cpc

gift deed without signature of major son

PARTNER

Our grandfather executed a gift deed about 35 years ago gifting 2 acres of agricultural land to his adopted daughter. This is out 10 acres piece and not subdivided. The deed was registered. However, the deed was signed only by him and not by my father. Later we paid money for one acre and taken back one acre. The remaining one acre was sold off by her about 30 years ago. She was never in possession of this land and we have been farming this land.

When we paid money and taken back the land we did not get any documentation. She later somehow managed to get pattadar passbook for this land. She was never in possession. Now she is approaching revenue authorities asking for subdivision and trying to get possession after around 30 years. She has been silent all these years.  We sold this one acre and given possession to somone else who also obtained passbook. Is there any remedy or course available to us to prevent her and protect our one acre which was sold out to third party.

 
Reply   
 
subregistrar/supdt.(retired)

Is the land gifted by your grandfather to his adopted daughter self-acquired or ancestral?  If ancestral, your father has also right over the property and if it is self-acquired then it is his will and no one can claim it.  Your aunt is selling her land and you have no right to prevent her as it is her own property.

 
Reply   
 


PARTNER

This is an ancestral property.

If my father has a right for share as it is ancestral, is the gift deed void and defective? Or does it mean that only one acre has been transferred effectively? Or now my father should approach civil court seeking to make gift deed ineffective? thanks.

 

 
Reply   
 
Retired employee.

The presumption is that the litigation/conflict is on one acre alone, which was purchased back from your paternal aunt as the 30ac land was already gifted by your GF to PA.  Be brief and focus on the vital issue.  If the one-acre was sold by you and given possession to someone long back, let the buyer who is in possession fight it out and support his case depending on such period after sale. as he must have mutated the property and obtained pass book in his name long back.

 
Reply   
 
Advocate

How is that the property is ancestral? Moreover, the facts posted suggests that much antagonism between the brother and the ( adopted) sister . It appears that the brother wants to ensure that the sister gets no parental property, by hook or crook. 

 
Reply   
 
PARTNER

There are few facts here. 

1.The land of 2 acres given to her by registered gift deed is out of a big piece of 10 acres which was not sub-divided. 

2. The gift deed was signed by only grandfather when there is a major son and from a joint family.

3. Grand father got this property from his father and ancestral.

4. She sold away one acre and never claimed the remaining acre. She does not know where the land is. She never stepped or cultivated this land. We have been in possession and enjoyment. This happened for the reason that she has taken money for this land and gave up the land. This happened about 30 years ago. 

5. She got passbook, it appears, without we knowing about it. It is a news for us now receiving an enquiry notice from MRO.

6. Unfortunately it is quite common in some parts of India giving gift and buying it back. For so many reasons some of these lands not taken back by registered documents. Though it is not a good way of doing things but this is the reality which in many instances leads to legal disputes.

 

 
Reply   
 

if it is an ancestral property the gift may not be binding on son. Check with a good lawyer.

 
Reply   
 
Advocate

Just because the grandfather got it from his father need not make it ancestral. Facts posted suggest there had been a division of property by metes and bounds, and probably, execution of a partition or settlement deed.

 
Reply   
 
PARTNER

I found that in case of ancestral property the person whoever looks after the property stands in the same footing as custodian or trustee. He manages the property for the benefit of the members or coparceners. He can not gift away a piece of property without consulting the members as the property is still belonging to all members as a unit until it is divided into shares. Even if he gifts by way of a registered gift deed it is not binding on the other members. He is gifting something which does not belong to him. The donee would not get any right in the property. At the maximum what the donee may get is  the portion/share of  property if it is split on the day of gifting.

Here is a case that went through all the tiers of judiciary from lower court to Supreme court confirming a similar situation.

https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1678680/

 

 

 
Reply   
 
Advocate

The facts of this and thee  judgment thereto, has no relevance to the facts posted.

 
Reply   
 

LEAVE A REPLY


    

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


 

  Search Forum








×

Menu

IPC Grand Course     |    x