difference in oral evidence in two different courts

hello experts, request your kind guidance and advise on my situation.

in her own RCR case, wife accepted in cross examination of being Bcom and MCom, of having worked earlier when she was in husbands home, and she left home because husband deserted her, this was in cross examination of her in her own RCR case. she had also filed 125 case, in that case, she had mentioned that she had not worked and has never mentioned anything about her qualification in her 125 petition. i have defeated her in her own RCR case. 

my question is: if she contradicts her own admissions in RCR, in her 125 case, what will happen?

she admits something in one case, and denies something in the other case, which statement will the judge consider in the 125 case?, because she herself admits something in RCR, and denies those same questions in 125 case? 

please advise. 


Hi gansham you need to get salary slip from her 'company where she work and show in court and you lawyer also make objection on it if she accept it in cross examination 

if she work than not eligible for maintaince in sec 125 



Social Studies Reader/Worker

Repeated query already answered.


There are ways to handle this situtation . By the way why did your lawyer not submit the certified copy of the cross examination  held in the RCR case for the 125 case . During the cross examination for the 125 case your lawyer could have asked this question showing the certified copy of the RCR case stating that she has admitted that she is a BCOM , MCOM and was earning . Since cross examination is carried out under oath .if she denies that than  the judge would understand that she is lying in the 125 case .

Retd Sr Director Govt of India/ Advocate

Agreed with staley.


Her income through salary and other sources if proved, her maintenance case can be got dismissed.




Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


  Search Forum


  LAWyersclubindia Menu

IPC Grand Course     |    x