Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

19cccccca (Teacher)     31 May 2014

Divorce filed by husband-as a defense for caw & dv complaint

Hi

Had filed complaint against husband in CAW for commiting cruelty, demanding dowry, domestic violence  and for forcing to divorce me. Then after a month filed a petition under DV act, 2005. Both at initial stages. Husband and in-laws very adamant regarding any reconciloiation or mutual settlement. Not ready to negotiate on any terms. All dowry articles/streedhan in their possession. They wanted mutual divorce without having to pay a single rupee towards alimony. It was not acceptable to us as 30-40 lakhs of rupees were spent on marriage. Marriage hardly 1 and 1/2 year old. Now, he has filed divorce on false grounds of cruelty which is nothing but a defense from their side in response to complaints of cruelty against them as highlighted in Caw complaint and DV petition....

Please help me know.. what options do i have ? Considering the facts that

# I am working

# In fist instance, I dont want divorce. I want reconciliation.

# IO at CAW cell seems influenced/bribed by them

# Grounds of divorce are totally false

 # If it has to end in a divorce, I want my share of alimony... had spent heavily on marriage and afterwards also... no bank balance now

Please suggest me the right way to proceed... ??

 

Regards



Learning

 7 Replies

great india (manager)     31 May 2014

If you wanted reconciliation why went to CAW.....? And which idiot asked you to file DV. You arr threatening them and expecting reconciliation....??? If patch up not fructifying..... Go for contesting his case and ask for return of streedhan and permanent alimony. How....... The one who asjed you to go to CAW can guide. Why everybody is running to criminal courts instead of civil remedies of reconciliation by filing sec.9 hma....???? Gud luk

(Guest)

Following are the facts which you will be facing in the coming days.  Dont panic.

Originally posted by : 19cccccca


Hi

Had filed complaint against husband in CAW for commiting cruelty, demanding dowry, domestic violence  and for forcing to divorce me. Then after a month filed a petition under DV act, 2005. Both at initial stages. Husband and in-laws very adamant regarding any reconciloiation or mutual settlement. Not ready to negotiate on any terms. All dowry articles/streedhan in their possession. They wanted mutual divorce without having to pay a single rupee towards alimony. It was not acceptable to us as 30-40 lakhs of rupees were spent on marriage. Marriage hardly 1 and 1/2 year old. Now, he has filed divorce on false grounds of cruelty which is nothing but a defense from their side in response to complaints of cruelty against them as highlighted in Caw complaint and DV petition....

Please help me know.. what options do i have ? Considering the facts that

# I am working

Hence you wont get 1 rupee also as maintenance.

# In fist instance, I dont want divorce. I want reconciliation.

Kiss your marriage goodbye, thats is the only option left for you.  Do you think your husband will get terrrorised and fall to your feet that you filed complaint, DV act case?  Answer is a big NO.  He wont budge a inch.  After all the insults you have made by filing police  complaint in CAW cell, they ie your husband and in-laws will never accept you.  even if they do out of compulsion or force of law, you will have a tough time for the rest of your life.  All in all your marriage is over the moment you stepped into police station.

# IO at CAW cell seems influenced/bribed by them

Whatever.

# Grounds of divorce are totally false

You filing complaint in CAW cell, filing false DV act case itself are enough to get your husband divorce.  Just be prepared to roam to courts for next 7-8 years along with your parents [if they accompany you to court halls whenever there is date].   Dont worry about grounds for divorce.  Its mainly now about the mental cruelty which has been meted out by you to your husband by filing police complaint, and DV case.

 # If it has to end in a divorce, I want my share of alimony... had spent heavily on marriage and afterwards also... no bank balance now

All this had to be thought before you spent that money on marriage.  Its worse than gambling.  99.99% marriage wont work these days.  So you had to keep expeneses to a minimum.  Now running behind getting back money spent on marriage would be a waste of time.  Instead of all this, ask for some settlement money which is decent, dont bargain too much for money, like that you do, they will refuse and only option will be to roam to court and lose precious years and money on litigation expenses.



Agree for mutual consent divorce aka MCD, get all the appropriate VAT bills for the articles of dowry, stridhan to claim them back.  Without original VAT bills, no claims will be entertained by the court, dont ever think of providing false bills, you might land up in jail.  


Worst case scenario:  If your husband wants to trouble you, they can file a case against you for giving dowry and also your parentage and you can end up behind bars ie jail for a very long time.  So just be careful.




Please suggest me the right way to proceed... ??

Go with neutral approach.  Approach with parents for talks, convince them that you will withdraw all cases and that you just want divorce and your stridhan articles back.  Ask money back only if you want, but I see no point in asking money spent on marriage, people came ate, did merry and shat in commode, for that you should not ask back money spent on food, marriage hall etc.  It simply did not work, your marriage.  Keep the above things in mind and do not make it too complicated, mostly you have complicated your own life now and have become a pain in the arse for your parentage [ask them and they will confess this with you].


Good luck

Any other advice you need, you can get in touch with me on phone.  Check PM.  

Regards

1 Like

19cccccca (Teacher)     31 May 2014

Will I get right to residence under DV act ? I have been thrown out of my matrimonial home. That is why I had to enter CAW cell. Right now residing with parents but real paucity of space

Gautam Kapoor (IT professional Studying Law)     31 May 2014

utter contempt of free legal advice.

fighting back (exec)     31 May 2014

Rightly advised by helping hand, nothing more to add, however it is interesting to note that a person who spends 40 lakhs on marriage has.a paucity of space to accommodate their daughter, sorry to say but u are trying to be shrewd, but u cant outwit the legal experts in this forum

Gautam Kapoor (IT professional Studying Law)     31 May 2014

Pls do not provide points which can be further improvished/corrected/tuned and furthered/fructified as a extortion tool against her hapless victim.In you good endeavour to bring home the point you are involuntarily sharpening her knives.


(Guest)
Originally posted by : 19cccccca
Will I get right to residence under DV act ? I have been thrown out of my matrimonial home. That is why I had to enter CAW cell. Right now residing with parents but real paucity of space

Yes, u/s 23 you can get right to residence, provided your in-laws property is ancestral one.  If it is self earned property, you cannot even step your toe inside their property.  They can rightfully kick you out by getting a civil injunction.


If it is ancestral property, you can go and stay there provided if your husband is living there, if your husband is not living there, again your in-laws can easily show you the door and you will be again on streets or you can take in government rest house for which you will have to pay 100 rs rent per day.

 

The way I see it, you did all this drama and now you are repenting and want to somehow get back into the in-laws house by hook or crook.  But you should have thought about all such consequences before giving written complaint against husband and in-laws in CAW cell and before signing on green sheet in court for DV case.

 

I really pity you, you just destroyed your life with your own hands.  Now forget lawyers, even God cant help you.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Related Threads


Loading