Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Krishnan Ana (Government)     10 September 2012

Request for advise

Private Message Subject : Advise on Family matters (Divorce) Message : My friend got married about 3 years back. The boy and the girl lived with the Boys parents for about 08 months. Thereafter she went back to her parents place for delivery. Post delivery she returned back (approximately after 07 months) with the 03 month old child (Boy). Then she stayed at home with her husband for about 08 months and she went back home saying that they have some function at their place. Thereafter she never returned back for the next 10 months. From her house she along with her parents, one of her sister and her husband started complaining that the Boy was not looking after well and she did not have any freedom etc. She had even told lot of personal things to her brother in law which in normal circumstances no girl would have told to any body except her mother/sister etc. She was hinting that they need to move to a separate house that is nearby the girls brother in laws place and she hinted that he would even get the boy some job (Her husband is the only boy). When she was carrying, the Boys parents were away to US for a few months and during this time, she never use to do anything in the house, not look after her husband and was caught with some boy in terrace one day also. All the tenants living were aware of all this and the terrace was locked up thereafter. Not withstanding all this, we had at various levels tried our best to get her back so that both of them can lead a good life. After all the cajoling and request for her to come back, finally after 10 months she came back. After coming home as she did not have any periods for 02 months, the Boys mother forced her and took her to the hospital. The preliminary medical examination revealed that she was carrying a child which is more than 3 months old. Later the detailed scan indicated that the child was 24 weeks. When inquired she did not answer anything. This clearly proves that the child she is carrying is not from her husband as she was away from him for the last 10 months. Immediately, her parents were informed and requested to take her to their home. As soon as they (Girls side parents and both her brother in laws) arrived there tried to pacify and tell that the medical examination may not be correct and we must wait for another 03 months. If she does not deliver that means the report is not correct and the Boys side were just blaming them for nothing. However the boys side were not convinced with all these things and asked her to give it in writing all that what has happened and she without any hesitation has penned it down saying that she is not interested in living with her husband and she is ready for mutual separation. Further she has written that she is carrying all the items what was brought by her during the marriage and does not want any monetary compensation. In the meanwhile, her parents and brother in laws who had come went to the police station and lodged a complaint saying that their daughter was being harassed. The boys side were called by the police and in the station both were inquired and the police were also convinced that she has cheated. Finally at the police station, her parents were also asked to sign on the letter what their daughter has written and they have gone to their place. The Boy was also asked by the police if he wants to live with this girl and he also refused and agreed for a mutual separation. This incident has happened about 20 days before. Can you kindly advise us on the following? (a) At what stage (right now or after few months) can we file a case requesting for Divorce? (b) For what reasons can I file the Divorce? (Adultery/Mutual separation or mutual separation because of Adultery) (c) How long can we wait before filing this case? (d) How much time will it take to obtain the divorce? (e) Do we need to pay any compensation from the boys side? If so for what? How much will it be? (Boy earns about 7000/- per month and his parents do not have any assets or any income. The daughters help them financially when required). (f) Can we wait for the Girl to initiate anything legally and if they do not approach the court what can be done by us in this case? Regards Thank you A Krishnan Sent to : Admin on 02 September 2012



Learning

 2 Replies

Tajobsindia (Senior Partner )     11 September 2012

(a) At what stage (right now or after few months) can we file a case requesting for Divorce?
Take:
In my opinion if all these discoveries are realistically really unbearable for the boy and followed by his family side then now is a good time to file and pray for relief of divorce.

(b) For what reasons can I file the Divorce? (Adultery/Mutual separation or mutual separation because of Adultery)
Take: Adultery in marriage as “ground” for cruelty and thus praying for divorce.

(c) How long can we wait before filing this case?
Take: See my take on your que. 'A'.

(d) How much time will it take to obtain the divorce?
Take: Depends on work load of court read with the girl’s side mood as and when they may prefer to contest and or give – in and agree for divorce without contesting the same. Say anywhere around 3 years.

(e) Do we need to pay any compensation from the boys side? If so for what? How much will it be? (Boy earns about 7000/- per month and his parents do not have any assets or any income.
Take: Your side need not have to pay final alimony if your side is able to prove adultery in marriage the ground with which you are advised to launch divorce. However, during the pendency of divorce under HMA she may file prime facie affidavit and seek maint. if she is hand to mouth and based on boy’s side proved income say anywhere between 500 – 1200 she may manage to get during the pendency of the divorce suit that also she has to press for the same very hard given to understand colly. facts of yoru brief. Post proving and if court comes to opinion that adultery proved then no alimony or pmt. Maint. in proved cases of adultery in marriage is given.

The daughters help them financially when required).
Take: From where she helps them? As no smell of her ‘income’ capacity mentione din your brief or is it that I am missing something here ;-)

(f) Can we wait for the Girl to initiate anything legally and if they do not approach the court what can be done by us in this case?
Take: When the wind sails in your direction which the facts hints so this is right time before matter goes to cold storage. First mover has always special advantage in family law litigation matters :-) 

1 Like

Krishnan Ana (Government)     11 September 2012

Dear Sir/maa'm

Thanks a lot for the reply.

Regarding 'daughters supporting their parents, I had written with respect to the boys father' and this has nothing to do with the girl side.

Regatrds

Thanks a ton.

Krishnan


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register