday turned down a plea making it mandatory for people to show respect to Mahatma Gandhi. 



The decision came in response to a PIL against UP chief minister Mayawati’s alleged description of Gandhiji as a ‘natakbaaz’ (a hypocrite or gimmicky). 



The petitioners — advocate Ravi Kant and Sukumar — had cited Gandhiji’s contributions to argue that he deserved respect from every citizen. A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India K G Balakrishnan and Justice B S Chauhan patiently heard the petitioners, but declined to lay down a code enjoining upon citizens to show respect to Gandhiji. 



“We totally agree with you on what you said on Gandhiji. But, we are not here to frame or issue guidelines to citizens for showing respect to Mahatma Gandhi. We cannot entertain such PILs,” the Bench said. 

The petitioners had sought the court’s intervention for the framing of guidelines, citing the absence of a law to prosecute anyone showing disrespect to the Father of the Nation. 



The Bench dismissed the PIL even before the petitioners could elaborate on the alleged derogatory remarks of Mayawati against Mahatma Gandhi and their plea for framing of suitable guidelines for showing respect to the Father of the Nation. 



Citing media reports, the petitioners had accused Mayawati of showing disrespect to Mahatma Gandhi by allegedly describing him as a ‘natakbaaz’ at a congregation of BSP leaders and members last month. 

The petitioners also criticised her remarks justifying the state government’s decision to install her own statues and those of dalit leaders on the ground that the money spent on these was miniscule compared to the amount spent on ‘samadhis’ at Rajghat.



 1 Replies

Kiran Kumar (Lawyer)     11 August 2009

i think SC is right.

 

we can not force anyone to pay respect to some particular individual....every one has right to freedom of speech and expression (Art 19)

 

and we can not stop criticism either....read Preamble and the aforesaid article.

 

and What Mayawati claims about herself or for Dalit leaders is really unfortunate.....statutes do not build leaders in fact.

 

she cant force herself upon people of India....may it be any case the Indians shall rise to vote for those who think of development and not just of religion based and caste based politics.

1 Like

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register