Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Parveen Kr. Aggarwal (Advocate)     14 January 2010

Withdrawl of suit

What is the effect when a court permits a plaintiff to withdraw suit with liberty to file fresh suit on the same cause of action?

 

Is the plaintiff put at the same position from where he started the suit or his position is altered in any manner?

 

Is there any case law on the point that in such case the plaintiff shall be at the same position as he had not instituted any suit?



Learning

 5 Replies

N RAMESH. (Advocate Chennai. Formerly Civil Judge. Mobile.09444261613)     15 January 2010

What is the effect when a court permits a plaintiff to withdraw suit with liberty to file fresh suit on the same cause of action?

 The plaintiff gets privilage to institute another suit on the same cause of action.

Is the plaintiff put at the same position from where he started the suit or his position is altered in any manner?

it can not be said so. He is only given previlage to file another suit and no other benefit can be derived from the permission.

Ajay kumar singh (Advocate)     15 January 2010

Mr. N. Ramesh is absolutely correct.

R.K.SUNDERRAJ (LAWYER HUBLI,KARNATAKA)     16 January 2010

I agree with N.Ramesh sir.

Gulshan Tanwar (Advocate)     16 January 2010

Order 23 Rule 1 to 4, CPC deals with such situation;  A plaintiff can withdraw a suit as a matter of right without the permission of the court. In such a case he shall be precluded from suing again on the same cause of action. He cannot withdraw a suit reserving to himself such a right to bring a fresh suit. Even if the plaintiff fails to make out his case on the merits of the application for withdrawal, if, in law, the plaintiff is entitled to withdraw, the plaintiff cannot be prevented from making such an application. A suit can be withdrawn in part with liberty to sue again in respect of it. But the whole suit cannot be withdrawn with liberty to sue again in respect of part only. When only part of suit is withdrawn, the remaining part must be proceeded with and if not, it must be dismissed.

Thus, once a suit is withdrawn by the plaintiff, it automatically follows that whatever benefits that were initially gained by the plaintiff by way of interim orders of the court, would naturally vanish and cease to exist. Except 1) to pay such costs as the court may award; and 2) plaintiff is precluded from instituting any fresh suit in respect of that subject-matter under Rule 1(3),

the right of the plaintiff to withdraw from a suit is absolute and unqualified.

Gulshan Tanwar (Advocate)     16 January 2010

M Kishore Kumar Vs. Mohd. Akbar Siddiqui, AIR 1994 NOC 194: (1993) 3 An LT 429


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register