cpc

can gift deed - be void


A civil case has been initiated.

The material facts are as follows ;

Without knowing other coparceners, my Uncle has taken my Grandmother who is unsound mind paralyzed and got registered a Gift Deed a share of 1/4 of the property.

Now my father and other coparcener wants the property to be shared equally distributed to all the brothers of the family.

The transaction of gift deed has happened when she was alive and now my uncle has filed a case of declaration after her death.

Our prayer is that the property is not self acquired by my grandmother, and can we cancel the Gift Deed.
 
Reply   
 
Lawyer

Gift deed executed and registered is irrevocable.

After death of donor it can not be cancelled.

 
Reply   
 


Retired employee.

The facts stated are not convincing.  As per my understanding Uncle has given to your GM a gift, and she is no more now.  Your uncle as she is no more has filed a declaration suit for cancellation of gift deed.   Your father wanted that as it is your GM property already, self-acquired through gift deed it should be distributed to legal heirs of your aunt.  When your uncle has already filed a declaration suit, you can only prevail for the continuation of the gift .  Where is the issue of unsound mind? Who are her legal heirs and how the property was enjoyed by her since the date of the gift.  Those who looked after your GM has extracted any will from her ?


Total likes : 2 times

 
Reply   
 

My Grandmother who is 80 Years old paralyzed, so in the due course what my uncle did is took my Grandmother without knowing other legal heirs and made a part of Shops of the property as a Gift Deed on to his name.
 
Reply   
 
Retired employee.

Your uncle has filed a declaration suit, argue before the court and establish will was a fraud or obtained through undue influence.   In fact, your uncle has made your job easy, argue and get that gift deed canceled by providing all those medical reports or witnesses statements etc.,

 
Reply   
 

If the property is not self acquired then it cannot be gifted to only person and every coparcener has a share over it.

 
Reply   
 
Advocate

Is the gift deed registered? Now that the uncle has filed the suit for declaration onus rests within him in proving deed. Your father can only deny the averment of gift. As the property belonged to the grandmother, it was not ancestral. She was competent to make the gift. 

 
Reply   
 

LEAVE A REPLY


    

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


 

  Search Forum








×

  LAWyersclubindia Menu

Complete Hindu Laws Course     |    x