Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

kilimanjaro (md)     24 July 2016

A decree or order may be executed either by the family cour

 A decree or order may be executed either by the Family Court which passed it or by the other Family Court or ordinary Civil Court to which it is sent for execution".

 

The above lines are from one of the citation i got online . Regarding the custody case.

 

Why this is such a big issue ? if a family court can order then it should order, Its so confusing to say either the family court which gave order or where it has been sent for orders ?

 

my execution orders are in karnataka and children are in mumbai

Can i file crp 227 in high court for execution orders ?

 

The term where child ordinarily resides in many citations have clearly mentioned it as the place where the child was born raised lived and went to school , Just because the parent shifted for their own reason will not make any other place as the ordinarily residing place of the child.

in my case for the execution petition , The judge sent multiple summons and after which paper publication and finally judge agreed saying posted for orders , in the last hearing judge is saying , she cannot give orders considering jurisdiction ? So the judge never opened the petition so far and read only after saying posted for orders the judge read the petition ?   What is the best solution for this again i do not want to waste one year for the execution petition in mumbai court ?     

In this view it is very clear that the child ordinary residence is karnataka and not mumbai then why do i have to file execution in mumbai ?​

 

 

Any help or suggestions appreciated 



Learning

 11 Replies

P. Venu (Advocate)     25 July 2016

What is the opinion of your advocate?

kilimanjaro (md)     26 July 2016

Originally posted by : P. Venu
What is the opinion of your advocate?

He got his fees so not much bothered about it , i have to call him and remind him my case hearing date. unfortunately i trusted this advocate and been with his so far bcoz technically he is ok .

His answer is lets see whats going to happen .

Some even suggested me to file a writ petition in high court under article 227 for which my lawyer said it cannot be done such way.

Due to the fault of the judge i my one year is wasted in the execution petition and now if its transfered to another state again i have to go thru the complete procudure and spend one more year .

Sanjay Gautam (Advocate)     31 July 2016

your question is not clear. Have you filed the execution petition in the karnatka family court which had passed the decree? if yes then you need to see what you get by execution of the order? does the court have jurisdiction to get what you are looking for? if no then you need to move an application to transfer your execution order to the court in which your purpose can be solved. The court would do the same as per law applicable but all those depend on the decree and your execution petition. 

kilimanjaro (md)     31 July 2016

Originally posted by : Sanjay Gautam
your question is not clear. Have you filed the execution petition in the karnatka family court which had passed the decree? if yes then you need to see what you get by execution of the order? does the court have jurisdiction to get what you are looking for? if no then you need to move an application to transfer your execution order to the court in which your purpose can be solved. The court would do the same as per law applicable but all those depend on the decree and your execution petition. 

I filed for the execution in the karnataka court and judge sent summons and after 4 summons party didnt appear so judge gave orders for paper publication and after that judge said posted for order and gave a date

 

In the next hearing date i went to the court , judge was asking ? why did you file this in karnataka ? so the judge never opened the execution petition and read it properly 

How can the judge be so careless , I have waited for 10 months and now this transfer to the other state and follow the same procedure ? another 10 months be gone ?

 

 

Sanjay Gautam (Advocate)     31 July 2016

please clarify what is the relief in the decree? 

kilimanjaro (md)     31 July 2016

Originally posted by : Sanjay Gautam
please clarify what is the relief in the decree? 

 

Thank you for your response sir

My Gwop petition was set exparte in karnataka court , i tried getting my children but my wife denied and using political and police to threaten me 

So i applied for execution petition for my gwop 

The prayer in that is to secure my children from my wife and hand over the custody to me as im the legal guardian 

 

 

Sanjay Gautam (Advocate)     31 July 2016

there are some options available for you instead of transfering the execution in the present court but the same can not be excercised unless have full knowledge of the petition and the decree and your execution petition. so better you consult with your advocate and explore the options available to you at the present court. 

kilimanjaro (md)     31 July 2016

The lawyer has got his full fees , So im sure he is not working much , I spoke to him two days aga , he said we can only request under section 9 and cant do anything

I even suggested him to file a writ petition under article 227 for which my lawyer said it will be dismissed.

Sir could you provie me other options to secure my children without getting this case transfered ?

Habus corpus will not work as i see most of such case judge order mother to retain custody

kilimanjaro (md)     31 July 2016

the prayer in the execution decree is quite simple

 

Based on the exparte order the petioner has the full court order to be the guardian , hence kindly secure the children from respondent to the petitioner. 

Sanjay Gautam (Advocate)     02 August 2016

Please understand, the execution can not be effective if you can not get your children as per the decree, the present court has no jurisdiction as your children is living in different jurisdiction hence move an application u/s 38 and 39 of CPC to transfer the execution proceeding to the jurisdiction in which your children is living at present in the present scenario. what ever be the procedure of the court in the new jurisdiction you need to follow

kilimanjaro (md)     02 August 2016

Do i have to spend same amount of time  or the court to which if the case gets transfered will consider a speedy trial ? or i have to follow same amount of multiple summons paper publication and then for orders ?


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register