Shree. ( Advocate.) 26 April 2008
JAGADEESH GOVIND (ADVOCATE) 26 April 2008
Prakash Yedhula (Lawyer) 26 April 2008
Shree. ( Advocate.) 26 April 2008
Kuljit Pal Singh (Legal Professional) 26 April 2008
Kiran Kumar (Lawyer) 27 April 2008
Ajay kumar singh (Advocate) 27 April 2008
Kanhaiya Singh (Advocate) 28 April 2008
Kuljit Pal Singh (Legal Professional) 29 April 2008
Ravishankar (Assistant) 06 May 2009
I have read the section of attempt to suicide, but if the attempt is successful then what action does the law take, I think a case will be filed against the deceased, can anyone tell me that if attempt is successful then would the person commiting suicide be treated as criminal if yes then what punishment does he deserve because he is already dead.
Meenakshi (Lawyer) 05 November 2009
Everything is fair which is done in the interest of good and well being...What has the society got to lose? This wil only refrain people from not commiting sucide in fear of being punished....Death seems very easy to a sucidal patient just like the sucide bombers so punishment by law may make some sense and fil in some fear.....Actually it should depend on the case if its a case of some person fed up of life etc then some reformaTIVE theory to be applied. if not then yes to be punished which sets an example thus disbling people scaring them not to comit suicide....If nobody law cares about good lives of people...
Gaurav Arora (Advocate) 05 November 2009
I also agree with the above said suggestions given by the respected members that there should be an organisation which specifically deals with such types of case so as to reform the persons who have attempted to commit suicide.....because mere punishing a person for such a sin is not the solution....
Bhaskaradeepak (SOFT. ENGG.) 06 November 2009
Yes i agree but if a person used suicide plights to make other to agree tos omething or meant to disturb,it should be punished badly.I myself was a victim, a girl from up made me fall in love initally by saying she was going to commit suicide since she can't leave as she likes and if i want her to leave, should be with her.After 10 months long realtion and some physical involvement,i found she was a cheat,when i asked her about that she abused me badly and my family so i too repeated the same.When i agai seeked for explanantion,she again made me depressed by stating she attempted suicide.Indeed made a conversation stating she was dying that time she took some pills and cutted off the line as she was faining.
That affected me drastically,i was so mcuh depressed for a week.Indeed contacted he friend to make sure she is allright.As i afraid anyting can hapen, i blogged everything happened between us.Contacted her fiance told him she is having such a idea,he too called and asked me to forward a suicide message she sent,i denied his request.
SO far i suffered to much mental depression.I was afraid of her,even she states i am the reason for her marriage proposal getting dropped and she will take revenge for that.I contacted her family members too,they were not ready to respond.Actually i fond out the moble number she used was taken under her previous BF proof,now she stoped using the number.
As law always gives advantage to the one who approaches firs,what should i do now? she herself is a law student and one of her realtive is a judge too.
Kamal Grover (Advocate High Court Chandigarh M:09814110005 email:firstname.lastname@example.org) 06 November 2009
As per my view it may be removed.