LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Ravi   20 June 2016

Service matter with govt organisation

I will briefly explain u my requirements. 

A Govt Organisation called (Dept of Health & Family welfare) applications for the post of accountant in sept 2008. Conducted exams on 01.03.2009 Results were announced on 28.03.2009
Subsequently appointment letters issued on 29.03.2009. Last date to report to duty was on 29.04.2009.

Before we could join to the post. Govt Office issued stay letter on 06.04.2009 "stating that your appointment is stayed until further orders".
Again They issued one more letter dated 13.04.2009. "Stating that entire procudure of appointment of accountant has been cancelled". This all happened before the due date to report to duty.

Than applicants filled 3 different cases before CAT requesting to quash the letters issued on 06.04.2009 n 13.04.2009. CAT issued orders in our favour of applicants on Dec 2011. In high court also case was in applicants favour on dec 2013. In supreme court also order was in our favour. 

Now Applicants have joined the duty without getting back the service and pay.

Please provide any court order regarding directing the Govt organisation to provide the service from retrospective date n pay.


 9 Replies


Mr. Ravi,


You can claim seniority from the date of selection, but no pay for the period not worked for the organization. But for that also, you may have to obtain Court order with a separate petition, if no relief was sought in your original application with CAT and not granted for seniority with retrospective effect. The department was bound to comply only with specific order passed by the CAT/HC/SC, and cannot be compelled to allow any more facility beyond the scope of the Court Order.




Ravi   20 June 2016



To claim the service from retrospective, we need a judgement copy of the similar case, If you have could you please provide the same.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     20 June 2016

Your counsel can provide if required.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     20 June 2016

Repeated Query:

compliance   21 June 2016

Thanks for telling this.

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     21 June 2016

Agreed with Mr Dhingra


Mr. Ravi,


Your request is quite amazing when you ask free service providers to waste their precious time for making search and to provide copies of judgments to serve your own paid lawyer. Your own hired lawyer would necessarily be required to do his own homework, not others.





Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     24 June 2016

Agreed with Mr Dhingra.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     24 June 2016

Your counsel shall provide, if required!


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Post a Suggestion for LCI Team
Post a Legal Query