Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

M. Kannan (Consultant)     30 November 2010

Right of property to children from 2nd wife

Mr. X married Y in the year 1971. His wife Y expired after delivering 3 children-one male and 2 females. After the death of Ist wife Y, Mr X married another girl Z. Mrs. Z delivered 2 female children. During that time, Mr. X applied for Society sites in the name of Z. All the payment receipts, correspondence and everything is in the name of Z only. No where Mr. X name is there in the record. Mr. X expired in the year 1985. All the Ist wife children and 2nd wife children got married. Mrs. Z is alive now. Now the allotment of sites going to happen in January 2011. Mrs. Z will get the allotment in her name. Now my question is, whether the children of Ist wife and 2nd wife eligible for this property or only Mrs. Z and her own 2 female children can enjoy the property. What about the right over the property for Ist wife children now? When Mr  X applied for site, he used his own earned money only. At that time, Z was the house wife only.



Learning

 6 Replies

Suchitra. S (Advocate)     30 November 2010

No rights for the children of  first wife over the property as the property is bought from the self earned money.

ramaraju ramaiah (Tax Consultants Advocates)     30 November 2010

Mr.Kannan

in your question all the payments were made in the name of the Z only by MrX. You have not

mentioned in your question source of income of MrX to make payment to society on behalf of his second wife Z,

if Mr. X is payment made from the source of HUF income then the second wife childers also entitled to get shares of the deceased person. Moreover It is under stook that Z is only house wife. she is depent on her husband. You must clarifi yourself that source of income of the deceased. And also clarifie is there any will executed belongs the society property

Viswanath (Student)     01 December 2010

Since it is said that the paymnets towards the site is out of the earnings of the husband alone and if the same can be proved to the satisfaction of the court then all the children including the widow form class one legal heirs and they may have equal share in the property.

1 Like

M. Kannan (Consultant)     01 December 2010

Mr. X is a carpenter by profession. He used his own self earned income to apply for the site in the name of Mrs. Z. Mrs. Z at that time was house wife only.This is not HUF income. Can the children of Ist wife claim their share of the property?. Mr. X has not left any Will as such.

Hemant Agarwal (ha21@rediffmail.com Mumbai : 9820174108)     02 December 2010

Originally posted by :Viswanath
"
Since it is said that the paymnets towards the site is out of the earnings of the husband alone and if the same can be proved to the satisfaction of the court then all the children including the widow form class one legal heirs and they may have equal share in the property.

"

 

1.  Opinion of Mr. Viswanath, is perfect and legally valid enough for  "ALL"  children to have equal rights over their biologial father's property.

 

2.  By law, the legal owner is the person who has paid for the property, out of his own personal owned and earned funds.  Property can be bought in anybodys name,  "for convience purposes"  (like authorising a POA holder to hold property in POA holders name  .OR.  in a nominee's name or whatever).    However this does not give rights & ownership title of the property to the proxy property holder.

OF COURSE,  subject to that the father (husband) should not have made a Gift Deed / Release deed / Reliquinshmentt deed in the mother (2nd wife's favour), in the life time of the father.

 

3.  However the above will have to be adjudicated with documentary evidence (like payment debited from father's account) in the court, to have an absolute rights, by  "ALL" the childrens on the father's property.

 

Conclusively, ALL the childrens (1st wife's children and 2nd wife's children)  have EQUAL rights of the property, purchased by their father with his own private funds, in the name of his 2nd wife.

 

Keep Smiling .... Hemant Agarwal

Pritam Saini, Advocate (Advocate)     03 December 2010

property purchase by x in the name of z from own poceket is a benami property and as per prohibtion of benami transtion act  there is presumtion if wife had no income then proprty deem x therefore ist class hear of x are entittled in eqal share


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register