Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

VIJAYAKUMAR (Asst.Manager Lega)     20 October 2011

Punishment for injured workmen for violating safety methods

Dear all,

Whether a workmen who is injured severely because of not following company safety rules and regulations can be punished?  Please provide me any SC or HC judgments regarding this issue.

 

VIJAY



Learning

 10 Replies

SURESH GODBOLE (ADVOCATE)     28 October 2011

Has it been proved that he was not following the Safety Rules or circumstances were beyond his control.

Also the Employer provided all the gadgets for upkeep of safety or not

0-9929596546

VIJAYAKUMAR (Asst.Manager Lega)     28 October 2011

It was proved that the worker was not following the Safety Rules

SURESH GODBOLE (ADVOCATE)     28 October 2011

Who proved it ,

Was training imparted to him

Are witnesses there to say he did not follow

Was he insured being employed in hazardous job

Is it NECESSARY TO INSURE SUCH EMPLOYEES WHO ARE ON HAZARDOUS JOBS

Several; questions to be answered

0-9929596546

VIJAYAKUMAR (Asst.Manager Lega)     29 October 2011

It was proved beyond reasonable doubt in domestic enquiry by covering all the points mentioned by you. As a labour law practioner,  I know very well the procedure to be followed. I want to know only the judgments of HC and SC in this regard.

 

VIJAY

SURESH GODBOLE (ADVOCATE)     29 October 2011

go to Sup Court /High Court Official Website and browse subjectwise , you will get catena of judgements

rajesh kantubhukta (officer)     31 October 2011

d/sir,

if any employee negligenty damage the company property or any thing in the plant premises he will be liable to bare damages. refer to the company certified standing orders act then we conduct domestic enquiry under the natural justice then we justify the same. 

regards

RAJESH KANTUBHUKTA

HR & ADMIN

SURESH GODBOLE (ADVOCATE)     31 October 2011

Many aspects in this :-

                 (i) Negligence

                (ii) Overworked

                (iii) Compulsion to work for long hours

                (iv) Intentional

                (v) Unintentional

                (vi) Lack of concentration due to performing multliplicity of Work bestowed on him

                (vii) Bestowed on him extra work without his consent

                 (viii) The Domestic enquiry will be tilted towards the management

                (ix) History of service rendered by him

                (x) Was it first instance of loss caused due to him or many such instances before

                 (xi) Amount of Loss

                 (xii) his salary and his capacity to pay

                  (xiii) Due and fair opportunity given to him to defend

                 many more questions to be answered

                Were they discussed point by point , if raised , and conclusions given

             


(Guest)

Dear Vijayakumar,

 

Why do you need HC/SC judgment when misconduct is very clear on the part of the worker that goes against the company's set safety rules/methods?

VIJAYAKUMAR (Asst.Manager Lega)     02 November 2011

Dear Sir,

We are going to punish a worker who is severly injured because of his own safety violations.  So we want to be clear, whether the injured workman can be punished?

 

VIJAY

kameswarao S (Head HR)     19 January 2012

Dear Vijaykumar,

You are confident that the worker violated all the safety norms and it is being proved in the domestic enquiry. To set a norm better to take the action, if you know the judgements or not some one will suggest him to proceed legally and he is going to challenge.

In due course you need to defend / deploy a lawyer so that he can take care of the activity.

Regards - kamesh


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register